Where does MLS stand as a league??

Discussion in 'MLS: Rumors' started by goussoccer, Jan 24, 2008.

  1. goussoccer

    goussoccer Member+

    May 23, 2001
    Avon, CT
    Quite often we tend to answer that question in terms of the level of play, however, recent events (at least in Revs land) make me think of this in different terms. What does it mean to MLS when Pat Noonan can earn more than $400K in Norway and Andy Dorman can go to a team that draws about 4,500 people and earn north of $200K per year? Both amounts are WELL beyond what they would be earning in MLS. While the SPL is known for Celtic and Rangers, St. Mirren isn't exactly a UEFA regular.

    I think this plays well beyond the Revs. Both of them were better than average I would think, but neither were stars. With these kind of wages out there in the 'world market' for these kinds of players, the MLS may become a feeder league like it or not - OR - they are going to have to get some serious money into the game to be able to significantly increase the salaries.
     
  2. Sachin

    Sachin New Member

    Jan 14, 2000
    La Norte
    Club:
    DC United
    Can we move this to General?

    MLS stands in the place where it lives.
     
  3. goussoccer

    goussoccer Member+

    May 23, 2001
    Avon, CT
    Do you want me to just restart it over in General, or can you move it? I'm fine with either.
     
  4. Sachin

    Sachin New Member

    Jan 14, 2000
    La Norte
    Club:
    DC United
    A friendly moderator (i.e. not me) will be along to move it. We're just here for the ride. :)

    Sachin
     
  5. Matrim55

    Matrim55 Member+

    Aug 14, 2000
    Berkeley
    Club:
    Connecticut
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Now face north.
     
  6. WFU03

    WFU03 Member

    Sep 8, 2004
    Singapore
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    I think it stands just North of Mexico.

    In the short run:
    I'm also completely unconcerned with losing players to Norway. If the Norwegian clubs wish to pay more, good for them. I imagine their scouting in the US is much better than their scouting in Latin America. More than likely, MLS clubs can simply sign an equivalent player for less money from Latin America.

    In the long run:
    We won't really lose any players we want to keep to Norwegian clubs. Our attendances dwarf theirs as does the market size. Norway has 4.7 million people. The US alone has 300 million. In 5-10 years, we will never lose a player that an MLS club actually wants to keep.
     
  7. SeaOtter

    SeaOtter Member

    Nov 7, 2006
    Atlanta, GA
    Club:
    Fulham FC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Noonan may be getting a huge pay raise when you just look at the salaries, but when you start looking at cost of living (don't know if the club pay his room and board) in Norway, he'll need a lot of that money. Norway is pretty friggin' expensive.
     
  8. Hansadyret

    Hansadyret Member

    Feb 20, 2007
    Bergen, Norway
    Club:
    SK Brann Bergen
    It's not that expensive at all if you compare the salaries to the cost of living. Housing in Aalesund will not cost much, it's not big city prices. It's a city of just over 40 000. Noonan can save up much of his salary and still have a good living. Incredible that a club in such a small market can pay that much to it's players. Being a free agent helps a lot.
     
  9. guamster

    guamster Member+

    Mar 30, 2001
    Winnetka, CA
    Club:
    --other--
    Nat'l Team:
    Guam
    Think about direction
    Wonder why you haven't before
    Now stand in the place where you work...
     
  10. goussoccer

    goussoccer Member+

    May 23, 2001
    Avon, CT
    I think the drain on MLS will be bigger than represented so far here. In a strange way, MLS' reputation has gotten strong enough that other leagues are going to start giving it a serious look. So, if our financial structure is not in line with theirs we are going to be subject to them 'picking off' our talent. As players see this, fewer of them are going to sign long-term contracts - or may even pull an EJ and put 'buy-out clauses' in their contracts. Hence, if we don't get the corporate sponsorships, the big money behind the MLS relatively soon, I think we could be in for some surprises. Market size is NOT the issue, realization of value in that market is the issue. There is a balance here between skill level and financial competitiveness on the world market: true professionals will go to where the money is (especially when we are talking about factors of 2-3 times.) There were only so many of our players that would be drawn into the top four leagues, but if you open it to the next two or three leagues below them, then what??
     
  11. The Blind Pig

    The Blind Pig Member

    Jul 14, 2005
    Section 8
    I beg to differ. I believe MLS stands in the place where it exists.
     
  12. Matt12

    Matt12 Member

    Nov 26, 2007
    Trondheim
    Club:
    Rosenborg BK
    Here is some info about the norwegain league that i posted a wile ago on anoter thread. Hope that helps your comperison.

    Norway has a population of sligthly below 5 million 4.8 - 4.9 million i think.
    But not all of the population has easy acess to top divison fotball.
    Cause wile the population migth be tiny comperd to the larger countrys in europe the land area is sligtly larger then germany.

    When it comes to attendance these were the avereage number for the top lvl teams last year

    1 Rosenborg 19903
    2 Brann 17225
    3 Viking 15846
    4 Vålerenga 13835
    5 Fredrikstad 11798
    6 Start 11216
    7 Aalesund 10475
    8 Lillestrøm 9018
    9 Lyn 7616
    10 Sif 6807
    11 Sandefjord 6098
    12 Tromsø 6053
    13 Odd 5795
    14 Stabæk 5570

    man Rosenborg just missed the 20000 mark :(

    Population of the diffrent towns with first divison teams in 2007

    Oslo (Lyn and Vålerenga) 557,052
    Bergen (Brann) 247,123
    Trondheim (Rosenborg) 164,245
    Stavanger (Viking) 119,176
    Bærum (Stabæk) 108 033
    Kristiandsand (Start) 78 585
    Fredrikstad (Fredrikstad) 71 784
    Drammen (Sif) 59 758
    Tromsø (Tromsø) 65 089
    Skien (Odd) 50 736
    Skedsmo (Lillestrøm) 45 777
    Sandefjord (Sandefjord) 42 214
    Ålesund (Ålesund) 41 774


    This was the planed budget for the diffrent teams for the 2007 season (inclued supports staff and oter expenses not only player salarys)

    First Divison

    Rosenborg 34,4 million dollar
    Brann 20,0 million dollar (champion)
    Lillestrøm 18,6 million dollar
    Vålerenga 18,6 million dollar
    Start 18,6 million dollar (relegated)
    Fredrikstad 18,6 million dollar
    Viking 17,7 million dollar
    Aalesund 11,9 million dollar
    Lyn 9,4 million dollar
    Tromsø 9,3 million dollar
    Strømsgodset 9,3 million dollar
    Stabæk 8,4 million dollar
    Odd Grenland 7,4 million dollar (relegated)
    Sandefjord 6,5 million dollar (relegated)

    Second Divison

    Molde 9,3 million dollar (promoted)
    HamKam 6,5 million dollar (promoted)
    Bodø/Glimt 5,6 million dollar (promoted)
    Bryne 4,2 million dollar
    Notodden 3,7 million dollar
    Sogndal 3,7 million dollar
    Haugesund 3,4 million dollar
    Moss 2,8 million dollar
    Hønefoss 2,8 million dollar
    Raufoss 2,5 million dollar
    Skeid 2,3 million dollar (relegated)
    Sparta 1,9 million dollar (relegated)
    Mandal 1,8 million dollar (relegated)
    Kongsvinger 1,7 million dollar
    Løv Ham 1,3 million dollar
    Tromsdalen 0,9 million dollar (relegated)

    The tv deal for the 2 top divisons was sold for about 182 million dollars for a 3 year periode.
     
  13. WFU03

    WFU03 Member

    Sep 8, 2004
    Singapore
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Based upon your expense figures, Rosenborg and Start had terrible seasons.

    Final standings:
    1. 54 pts Brann
    2. 48 pts Stabæk
    3. 47 pts Viking
    4. 44 pts Lillestrøm (plus Cup title)
    5. 41 pts Rosenborg
    6. 40 pts Tromsø
    7. 36 pts Vålerenga
    8. 36 pts Frederikstad
    9. 34 pts Lyn
    10. 30 pts Strømsgodset
    11. 30 pts Aalesund
    12. 27 pts Odd Grenland
    13. 26 pts Start
    14. 16 pts Sandefjord

    Sum: (Spending Rank - Final Position):
    1. Stabæk 10 (12-2)
    2. Tromsø 4 (10-6)
    3. Viking 4 (7-3)
    4. Odd Grenland 1 (13-12)
    5. Lyn 1 (9-8)
    6. Brann 1 (2-1)
    7. Sandefjord 0 (14-14)
    8. Strømsgodset 0 (10-10)
    9. Lillestrøm 0 (4-4)
    10. Aalesund -3 (8-11)
    11. Vålerenga -3 (4-7)
    12. Frederikstad -4 (4-8)
    13. Rosenborg -4 (1-5)
    14. Start -9 (4-13)

    Also, just by looking at the expense figures, you can tell why the Norwegian league can currently outbid US teams for good but not great players. It's primarily because of the TV contract.
     
  14. Matt12

    Matt12 Member

    Nov 26, 2007
    Trondheim
    Club:
    Rosenborg BK
    hmm yes the dp players in MLS probebly earn more then any player in ouer league

    average pay is about 200K dollars

    higest is about 1 million dollars.

    As for Start and Rosenborg yes the season was terribel.

    Rosenborg really do have a very good squad as seen in CL but many players are young and well ouer defense was very unstabel last year hopefully we will get a few new players there and have a better season next year.
     
  15. WFU03

    WFU03 Member

    Sep 8, 2004
    Singapore
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    I would also try to keep opposing goalkeepers from scoring on your team this year. :eek:

    I happened to catch that game while visiting this summer.
     
  16. Matt12

    Matt12 Member

    Nov 26, 2007
    Trondheim
    Club:
    Rosenborg BK
    :p thanks mate, really wanted to be reminded of that.
     
  17. triplet1

    triplet1 BigSoccer Supporter

    Jul 25, 2006
    Some good stuff Matt. Do you have a guess as to how much of the budget goes for player salaries?
     
  18. Nico Limmat

    Nico Limmat Member+

    Oct 24, 1999
    Dubai, UAE
    Club:
    Grasshopper Club Zürich
    Nat'l Team:
    Switzerland
    Current Austrian Bundesliga budgets:

    Red Bull Salzburg - USD 51.5 million
    FK Austria Wien - USD 22 million
    SK Rapid Wien - USD 16.2 million
    LASK Linz - USD 10.6 million
    SV Mattersburg - USD 9.6 million
    SK Sturm Graz - USD 8.8 million
    SK Austria Kärnten - USD 8.8 million
    FC Wacker Innsbruck - USD 7.7 million
    SV Ried - USD 6.8 million
    SCR Altach - USD 6.6 million

    Austria Kärnten bought Ngwenya and Jaqua is on trial at Altach.
     
  19. Matt12

    Matt12 Member

    Nov 26, 2007
    Trondheim
    Club:
    Rosenborg BK
    only guessing but 50-60% maybe.

    Maye more for the smaller team as they probebly don`t have youth academys and as much support staff and adminestrators.
     
  20. triplet1

    triplet1 BigSoccer Supporter

    Jul 25, 2006

    I can't give you a link, but perhaps you can confirm it SwissGCZ. The current issue of World Soccer (page 58) indicates that FC Basel has the highest budget in Switzerland at £14 million -- roughly USD 27.6 million. Does that sound about right?
     
  21. Nico Limmat

    Nico Limmat Member+

    Oct 24, 1999
    Dubai, UAE
    Club:
    Grasshopper Club Zürich
    Nat'l Team:
    Switzerland
    Yep, sounds about right.
     
  22. triplet1

    triplet1 BigSoccer Supporter

    Jul 25, 2006
    Are there some extraordinary expenses in these budgets? For example, I wonder if the Salzburg and Rosenborg budgets have some stadium renovation costs included, which explains why they are so much greater than the rest of their respective leagues.
     
  23. Matt12

    Matt12 Member

    Nov 26, 2007
    Trondheim
    Club:
    Rosenborg BK
    nope that is there regular budgets. and because they did well in CL i think rosenborgs ended up been about 50 million dollars.
     
  24. BrannSupporter2

    BrannSupporter2 New Member

    Feb 1, 2008
    Bergen
    In SK Brann ( current champs in Norway) Base pay is 200K us$. The highest payed player today is Erik Huseklepp who will recieve 2 mill us$ over 3 years, tho this also included sign-on-fee. Most valuable player is Håkon Opdal ( also national team keeper ) who is worth an estimated ( by Brann) 5-8 mill us$.
    Its expected that a player investment company will spend 7-10 mill us$ during the summer transfer period on either one or two players for Brann.
     

Share This Page