'96 MLS Supporters' Shield: Tampa Bay Mutiny '96 MLS Cup: D.C. United '96 U.S. Open Cup: D.C. United '97 MLS Supporters' Shield: D.C. United '97 MLS Cup: D.C. United '97 U.S. Open Cup: Dallas Burn '98 MLS Supporters' Shield: L.A. Galaxy '98 MLS Cup: Chicago Fire '98 U.S. Open Cup: Chicago Fire '99 MLS Supporters' Shield: D.C. United '99 MLS Cup: D.C. United '99 U.S. Open Cup: Rochester Raging Rhinos '00 MLS Supporters' Shield: K.C. Wizards '00 MLS Cup: K.C. Wizards '00 U.S. Open Cup: Chicago Fire '01 MLS Supporters' Shield: Miami Fusion '01 MLS Cup: San Jose Earthquakes '01 U.S. Open Cup: L.A. Galaxy '02 MLS Supporters' Shield: L.A. Galaxy '02 MLS Cup: L.A. Galaxy '02 U.S. Open Cup: Columbus Crew '03 MLS Supporters' Shield: Chicago Fire '03 MLS Cup: San Jose Earthquakes '03 U.S. Open Cup: Chicago Fire '04 MLS Supporters' Shield: Columbus Crew '04 MLS Cup: D.C. United '04 U.S. Open Cup: K.C. Wizards Titles, by team D.C. United: 7 Chicago Fire: 5 L.A. Galaxy: 4 K.C. Wizards: 3 San Jose Earthquakes: 2 Columbus Crew: 2 Dallas Burn: 1 Miami Fusion: 1 Tampa Bay Mutiny: 1 Rochester Raging Rhinos: 1 (A-League) MLS Supporters' Shields, by team D.C. United: 2 L.A. Galaxy: 2 Chicago Fire: 1 Miami Fusion: 1 K.C. Wizards: 1 Tampa Bay Mutiny: 1 Columbus Crew: 1 MLS Cup, by team D.C. United: 4 San Jose Earthquakes: 2 Chicago Fire: 1 K.C. Wizards: 1 L.A. Galaxy: 1 U.S. Open Cup, by team Chicago Fire: 3 D.C. United: 1 L.A. Galaxy: 1 Dallas Burn: 1 Rochester Raging Rhinos: 1 (A-League) Columbus Crew: 1 K.C. Wizards: 1 Teams with no titles (Finals played in) New England Revolution ('01 U.S. Open Cup, '02 MLS Cup) Colorado Rapids ('97 MLS Cup, '99 U.S. Open Cup) MetroStars ('03 U.S. Open Cup
I suspect it has something to do with this thread ... https://www.bigsoccer.com/forum/showthread.php?t=170240
if anyone's wondering... the thread in my sig is to a slightly different titles thread than this one... the link takes you to one that entails 3 extra titles won by dc and la which has me thinking of another idea