Farve, no dobt in my opinion. Get him another two rings in the next 5 years (that I assume he'll be playing) and I'll mark him down as the best QB of all time. I'm a huge Farve guy. How many players have gotten 3 MVP's? 4-5 MVP's and 3 superbowl rings will no doubt do it for me. Right now I'll put him behind Montana and Unitas as best of all time.
brett fav-re by far... he is playing unreal this year... close second is tim couch kidding, just kidding...
It would have been funnier if you had said Dilfer. Don't get me wrong. I'm hip to Fahvreh, but it's blasphemy not to mention Elway in the top three. As far as this year, according to the quarterback ratings, which don't neccesarily mean anything, Favre is listed as 1 with a 102.5 rating and freakin' Holcomb is in at 2 with a 101.9.
1. Joey Harrington 2. Tommy Maddox I'm also going out on a limb to say Joey Harrington will end up recognized as the greatest QB in NFL history. It will happen, mark my words. Bookmark this post.
Huh? Ok, since you can't list 5 QB's in the top 3, so who are you bumping off the list? Marino gets the nod on top of Elway, dude holds like every QB passing record. And before SB rings are mentioned, keep in mind that Trent Dilfer has a SB ring. Rings don't make a QB, and QB's don't make Superbowls. The way I see it... First Tier --------- Montana Unitas Second Tier ----------- Where Favre will be remembered Marino Elway Young Third Tier --------- Everyone else Ok, commence the flaming.
Troy Aikman was not anywhere near the top QBs in history. He was a good, solid player and a strong leader, but hardly one of the best ever. Terry Bradshaw had 4 rings and isn't listed. The most underrated QB in history, and in my mind the best ever, was Roger Staubach. And, I hate the Cowboys worse than almost anything.