2019-2020 UEFA Referee Discussion [Rs]

Sounds like a familiar situation elsewhere.
Maybe the PGMOL should take notice of this!

PH

 

Well, there is an "*" after the statistic, but my lousy laptop cannot make it out

 

Final

Real Madrid - Atlético Madrid: SÁNCHEZ MARTÍNEZ (VAR: IGLESIAS VILLANUEVA)

 

About Supercopa de España:


Valencia - Real Madrid, Gil Manzano (González Fuertes)

=> 26' small charge on VAL player, correct play-on call
https://ok.ru/video/1551275919930?fromTime=1791

=> 44' illegal use of arm on VAL player, VAR confirmed the play-on call
https://ok.ru/video/1551275919930?fromTime=2970

=> 90' penalty for handball in favour of VAL awarded after OFR
https://ok.ru/video/1551317535290?fromTime=3016


Barcelona - Atlético Madrid, González González (Martínez Munuera)

Refereeing Highlights
https://vk.com/video424113568_456239069

5:50 - penalty incident
9:20 - penalty incident
18:15 - disallowed goal (handball)
22:10 - penalty incident
24:20 - disallowed goal (offside)
26:50 - penalty
28:05 - penalty incident


Final
Real Madrid - Atlético Madrid, Sunday 12th January

REF: José María Sánchez Martínez
AR1: Raúl Cabañero Martínez
AR2: José Gallego García
4th: Guillermo Cuadra Fernández
Res AR: Diego Barbero Sevilla

VAR: Ignacio Iglesias Villanueva
AVAR1: Santiago Jaime Latre
AVAR2: Roberto Díaz Pérez del Palomar

 

The big matchup this weekend in Spanish first division:

Saturday, January 18, 2020
Real Madrid vs Sevilla: Martínez Munuera, Juan (VAR: Soto Grado, César)

 

Elite referees and selected First Cat. referees will handle the UEFA Club Competition (CL / EL) games in the knockout stage this year.

Selected 1st Cat. referees:

Georgi Kabakov (Bulgaria, Category 1)
Xavier Estrada Fernández (Spain, Category 1)
José María Sánchez Martínez (Spain, Category 1)
Mattias Gestranius (Finland, Category 1)
Ruddy Buquet (France, Category 1)
Daniel Siebert (Germany, Category 1)
Tobias Stieler (Germany, Category 1)
Marco Guida (Italy, Category 1)
Davide Massa (Italy, Category 1)
Gediminas Mažeika (Lithuania, Category 1)
Andris Treimanis (Latvia, Category 1)
Serdar Gözübüyük (Netherlands, Category 1)
Robert Madden (Scotland, Category 1)
Srđan Jovanović (Serbia, Category 1)
Andreas Ekberg (Sweden, Category 1)
Ali Palabıyık (Turkey, Category 1)

All those referees are in Málaga for a UEFA course at the end of this month.

 

Course is in Mallorca, not Málaga

Referees invited as VARs:

Stuart Attwell (England, Category 2)
Christopher Kavanagh (England, Category 2)
Craig Pawson (England, Category 1)
Paul Tierney (England, Category 2)
Ricardo de Burgos Bengoechea (Spain, Category 2)
Alejandro José Hernández Hernández (Spain, Category 2)
Juan Martínez Munuera (Spain, Category 2)
Jérôme Brisard (France, Category 2)
François Letexier (France, Category 1)
Benoît Millot (France, Category 2)
Bastian Dankert (Germany, Category 2)
Christian Dingert (Germany, Category 2)
Sascha Stegemann (Germany, Category 2)
Anastasios Papapetrou (Greece, Category 2)
Roi Reinshreiber (Israel, Category 2)
Marco Di Bello (Italy, Category 2)
Michael Fabbri (Italy, Category 2)
Massimiliano Irrati (Italy, Category 2)
Paolo Valeri (Italy, Category 2)
Dennis Johan Higler (Netherlands, Category 2)
Kevin Blom (Netherlands, Former FIFA)
Bas Nijhuis (Netherlands, Category 1)
Pol van Boekel (Netherlands, Former FIFA)
Bartosz Frankowski (Poland, Category 2)
Pawel Gil (Poland, Category 1)
Luís Miguel Branco Godinho (Portugal, Category 3)
Tiago Bruno Lopes Martins (Portugal, Category 1)
João Pedro Silva Pinheiro (Portugal, Category 2)
Vitaliy Meshkov (Russia, Category 2)
Mete Kalkavan (Turkey, Category 2)

This should be a preselected list for VARs at EURO 2020.

 

Ha, I came here seeking help understanding this decision. I watched this match with someone who knows and enjoys soccer but isn’t up to date on all the laws. I thought I did a decent job explaining why under the current laws they were going to waive off the goal, and then they restarted with a kickoff.

 

Because the player who “handled” didn’t create the GSO? That works with the language of Law 12, but not the further explanation.

 

The handball rules are expected to be reviewed by the IFAB next month. You should make this proposal to them

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/f...ersial-new-handball-rules-reviewed-month.html

 

This weekend in Spanish first division:
Saturday, January 25, 2020
Valencia vs Barcelona: Gil Manzano (VAR: Iglesias Villanueva)

Mateu Lahoz gets a Madrid derby, though perhaps a lopsided one:
Sunday, January 26, 2020
Atlético Madrid vs Leganés: Mateu Lahoz (VAR: Álvarez Izquierdo)

 

The big Madrid derby:
Saturday, February 1, 2020
Real Madrid vs Atlético Madrid: Estrada Fernández, Xavier (VAR: Sánchez Martínez, José María)

 

Some interesting scenes from top games in Greece handled by top UEFA referees in the last weeks:

PAOK Thessaloníki - AEK Athína, Orel Grinfeld (Roi Reinschreiber)

55' Penalty (holding) to PAOK
75' Penalty (tripping) to AEK? No VAR intervention
83' Penalty (handling) to AEK? No VAR intervention
+91' Red Card (DOGSO) to AEK no.23
+94' 2nd Yellow Card (SPA/LoR) to AEK no.10


Olympiakòs Pireás - Panathinaïkòs, Mattias Gestranius (Anastásios Sidirópoulos)

9' Penalty (tripping) to Panathinaïkòs? After On-Field Review, referee confirmed play on
51' Penalty (tripping) to Panathinaïkòs? After On-Field Review, referee confirmed play on


AEK Athína - Olympiakós Pireás, Matej Jug (Stéfanos Koumparákis)

1' Careless, Reckless or Violent Conduct? No foul given
85' 2nd Yellow Card (reckless) AEK no.8; management
+91' Follow-Through SFP incident - foul given, no sanction


Jorge Sousa, Stephan Klossner, José María Sánchez Martínez, Slavko Vinčić and Sascha Stegemann have too handled games there this season; Gestranius also handled a further game.

By my calculations, there should be nine more foreign-officiated matches (assuming last Thessaloníki Derby is refereed by a Greek and Atrómitos don't get one). Last two PAOK - Olympiakós games are ones to watch out for - likely they will decide the championship and should get top Elite referees.

 

> +91' Red Card (DOGSO) to AEK no.23

Is it just me or did the attack try to get out of the way? Seems like a collision... but I am probably wrong.

 

Coming sunday:

Referee Bjorn Kuipers, VAR Bas Nijhuis

 

Maybe you’re seeing this wrong? The defender is the one sent off for DOGSO, not the attacker for colliding with the GK. The defender makes an attempt for the ball and catches the player outside the PA.

 

It seems like to me that the white player goes down first than the player who got him and got sent off.

I don't see 100% contact on his fault to be honest.

 

White went down first because Yellow tripped him during an OGSO.

Watch the slow replay portions starting at 0:51 & 0:59... Just after White #47 plays the ball, Yellow #23's left shin goes into White's right shin and appears to cause White to lose his balance and start falling. Yellow's contact came from slightly behind/side and his left foot turned/pointed towards White - that tells me Yellow was not simply running alongside his opponent.

My apologies if that's not what you were asking.

 

A couple more games from Greece:

Olympiakós Pireás – PAOK Thessaloníki
José María Sánchez Martínez (David Medié Jiménez)

27’ Penalty (holding) to PAOK?
31’ Careless, Reckless or Serious Foul Play? Foul given, no sanction
49’ Penalty (tripping) to Olympiakós?
63’ Penalty (tripping) to Olympiakós given
79’ Reckless vs. Serious Foul Play? Yellow Card given
89’ Reckless vs. Violent Conduct? Yellow Card given

VAR Interventions: -


PAOK Thessaloníki – Panathinaïkós
Slavko Vinčić (Athanásios Tzílos)

53’ Reckless vs. Serious Foul Play? No Foul given
55’ Reckless vs. Serious Foul Play? Yellow Card given
76’ Offside or Foul? If foul – what sanction? (very interesting LotG scene)
81’ PAN no.44 on PAOK no.9 – sanction needed? [ REPLAY ]
+96’ Penalty (charging) given to PAOK

VAR Interventions: +96’ No Foul -> Penalty (OFR)


Əliyar Ağayev (AZE, UEFA 1st, 32 yrs) will handle Panathinaïkós - PAOK Thessaloníki game in this weekend's round of matches.

 

Sorry if this is the wrong thread - I didn't see a better one (and it's probably not worth a new thread), but it's a really nice piece of refereeing and communication in a situation that wouldn't seem to come up very often.

Here's something you don't see every day...
The ref gives Garforths' Alex Low three cards at once 😲🙋‍♂️ pic.twitter.com/A6a9itEc0O

— Garforth Town AFC (@TheGarforthTown) January 26, 2020

 

Brings back memories of Cakir in his better days

 

Simply crazy game in Kuwait this week:

Al Kuwait - Al Qadisia
Mads-Kristoffer Kristoffersen (Abdallah Jimali)

32’ Yellow Card QAD no.33 (tackle); Violent Conduct against the referee? No sanction
57’ Second Yellow Card QAD no.33 (striking); Violent Conduct(s) against the referee? No sanction; Yellow Cards (UB) to KUW no.20 & QAD no.35
69’ Goal for Al Qadisia disallowed for foul (tripping) in the ‘build-up’
78’ Penalty (striking) to Al Qadisia?
+97’ Penalty (holding) to Al Qadisia? YC (simulation) given

VAR Interventions:
67’ Goal -> Defensive Freekick [OFR];
78’ No penalty, play on -> confirmed [OFR];
+97’ Penalty -> Indirect Freekick + Yellow Card (Simulation) [OFR]