Another all-time challenge

Discussion in 'The Beautiful Game' started by comme, Nov 24, 2004.

  1. PDG1978

    PDG1978 Member+

    Mar 8, 2009
    Club:
    Nottingham Forest FC
    ----------------------Tomaszewski-----------------

    Sivebaek---------Grun-------------Helmer-------Zhirkhov

    ---------Martin Vazquez---Y.Toure-------Iniesta--------

    -----------------Lubanski-------------Piantoni----------
    ----------------------------Ademir---------------------
     
  2. PDG1978

    PDG1978 Member+

    Mar 8, 2009
    Club:
    Nottingham Forest FC
    Goalkeepers: Banks, Beara, Bento, Buffon, Campos, Carbajal, Cech, Chilavert, Clemence, Dasayev, Fillol, Gilmar, Grosics, Goycochea, Jennings, Kahn, Keller, Maier, Máspoli, Mazurkiewicz, Pagliuca, Pfaff, Planicka, Preud'homme, Schmeichel, Schumacher, Seaman, Shilton, Southall, Taffarel, Toldo, Tomaszewski, Trautmann, Van Der Sar, Viktor, Yashin, Zamora, Zenga, Zoff, Zubizaretta

    Right Backs: Andrade, Armfield, Babbel, Battiston, Bergmark, Bergomi, Burgnich, Cafú, Carey, Carlos Alberto, Dixon, Djalma Santos, Djorkaeff, Ferrer, Gentile, Gerets, Pannuci, Petrescu, João Pinto, Reuter, Rob Jones, Jorginho, Josimar, Kaltz, Leandro, Leonardo, McGrain, Nasazzi, Neal, Neville, Nelinho, Sivebaek, Suurbier, Szymanowski, Thuram, Vogts, Zambrotta, J Zanetti

    Centrebacks: T.Adams, P.Albert, Aldair, Allemandi, Augenthaler, R. Ayala, Baresi, Beckenbauer, Belodidici, Blanc, Bratseth, Campbell, Cannavaro, R.Carvalho, Chumpitaz, I. Córdoba, Costacurta, Darío Pereyra, de Boer , Desailly, Domingos da Guía, Edmilson, Ferdinand, Ferrara, Ferri, Figueroa, Förster, Gallas, Gamarra, Germano, Gorgon, Grun, Hansen, Happel, Helguera, Helmer, Hierro, E. Hughes, Hulshoff, Hyypia, Jonquet, Julio Cesar, Katalinski, M.Keown, Koeman, Kohler, Krol, Kuffour, Lalas, Lawrenson, Lorant, Luiz Pereira, Manuel Sanchis, Marcio Santos, McGrath, Miller, Montero, Moore, Nesta, M. Olsen, Ondrus, Passarella, Perfumo, Pique, Rijkaard, Ruggeri, Santamaría, Schesternev, Schwarzenbeck, Scirea, Stam, Terry, K.Toure, Tresor, Varela, Vidic, Vierchowod, Walker, Wright, Zmuda,

    Left Backs: Amoros, Bossis, Brehme, Breitner, Briegel, Byrne, Cabrini, Camacho, Candela, Demianenko, Dimas, Facchetti, Haan, Hapgood, Hilário, Irwin, Jarni, Júnior, Júnior (82), Lahm, Lerby, Lizarazu, Maldini, Marche, Marzolini, Meléndez, Nilton Santos, Roberto Carlos, Schnellinger, Sergi, Tarantini, P. Thompson, van Tiggelen, R. Wilson, N. Winterburn, Zhirkhov

    Defensive Midfielders: Blanchflower, Bozsik, Bremner, Clodoaldo, Copping, Davids, Deschamps, De Rossi, Dino Baggio, Dunga, Edwards, Gattuso, Kasperczak, Keane, Mackay, Makelele, Masopust, Matthäus, Monti, Oliseh, Onopko, Neeskens, Netto, Ocwirk, Paulo Sousa, Y Toure, Petit, Rattin, Redondo, Simeone, Toninho Cerezo, Victor Andrade, Vieira, Wouters, Zito,

    Central Midfielders: Antognoni, Ardiles, Bertoni, Boban, Bohinen, Cajú, Challe, Charlton, Coluna, Di Stéfano, Effenberg, Falcão, Gascoigne, A.Gemmill, Gerrard, Giannini, Giresse, Guardiola, Hassler, Hoddle, Iniesta, Kaka, Letchkov, Liedholm, Martin Vazquez, Nyilasi, Okocha, Prosinecki, Robson, Rosicky, N.Rossi, Rui Costa, Sammer, Schuster, Socrates, Souness, Stojkovic, Tardelli, Tigana, Van Hanegem, Veron, Xavi

    Right Midfielders: Beckham, Bene, Blokhin, Conti, Donadoni, Finney, Garrincha, Gren, Gullit, Hanappi, Johnstone, Julinho, Kanchelskis, Lato, Matthews, Míchel, Netzer, Overmars, C.Ronaldo, Simonsen, Waddle, Zico

    Left Midfielders: Barnes, Baxter, Boniek, Ceulemans, Czibor, Dzajic, Futre, Gento, Gérson, Giggs, Ginola, Keizer, Maradona, Nedved, Overath, Pires, Rivelino, Robertson, Schiaffino, Signori, Suarez, Fritz Walter, White, Zidane

    Offensive Midfielders: Abedi Pelé, Aimar, Brady, Brolin, Bochini, Caniggia, Cubilla, Cueto, Deco, Deyna, Didí, Francescoli, Hagi, Hatzipanagis, B.Laudrup, M.Laudrup, S Mazzola, V Mazzola, Messi, Mostovoi, Pelé, Platini, Rivaldo, Rivera, Ronaldinho, Savicevic, Scholes, Scifo, Sívori, Sobeck, Suárez, Susic, Valderrama

    Second Strikers: Albert, Amancio, Arshavin, Baggio, Bebeto, Bergkamp, Bican, Cruyff, Dalglish, Del Piero, Figo, Gonsalves, Hidegkuti, A.James, Hamrin, Kempes, Kopa, Kubala, Litmanen, Lubanski, Mancini, Piantoni, Robinho, Six, Stoitchkov, Tostao, Totti, Uribe, Zola

    Strikers: Ademir, Batistuta, Best, Boksic, Cantona, Careca, Charles, Coutinho, Cubillas, Elkjaer, Erico, Eusebio, Fontaine, Greaves, Henry, A. Jackson, Jairzinho, Law, Lawton, Leónidas, Lineker, Littbarski, Lofthouse, Klinsmann, Kócsis, Larrson, McGrory, Meazza, Milla, Moreno, Müller, Nordahl, Papin, Pedernera, Peyroteo, Piola, Puskas, Raul, Reinaldo, Rensenbrink, Rep, Rial, Romário, Ronaldo, P. Rossi, Rummenigge, Rush, H. Sanchez, Seeler, Shearer, Shevchenko, Sindelar, Spencer, Streltsov, Suker, van Basten, Van Nistelrooy, Vialli, Voller, Weah, Wilkes, Wright, Zamorano, Zizinho
     
  3. JamesBH11

    JamesBH11 Member+

    Sep 17, 2004
    There are alot of mixed up position for players ...(bold)
    (Best, Zairzinho, Charles, Rensenbrinks ) are not strikers.
    Maradona, Zico, Zidane, Rivelino, Walter would be offensive midfielder rather than a left or right mid.
    Di Stefano, Pele are more of forward/2nd striker than midfielder.
     
  4. PDG1978

    PDG1978 Member+

    Mar 8, 2009
    Club:
    Nottingham Forest FC
    Yeah I think the players are listed according to where they were picked in these teams rather than their best positions eg on page 1 Pele is in the first team playing along with Maradona and Di Stefano, in front of Bozsik. Athough Maradona has ended up listed as a left midfielder - I'd have to look back through the thread to see when that happened. I had Kaka as a central mid in a very attacking team. Neeskens was picked as the anchor mid in one of the first teams, also on page 1 I think. Djorkaeff is not Youri but Jean Djorkaeff, who played in the 50's I think.
     
  5. JamesBH11

    JamesBH11 Member+

    Sep 17, 2004
    Well technically, Maradona, Cruyff, Pele, Zico, Di Stefano, Falcao, Rivelino ... could play almost anywhere in midfield. For example, Pele, Di Stefano and Cruyff could also play very well in defense but it's a CRIME to put them in such position! Or since Maradona is a leftfooter, so either he is at central or on the right (so he can shoot more effectively) rather than on the left (which he was also capable of). Cruyff and Zidane would be either on central or on the left as prefer to their right foot naturally.

    Usually you would see the best midfield all time are (according to their prefer position) - but

    Cruyff ------ Di Stefano ------ Maradona ------- Garrincha

    Forward line All time are often:

    -------- Ronaldo/Eusebio -------------------
    --------------------------- Pele ------------
    or
    ------- Puskas/Cruyff --------- Pele -----------
     
  6. PDG1978

    PDG1978 Member+

    Mar 8, 2009
    Club:
    Nottingham Forest FC
    I'm going to post one final team on this thread (which was the one I found that led me to join Big Soccer). It'll probably be a little trickier for any future posters to construct teams at this stage with the greatest players gone, and over 400 gone in total but there's still plenty of top players left if others want to have a go... players rated extemely highly in their era including currently etc. I haven't checked if all the picks on the All-Time Draft have gone or all the non-sheep from the Shep Draft but I'd be suprised if there weren't a few of them left. Excellent thread anyway, enjoyed reading the teams from the first ones to more recent ones too, and the selections have covered all era's (or most):

    ------------------------Marchegianni--------------------

    Mannini---------England-------------Pallister--------Ziege

    ---------------------------Crerand-----------------------
    ---Rahn------------------Juninho Paulista---------Dirceu----

    ------------------Butragueno---------Crespo----------------
     
  7. PDG1978

    PDG1978 Member+

    Mar 8, 2009
    Club:
    Nottingham Forest FC
    Goalkeepers: Banks, Beara, Bento, Buffon, Campos, Carbajal, Cech, Chilavert, Clemence, Dasayev, Fillol, Gilmar, Grosics, Goycochea, Jennings, Kahn, Keller, Maier, Marchegianni, Máspoli, Mazurkiewicz, Pagliuca, Pfaff, Planicka, Preud'homme, Schmeichel, Schumacher, Seaman, Shilton, Southall, Taffarel, Toldo, Tomaszewski, Trautmann, Van Der Sar, Viktor, Yashin, Zamora, Zenga, Zoff, Zubizaretta

    Right Backs: Andrade, Armfield, Babbel, Battiston, Bergmark, Bergomi, Burgnich, Cafú, Carey, Carlos Alberto, Dixon, Djalma Santos, Djorkaeff, Ferrer, Gentile, Gerets, Pannuci, Petrescu, João Pinto, Reuter, Rob Jones, Jorginho, Josimar, Kaltz, Leandro, Leonardo, Mannini, McGrain, Nasazzi, Neal, Neville, Nelinho, Sivebaek, Suurbier, Szymanowski, Thuram, Vogts, Zambrotta, J Zanetti

    Centrebacks: T.Adams, P.Albert, Aldair, Allemandi, Augenthaler, R. Ayala, Baresi, Beckenbauer, Belodidici, Blanc, Bratseth, Campbell, Cannavaro, R.Carvalho, Chumpitaz, I. Córdoba, Costacurta, Darío Pereyra, de Boer , Desailly, Domingos da Guía, Edmilson, England, Ferdinand, Ferrara, Ferri, Figueroa, Förster, Gallas, Gamarra, Germano, Gorgon, Grun, Hansen, Happel, Helguera, Helmer, Hierro, E. Hughes, Hulshoff, Hyypia, Jonquet, Julio Cesar, Katalinski, M.Keown, Koeman, Kohler, Krol, Kuffour, Lalas, Lawrenson, Lorant, Luiz Pereira, Manuel Sanchis, Marcio Santos, McGrath, Miller, Montero, Moore, Nesta, M. Olsen, Ondrus, Pallister, Passarella, Perfumo, Pique, Rijkaard, Ruggeri, Santamaría, Schesternev, Schwarzenbeck, Scirea, Stam, Terry, K.Toure, Tresor, Varela, Vidic, Vierchowod, Walker, Wright, Zmuda,

    Left Backs: Amoros, Bossis, Brehme, Breitner, Briegel, Byrne, Cabrini, Camacho, Candela, Demianenko, Dimas, Facchetti, Haan, Hapgood, Hilário, Irwin, Jarni, Júnior, Júnior (82), Lahm, Lerby, Lizarazu, Maldini, Marche, Marzolini, Meléndez, Nilton Santos, Roberto Carlos, Schnellinger, Sergi, Tarantini, P. Thompson, van Tiggelen, R. Wilson, N. Winterburn, Zhirkhov, Ziege

    Defensive Midfielders: Blanchflower, Bozsik, Bremner, Clodoaldo, Copping, Crerand, Davids, Deschamps, De Rossi, Dino Baggio, Dunga, Edwards, Gattuso, Kasperczak, Keane, Mackay, Makelele, Masopust, Matthäus, Monti, Oliseh, Onopko, Neeskens, Netto, Ocwirk, Paulo Sousa, Y Toure, Petit, Rattin, Redondo, Simeone, Toninho Cerezo, Victor Andrade, Vieira, Wouters, Zito,

    Central Midfielders: Antognoni, Ardiles, Bertoni, Boban, Bohinen, Cajú, Challe, Charlton, Coluna, Di Stéfano, Effenberg, Falcão, Gascoigne, A.Gemmill, Gerrard, Giannini, Giresse, Guardiola, Hassler, Hoddle, Iniesta, Kaka, Letchkov, Liedholm, Martin Vazquez, Nyilasi, Okocha, Prosinecki, Robson, Rosicky, N.Rossi, Rui Costa, Sammer, Schuster, Socrates, Souness, Stojkovic, Tardelli, Tigana, Van Hanegem, Veron, Xavi

    Right Midfielders: Beckham, Bene, Blokhin, Conti, Donadoni, Finney, Garrincha, Gren, Gullit, Hanappi, Johnstone, Julinho, Kanchelskis, Lato, Matthews, Míchel, Netzer, Overmars, Rahn, C.Ronaldo, Simonsen, Waddle, Zico

    Left Midfielders: Barnes, Baxter, Boniek, Ceulemans, Czibor, Dirceu, Dzajic, Futre, Gento, Gérson, Giggs, Ginola, Keizer, Maradona, Nedved, Overath, Pires, Rivelino, Robertson, Schiaffino, Signori, Suarez, Fritz Walter, White, Zidane

    Offensive Midfielders: Abedi Pelé, Aimar, Brady, Brolin, Bochini, Caniggia, Cubilla, Cueto, Deco, Deyna, Didí, Francescoli, Hagi, Hatzipanagis, Juninho Paulista, B.Laudrup, M.Laudrup, S Mazzola, V Mazzola, Messi, Mostovoi, Pelé, Platini, Rivaldo, Rivera, Ronaldinho, Savicevic, Scholes, Scifo, Sívori, Sobeck, Suárez, Susic, Valderrama

    Second Strikers: Albert, Amancio, Arshavin, Baggio, Bebeto, Bergkamp, Bican, Cruyff, Dalglish, Del Piero, Figo, Gonsalves, Hidegkuti, A.James, Hamrin, Kempes, Kopa, Kubala, Litmanen, Lubanski, Mancini, Piantoni, Robinho, Six, Stoitchkov, Tostao, Totti, Uribe, Zola

    Strikers: Ademir, Batistuta, Best, Boksic, Butragueno, Cantona, Careca, Charles, Coutinho, Crespo, Cubillas, Elkjaer, Erico, Eusebio, Fontaine, Greaves, Henry, A. Jackson, Jairzinho, Law, Lawton, Leónidas, Lineker, Littbarski, Lofthouse, Klinsmann, Kócsis, Larrson, McGrory, Meazza, Milla, Moreno, Müller, Nordahl, Papin, Pedernera, Peyroteo, Piola, Puskas, Raul, Reinaldo, Rensenbrink, Rep, Rial, Romário, Ronaldo, P. Rossi, Rummenigge, Rush, H. Sanchez, Seeler, Shearer, Shevchenko, Sindelar, Spencer, Streltsov, Suker, van Basten, Van Nistelrooy, Vialli, Voller, Weah, Wilkes, Wright, Zamorano, Zizinho
     

Share This Page