By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
  1. Bill Archer

    Bill Archer BigSoccer Supporter

    Mar 19, 2002
    Washington, NC
    Club:
    Columbus Crew
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    #1 Bill Archer, Nov 20, 2017
    Last edited: Nov 20, 2017

    Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

    By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
    Nothing says "Major, legitimate, world class sports league" like a nationally televised semi-final playoff game where everyone knows that the owner of one of the contenders - along with the commissioner of the league itself - is hoping his team loses. Nothing even remotely like this has happened since Rachel Phelps owned the Cleveland Indians.

    Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Don Garber, who has screwed the pooch so badly in all of this that they're going to start playing soulful Sarah McLaughlin ballads whenever his face appears on screen.

    As for Fratboy McTrustfund, the man who, according to the Columbus Dispatch, tried to get the statue of Lamar Hunt removed from the plaza in front of the stadium, his unbelievably creepy hatchet man Dave Greeley emailed someone he thought was MLS communications gerbil Dan Courtemanche just prior to the Halloween game in Mapfre vs. NYCFC that "AP" had told him he would "never set foot in Columbus again".

    However, Greeley subsequently told Fratboy that if he didn't show up for his own team's playoff game that his pretense of "even handedness" between CBus and Austin would collapse and everyone would see that the whole "just exploring our options" meme was nothing but a lie.

    So "AP" went to the game, heard thousands of people lustily cursing his miserable ass for 90 minutes and, between that and having to watch the team he wanted so badly to see get crushed post a stunning 4-1 victory over a very good NYCFC side, he didn't seem to be having a very good time.

    The question now is, will he be back on Tuesday to spend a few more hours in the city he has avoided like genital herpes for the last four years - but which he claims he is "open minded" about - or will he finally admit what everybody knows and he might as well stop lying about.

    Either way, Precourt has to take second chair on the Liars Club dais to the man whose lips barely move when Fratboy speaks: "Call Me Soccer Don, That's, Like, So Cool" Garber.

    Now I'm sure that you've read that the big problem in Columbus is attendance. It's being pushed behind the scenes every chance they get by the scurrying media peons at MLS as they feed simpleminded stooges like Taylor Twellman his talking points.

    As an example, they point out that the Halloween playoff game in CBus only drew 14,000 people. Can you imagine? A playoff game. Just goes to show you.

    Well, like they say, you can take your pick who to believe: them or your own lying eyes.

    Here, for comparison sake, is the playoff game in Houston the previous night; MLS tells us that there were 15,600 people in attendance:

    [​IMG]

    And here's "14,000" in Mapfre 24 hours later:

    [​IMG]

    Now some people have suggested that they got the number - which not a single player, former player, journalist, fan or anyone who's ever set foot in the place agrees is even close to accurate (one player has said they all thought it looked like "a sellout") - by taking a turnstile count at kickoff since, unbeknownst to anyone, the "management" decided at the last minute that everyone entering the building had to be individually patted down and no, I'm not going to speculate as to why.

    As a result, hundreds of fans were still waiting patiently in line to get a farewell crotch squeeze from PSV when the game kicked off.

    Now in truth everybody knows that MLS lies about attendance. It's as traditional in The Soccer Don's league as terrible officiating. It's just that normally they OVERstate the turnstile count. In this case, breaking new frontiers of MLS lying, they've clearly UNDERstated it, either by simply making up a low number or by manipulating the timing of the count to suit themselves.

    I only mention this because, as far as anyone can tell, Tuesday night's match is sold out. Has been for a week now. Go over to Ticketmaster and see for yourself.

    Normally, the league and the team can't wait to issue releases proudly trumpeting a quick sellout, and in fact that's exactly what happened with the evenings' other game, in Houston.

    But oddly, even though the game has been sold out for a week now, they've made no announcement at all regarding the game in Columbus. Only a very few people have been cynical enough to wonder out loud whether PSV is holding back a couple blocks of tickets so they can again screw with the narrative but I'd prefer not to think that.

    Still, there's something else very puzzling going on:

    Those of you who've been to Mapfre/Crew Stadium for big events (Crew Stadium: good enough for 3 national team games and an MLS Cup in the past 2 years but not good enough for "Frat Tony") know that when the regular seats sell out they put bleachers on the stage at the north end and on the patio to the south, letting them sell another 2500 or so seats. They've done it many times in the past.

    But for this game they have not done so and refuse to say why, but it's not hard to figure out: setting attendance records at Mapfre does not exactly fit the narrative. You might think that the opportunity to pocket another $250,000 or so from the match would be of interest to a team supposedly struggling to turn a profit, but you'd apparently be wrong.

    As long as we're discussing attendance, let's look at something that Andy Loughnane, the Crews's President of Business Operations, told a writer from Business Journal about a year ago:

    “We set attendance records, both sellouts and overall season tickets and overall season attendance records, (in) 2014, ‘15 and ‘16."

    Wait. What?

    But MLS keeps saying that attendance has been cratering, nobody was showing up and the players were getting lonely out there on game day, proving that Columbus "won't support" the team.

    Actually, attendance did in fact go down this year, but the primary reason is that MLS and PSV arranged for it to happen that way.

    The details are all located here, and it's eye opening to say the least; the team and the league quite clearly conspired to tamp down attendance.

    One recent Crew player, who still has numerous front office ties, says that he knows "for a fact" that the team literally "zeroed out" the marketing budget, something any resident of Columbus already knew. No TV, no print, no billboards, no display ads, nothing at all.

    It was so bad that a local outdoor advertising company actually created billboards promoting the Crew playoff run on their own because the team wouldn't do it.

    Why, if you didn't know better you'd swear that PSV didn't WANT to sell tickets in 2017. Why would that be I wonder.

    By now you've probably heard about the meeting in New York last week when the top political and business leaders from Columbus Ohio were finally granted an audience with Don 'Sir Lies A Lot' Garber and his organ grinder's monkey of a BFF, Anthony "Fratboy" Precourt.

    Basically, the guys from Columbus had some serious offers to make - downtown stadium sites, millions in corporate sponsorships and an offer to purchase the Crew either in part or in whole among them.

    They started the meeting by telling Garber and Precourt that they are committed to doing what it takes to keep the Crew in Columbus and, on that basis, asked them what was necessary to make that happen.

    They got no answer.

    Instead, displaying an attitude which Grant Wahl rightly characterized as "outrageous", MLS/PSV told them that they should just make an offer. Their view was that Columbus owed them something. This is what Precourt characterized, in a statement which the MLS comm shop released (under a PSV letterhead) before the Columbus contingent cleared the front desk on the way out, as "being willing to listen".

    The meeting lasted all of 20 minutes.

    [​IMG]

    Garber and Precourt didn't want this meeting to begin with. They thought they had this whole relocation thing pretty well figured out and when all hell broke loose they didn't know what to do, although one of the options they're NOT considering at the moment is "Not move the Crew to Austin Texas where they average 16 days a year over 100 degrees F.

    It's like Qatar without the slaves.

    Mostly, Don figures he has the cards, no one can stop him; Seattle majority owner Joe Roth told a supporters meeting that "it's not an owners decision" and "the Sounders have nothing to do with it". In other words, Don and his Monkey have all the authority they need to do whatever they want and what they want is to move MLS' original team to Austin and screw anybody who doesn't like it.

    A lot of people are saying the secret here is that if MLS can do this to Columbus they can do it to anyone. It says here that's exactly the lesson Garber wants everyone to take away from this. Do as he says, don't tick him off, or you'll get the same.

    Not long ago, two (or if they were feeling generous, three) guys could get together on the phone and give Garber his marching orders. He was not much more than a functionary who had to salute when Anschutz or Hunt walked in. No more.

    Welcome to MLS 4.0: It's Don's league now.
     

Comments

Discussion in 'Articles' started by Bill Archer, Nov 20, 2017.

    1. Olo2317

      Olo2317 Member

      Jun 1, 2014
      Club:
      CA River Plate
      Nat'l Team:
      Argentina

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      what is being done with @ColumbusCrewSC has turned me into an Euro-snob,adieu,adios,auf wiedersehen MLS ! now will only comeback if fans can be part owners and there is pro/rel
       
    2. Rob_Crewman

      Rob_Crewman New Member

      Leeds (UK), Vålerenga (NO), Crew (US)
      United States
      Sep 15, 2017

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Brilliant!!
       
    3. SportBoy333

      SportBoy333 Member+

      Jun 27, 2003

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Move the Crew to Cincinnati ?
       
    4. kgilbert78

      kgilbert78 Member+

      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      United States
      Dec 28, 2006
      Cowlumbus, OH
      Club:
      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      That seems to be MLS's "plan". Take the Crew away and then tell us--"Look, Ohio, we saved soccer for you" and present themselves as heroes. But that won't work here....
       
    5. CakeYear

      CakeYear Member

      none
      Jun 22, 2007
      Inglewood, Ca.
      Club:
      Los Angeles Galaxy

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Why Austin though.. do they even want a MLS team?
       
    6. kgilbert78

      kgilbert78 Member+

      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      United States
      Dec 28, 2006
      Cowlumbus, OH
      Club:
      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Austin is like Columbus was about 20 years ago--a college town that also happened to be the state capital, that found itself becoming a major city. One of the things major cities have is major league sports. So, for us, when the Crew came along, there was interest for just that reason--a lot of folks weren't even sure what soccer was (especially when I first moved to Columbus 40 years ago--for example, Columbus Public Schools didn't even offer the sport, tho some suburbs did). I'd expect the same is true in Austin--but there is no way of knowing right now--the one poll taken and reported was really on a couple hundred (at most) Austin soccer fans.
       
    7. scott47a

      scott47a Member+

      Seattle Sounders FC; Arsenal FC
      Feb 6, 2007
      Austin, Texas
      Club:
      Seattle Sounders
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      I"m surprised a guy from California is asking why Austin?
      I mean Austin is basically a smaller version of LA with better clubs. Lots of rich, good-looking people at the Whole Foods, many of whom you have seen on TV at some point or another.
      I think MLS wants Austin because it is the cool place to be in the USA at this point and it is growing incredibly rapidly.

      Now whether Austinites care at all about MLS remains to be seen. Demographically it makes sense. But I'm not really hearing any kind of groundswell of interest around here. If it's around, it's pretty quiet.
       
    8. CakeYear

      CakeYear Member

      none
      Jun 22, 2007
      Inglewood, Ca.
      Club:
      Los Angeles Galaxy

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      This right here is the meat of my question. All the other Anthony Bourdain/Travel Channel stuff you wrote is whatever. The million dollar question is: Does Austin even give a shit about MLS, do they even want a team, and would they support a team?
       
    9. scott47a

      scott47a Member+

      Seattle Sounders FC; Arsenal FC
      Feb 6, 2007
      Austin, Texas
      Club:
      Seattle Sounders
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      I said this in response to Bill's previous column, but I seriously think it comes down to location and marketing/investment.

      Getting the right location, close in to downtown and SoCo and Zilker Park and all is going to be very difficult. If it's there, it works. If the downtown people and college kids have to drive forget about it. If it's a suburban location like what happened in Dallas, I'm sure you will see the same shitty result.

      In terms of marketing and investment I have no faith that Precourt will succeed at that. If he couldn't do it in an already established market, I don't see how he's going to enliven a dormant market.

      I mean demographically and such I think there is a chance it could go well. Look at Atlanta, did any of us expect that? But do we really think Precourt can hold a candle to what Arthur Blank did to create momentum and ignite a fan base? Nah, I don't think so.

      Honestly I think the best solution is to force the guy to sell to someone in Columbus/with an agreement for a new stadium.

      Austin could be a great market for MLS, but I doubt Precourt can make it that.
       
      RevsLiverpool and RafaLarios repped this.
    10. nowherenova

      nowherenova Member+

      Jul 20, 2003
      Formerly Terminus

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Arthur Blank didn’t do very much to ignite Atlanta’s fan base. The fans were already here and waiting.
       
      RevsLiverpool repped this.
    11. RevsLiverpool

      RevsLiverpool Member+

      Nov 12, 2005
      Boston
      Club:
      Liverpool FC
      Nat'l Team:
      United States
      #36 RevsLiverpool, Nov 29, 2017
      Last edited: Nov 29, 2017

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      No, they don't. Precourt keeps saying "largest city without a pro team" - well, there's a reason for that: no appetite. Earlier poster hinted that with the "quiet" local support. They've got UT and a great city as is. Another way of putting it, "it's the market, stupid." Compare that to Cincy, Sacramento and some of the other exciting MLS prospective cities.
      Bingo. Expansion should always be a supporter-driven decision rather than a pure power move or money play.
       
    12. scott47a

      scott47a Member+

      Seattle Sounders FC; Arsenal FC
      Feb 6, 2007
      Austin, Texas
      Club:
      Seattle Sounders
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      This is revisionist history. Where were all those fans at the Silverbacks games through the years? Why weren't they supporting at a lower level like Sacramento or Cincinnati?

      It was very much not a given that MLS in Atlanta would succeed or that the fans were there. I believe much of the discussion on this website was "Atlanta is a terrible choice, they never support their teams, look at the Braves, the Hawks, the Thrashers." The discussion was much like it is about Miami.

      Using your logic, Austin is pretty much going to be a success too.I guarantee you there are a lot of soccer fans in Austin who never go to any games. I have met many of them through Austin AO.

      I contend that how a team is owned, managed, and marketed has everything to do with whether those fans show up or not.
       
    13. kgilbert78

      kgilbert78 Member+

      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      United States
      Dec 28, 2006
      Cowlumbus, OH
      Club:
      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Don't forget the Flames too....
       
    14. nowherenova

      nowherenova Member+

      Jul 20, 2003
      Formerly Terminus

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      How about I’m the one who applies my own logic - I said nothing about Austin - and it’s not revisionist when you have been involved in youth and adult Soccer in Atlanta for 25 years - Plenty of us knew MLS would do well in Atlanta and are sick of hearing how Arthur Blank made us a Soccer town

      And the fact you bring up the Silverbacks shows how little you understand apples and oranges

      (Oh and I don’t think Austin and Atlanta are at all similar situations for the record)
       
    15. Ch(Elsey)

      Ch(Elsey) Member+

      Columbus Crew
      United States
      May 2, 2003
      Green, Ohio
      Club:
      Columbus Crew
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Beclown. Great word choice. I love the beclowned main photo of Garber.
       
    16. zaqualung

      zaqualung Member+

      Jun 17, 2015
      San Francisco
      Club:
      Liverpool FC

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM

      Well, the guy made the post in reference to Sean Spicer, who isn't a politician. And it's probably correct to say that a vast number of people who listened to any good number of Mr. Spicer's utterances would have considered them to be zany distortions of reality. Therefore the analogy stands perfectly well (better than any other I can think of off hand) for a theoretical someone claiming a more than half empty stadium to be full..... in fact, I think Sean or someone may have said somethign nearly exactly equivalent this year about some gathering on the Washington Mall.
       
    17. txsn

      txsn Member+

      Jan 22, 2008
      Texas
      Club:
      Houston Dynamo
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      MLS does lie about attendance and there was definitely not 15k at the Dynamo game pictured, but the picture is just as much misinformation as MLS stating 15k. You should have plenty of ammo without having to mislead the facts to further your point.
       
    18. kgilbert78

      kgilbert78 Member+

      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      United States
      Dec 28, 2006
      Cowlumbus, OH
      Club:
      Borussia Mönchengladbach
      Nat'l Team:
      United States

      Don Garber and the Beclowning of MLS

      By Bill Archer on Nov 20, 2017 at 11:13 AM
      Again, he is/was part of the current administration. Your attempt to say "he's not a politician" is disingenuous at best. It was a political post--and there are plenty of ways to make that point without going there. So let's refrain. Please.
       

Share This Page