https://www.machermanntrophy.org/2021-watch-lists No clear cut choice IMO. How many times have defenders won that? Who do you think wins it this year?
There is no Macario this year. If you go defensive, you would have to get real wonky (apologies to CPT) with in depth stats. Or do ;you go with the best player on one of the best teams. https://www.machermanntrophy.org/winners Looking at the list above, weren't Sullivan and Buchanan Defensive players?
IOW, it's rare for a defender to win the MAC Hermann. This is the type of year where it could happen. No offensive player stands out above everyone else IMO. We'll see!