You might want to try NEVADA SMITH on 3rd avenue between 11th and 12th street or BECKY'S on 1st avenue and the low 60s. Enjoy.
I've seen loads of Arse fans at Nevada Smiths. Of course that has absolutely nothing to do with their recent success.
Home of the New York Reds. Lovely place. I might drive to New York City this weekend just to watch the FA Cup matches on Sunday... Here's the link, btw: http://www.nevadasmiths.net/