this is a very tough pick in all honesty for me, now theres a possibility that they both stay up, but alot has to go right for Charlton to get out of it even as commendable as their recent campaign has been. West Ham are even on points with Wigan and they HAAAVE to win this weekend. I think it comes down really to who id prefer at large in the premiership, and i have to say west ham, I think they play a more dynamic albeit risky style of ball that is ultimately more exciting to watch than Charlton's conservative play it safe approach. Unfortunately looking at the way things are, Spector would probably have a less chance to start than a healthy Gibbs. the CCCL might actually benefit Spector with much more playing time and a more key role to grow into his position. Gibbs i am completely confident if healthy would be El Karkouri's counterpart in the middle of Charlton's backline and would be getting consistent starts. Its close, if i was judging strictly on the YA, Id want Charlton to stay up. If it is the team at large, its West ham for me.