I used to live in Paint Lick, KY. I was disappointed to see it didn't make it. Chicken, Alaska is pretty weird, too.
Rough and Ready, California Well, truth be told it's the Republic of Rough and Ready. They seceeded from the United States back in 1850 for three months. http://www.roughandreadychamber.com/secession.html
Newfoundland has loads: Come by Chance Cow head Joe Batt's Arm Snooks Arm The Beaches Three Rock Cove Cape Cove Dildo Mosquito Little Heart's Ease
Smackover, Arkansas. Our local high school used to play against them in football...we had some great signs at the games for them.
Fishkill, NY ------------------------------------------ Others that I always found amusing, but not in the order of those above.. Poland, Greece, Cuba, Rome, NY Montezuma, IA
There's always these classics: Boring, Oregon Peculiar, Missouri And my favorite West Ely, Missouri Not because the name is unusual, but because it is 5 miles east of Ely, Missouri.....
A couple from my home state. Gas, KS Greenbush, KS ---wouldn't it suck if you're getting ready to hook up with a lady, you look down and she has green bush
Coalinga, CA. People say it with a Spanish accent ("co-a-LING-a") but it was actually named after a train station where the old steam trains could pick up more fuel: Coaling Station A. The "Station" was dropped from the name and it became Coalinga. Tarzana, CA. Named after the fictional character Tarzan.
King of Prussia, PA My faves from Pennsylvania Dutch country ... Blueball Bird-in-Hand Intercourse Paradise
And don't forget Western PA, where we have not one but TWO towns called "Oklahoma," about 80 miles from one another. Not to mention a town called Eighty Four. I always thought "Montezuma, Iowa" was funny, since the exit from route 80 is also the exit for Tama, Iowa. So if you're bored (as you no doubt will be, driving on I-80) you can start imagining a person named Tama Montezuma. Has anyone mentioned Cut And Shoot, Texas yet?
There's... Florida, NY Big Flats, NY Accident, MD California, PA Mars, PA Panic, PA Desire, PA State College, PA Hardscrabble, DE