Review: Who's Better ? Roberto Carlos or Marcelo

I always have Roberto Carlos my 1b to Maldini's 1a of greatest ever left backs in the history of football.

So for me to say Marcelo is better I would have to put him in that conversation as well and i don't think I am ready nor is it justified to do so as yet.

 

what a golden era of footballers that was...

 

It reminds me of skaters in the 80s, each had a distinct style. By the mid 90s however skateboarding was mostly just technical skills with much less emphasis on style. Soccer players today are much harder to identify as the personalities on the ball aren't as obvious. I do appreciate technical ability, just not robots like you see on these stupid YouTube videos who lack any personality.

 

Roberto Carlos without a doubt. I love Marcelo but RC is the GOAT wingback. Hes the archetype that set a standard in that position which hasnt been attained since hum. Marcelo is a better playmaker, and that fact makes him very unorthodox threat, but the bulk of playmaking is still the midfield's job. As a fullback Roberto had everything you need, his shooting, speed and flair was just spectacular. Marcelo adds so much to the team, but Roberto added even more.