"Bild" vs. "Kicker-Sportmagazin" Comparison of Grades 1965-1977

Discussion in 'Soccer History' started by Gregoriak, Jan 6, 2016.

  1. Gregoriak

    Gregoriak BigSoccer Supporter

    Feb 27, 2002
    Bolzplatz
    #1 Gregoriak, Jan 6, 2016
    Last edited: Jan 6, 2016
    The following is a comparison between the Top 3 highest-rated Bundesliga players of "Sportmagazin" respectively "kicker-sportmagazin" (the two magazines merged in October 1968) and Germany's biggest tabloid "Bild", which entertains a big sports section.

    "Sportmagazin"/"Kicker-Sportmagazin"rated players using the following method:

    1 = best
    5 = worst

    "Bild" did it like this:

    6 = world class
    5 = international class
    4 = strong
    3 = fair average
    2 = modest
    1 = very bad
    0 = didn't earn his money

    1965-66

    Sportmagazin

    1.40 Josef Marx
    1.58 Josef Maier (GK)
    1.67 Franz Beckenbauer

    Bild

    4.42 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.17 Max Lorenz
    4.17 Günter Netzer
    4.17 Willi Schulz

    1966-67

    Sportmagazin

    1.66 Horst Wolter (GK)
    1.67 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.79 Josef Maier (GK)

    Bild

    4.45 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.22 Horst Wolter (GK)
    4.20 Willi Schulz

    1967-68

    Sportmagazin

    1.52 Joachim Bäse
    1.74 Günter Netzer
    1.74 Hans-Hubert Vogts

    Bild

    4.27 Joachim Bäse
    4.11 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.08 Hans-Hubert Vogts

    1968-69

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.58 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.65 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    1.71 Volkmar Gross (GK)

    Bild

    4.50 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.35 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    4.33 Günter Netzer

    1969-70

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.50 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.82 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    1.85 Josef Maier (GK)

    Bild

    4.74 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.24 Günter Netzer
    4.18 Hans-Hubert Vogts

    1970-71

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.76 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.91 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    1.94 Günter Netzer

    Bild

    4.39 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.31 Günter Netzer
    4.15 Hans-Hubert Vogts

    1971-72

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.91 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.93 Günter Netzer
    2.03 Norbert Nigbur (GK)

    Bild

    4.45 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.21 Günter Netzer
    4.15 Jürgen Grabowski

    1972-73

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.82 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    1.85 Bernd Franke (GK)
    1.88 Franz Beckenbauer

    Bild

    4.41 Franz Beckenbauer
    3.91 Josef Maier (GK)
    3.84 Gerhard Müller

    1973-74

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.79 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.88 Norbert Nigbur (GK)
    2.00 Franz-Josef Pauly (GK)

    Bild

    4.30 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.00 Jürgen Grabowski
    3.88 Paul Breitner
    3.88 Bernd Hölzenbein

    1974-75

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.79 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    1.88 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.97 Jürgen Grabowski

    Bild

    4.12 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.06 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    3.97 Willi Lippens

    1975-76

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.79 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    1.88 Franz Beckenbauer
    1.97 Bernard Dietz

    Bild

    4.24 Franz Beckenbauer
    4.06 Hans-Hubert Vogts
    3.94 Jürgen Grabowski

    1976-77

    Kicker-Sportmagazin

    1.65 Volkmar Gross (GK)
    1.88 Bernd Franke (GK)
    1.96 Hans-Hubert Vogts

    Bild

    4.18 Volkmar Gross (GK)
    4.06 Franz Beckenbauer
    3.97 Jürgen Grabowski
     

Share This Page