Serie-A old ratings

Thanks to @schwuppe who finds amazing info about italian Serie-A rankings from the 1950s-1960s, I create this thread to re-ordering the rankings provided.

 

Serie-A 1956-57

According the original source, for overall points, the top players were:
1. Fontana - 235 points
2. Lovati, Julinho & Vinicio - 234 points
5. Dino Costa - 233 points
6. Lindskog & Pesaola - 231 points
8. Bernasconi, Ocwirk & Bonifaci - 229 points

This system, awarded those players who performed great during the season, but also missed none or very few matches.

 

In contrast (but based on this ranking), I made another one, based in average performance only, but considering players who have played at least 60% of the games (20 out of 34 rounds).

This is the result for Serie-A 1956-57 season.

Nº ------ Player------------Role-----Club--Country--Games--Rating

01) LIEDHOLM, Nils------------- RM--- AC Milan---- Sweden - 26 - 8.17
02) JULINHO Botelho------------ RW--- Fiorentina --- Brazil--- 30 - 7.80
03) SCHIAFFINO, Juan----------- IL---- AC Milan---- Uru/Ita - 29 - 7.72
04) LINDSKOG, Bengt------------ IL----- Udinese----- Sweden-- 30 - 7.70
05) SECCHI, Giuseppe ----------- CF---- Udinese------- Italy---- 28 - 7.41
06) POSIO, Celso------------------- LM---- Napoli-------- Italy---- 29 - 7.31
07) PILMARK, Axel--------------- LM---- Bologna--- Denmark - 30 - 7.30
08) SEGATO, Armando---------- LM--- Fiorentina----- Italy---- 30 - 7.25
09) GUSTAVSSON, Bengt ------- CB --- Atalanta --- Sweden - 31 - 7.23
10) RICAGNI, Eduardo---------- IR/IL--- Torino----- Arg/Ita-- 31 - 7.19

11) LOSI, Giácomo----------------- LB---- AS Roma--- Italy --- 30 -- 7.18
12) MUCCINELLI, Ermes -------- RW------ Lazio------ Italy --- 29 -- 7.17
13) BONIFACI, Antoine------------ RM---- Bologna-- France -- 32 -- 7.16
14) CERVELLATI, Cesarino ----- RW --- Bologna ---- Italy --- 30 - 7.13
15) BUGATTI, Ottavio------------- GK------ Napoli------ Italy --- 32 - 7.11
16) DA COSTA, Dino--------------- IL ----- AS Roma - Bra/Ita - 33 - 7.06
17) ORZAN, Alberto--------------- CB --- Fiorentina --- Italy --- 31 - 6.98
18) FERRARIO, Rino--------------- CB ---- Triestina ---- Italy --- 32 -- 6.97
19) FONTANA, Alfio------------- LM/RM - AC Milan---- Italy -- 34 -- 6.91
20) STUCCHI, Giosué-------------- CB------ AS Roma--- Italy -- 33 - 6.91

21) COMASCHI, Luciano ----------- RB------ Napoli------ Italy - 32 - 6.91
22) LOVATI, Roberto ---------------- GK ------ Lazio ------ Italy - 34 - 6.88
23) VINICIO, Luis -------------------- CF ------ Napoli ---- Brazil - 34 - 6.88
24) VIVOLO, Pasquale ------------ CF/IR ---- Lazio ------ Italy -- 28 - 6.86
25) PIN, Antonio --------------------- GK ----- Padova ------ Italy - 33 - 6.82
26) LONGONI, Angelo ------------- LW -- Atalanta ------ Italy -- 30 - 6.80
27) PESAOLA, Bruno----------------- IL ----- Napoli --- Arg/Ita - 34 - 6.79
28) BERNASCONI, Gaudenzio --- CB --- Sampdoria -- Italy -- - 34 - 6.74
29) OCWIRK, Ernst ------------------- IR --- Sampdoria -- Austria - 34 - 6.74
30) SELMONSSON, Arne ------- LW/IL ----- Lazio ----- Sweden - 34 - 6.74

31) BECATTINI, Fosco ----------- LB/RB ---- Genoa ----- Italy --- 32 - 6.73
32) MORIN, Sergio ------------------ RM ----- Napoli ------ Italy ---- 33 - 6.73
33) SKOGLUND, Lennart ---------- LW ------ Inter ----- Sweden - 31 - 6.71
34) BANDINI, Piero ------------------ GK --- Triestina ------ Italy -- 34 - 6.66
35) DI GIÁCOMO, Benjamino ----- IR ------- SPAL ------- Italy -- 32 - 6.66
36) NORDHAL, Gunnar ------------- CF --- As Roma --- Sweden 30 - 6.65
37) FARINA, Giuseppe -------------- RB --- Sampdoria --- Italy --- 34 - 6.65
38) CORSINI, Giulio ----------------- LB ----- Atalanta ----- Italy --- 33 - 6.58
39) FRIGNANI, Amleto ------------- RW ---- Udinese ----- Italy --- 33 - 6.58
40) PESTRIN, Paolo ---------------- IR ------ As Roma ---- Italy --- 32 - 6.56

41) CORRADI, Giuseppe ------- RB ----- Juventus - Italy -- 34 - 6.53
42) BETTOLI, Pietro -------------- LB ---- Palermo -- Italy --- 33 - 6.48
43) BENEDETTI, Enzo ---------- RM --- Palermo -- Italy --- 34 - 6.41
44) ARMANO, Gino ---------- RW/IR -- Torino --- Italy --- 33 - 6.36
45) BROCCINI, Pietro ----------- IL/IR --- SPAL -- Italy --- 33 - 6.33
46) MOLINO, Giovanni ---------- RB ----- Lazio --- Italy --- 34 - 6.32
47) DAL POS, Edoardo ----------- LM ---- SPAL --- Italy --- 33 - 6.30
48) FONTANESI, Alberto ------- LW --- Udinese - Italy --- 34 - 6.03
49) -------------------- unknown
50) -------------------- unknown

All 4 nominees were considered for the 11 roles and 4 players for Ruoli Vari.

 

Ideal team 1956-57 (Corriere dello Sport unnoficial)
--------------------- Bugatti
Comaschi --------- Gustavsson ----------- Losi
------------- Liedholm --------- Pilmark
-------- Schiaffino ---------------- Lindskog
Julinho ----------- Secchi --------------- Longoni


Arguably: Ghezzi (GK), C.Maldini (RB)

 

Serie-A 1956-57 (Stars not making the top-50)

The player with less matches making the CdS ranking was Nils Liedholm with 26 games, who finished fourth in his Category by points, but a clear #1 by average.

Players with high-probability to make the top-50:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
x > 7,50 there are: Maldini (21g), Hamrin (23g), Vonlanthen (23g), Ghezzi (24g)

Players with medium-probability to make the top-50:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
7,00 > x > 6,50 there are: Boniperti (24g), D.Arce (24g), Bredesen (27g), Ghiggia (27g)

Players with low rating:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
6,50 >x, there are: Montuori (30g), Abaddie (29g), Szoke (29g), Cervato (30g), Lorenzi (28g), W.Gómez (27g)

Less than 20 matches:
Lojacono, H.Jepsson, Buffon, Cuchiarioni, Praest, Vernazza, Silvio Parodi, José Parodi, Humberto Tozzi, Hugo Natteri (Per)

https://www.bigsoccer.com/threads/various-stuff-i-found-from-the-40s-60s.2092755/
http://calcio-seriea.net/risultati/1956/832/

 

Overall, the ratings seems inflated. Even, with a correction, they could be decreased in +/- 0.50 points

So, my estimation about best players in Serie-A 1956-57:

5 stars(1): Nils Liedholm

4 stars(3): Julinho, Schiaffino, Lindskog

3 stars(12): Secchi, Posio, Pilmark, Segato, Gustavsson, Ricagni, Losi, Muccinelli, Bonifaci, Cervellati, Bugatti, Dino da Costa

2 stars(19): Orzan, Ferrario, Fontana, Stucchi, Comaschi, Lovati, Vinicio, Vivolo, Pin, Longoni, Pesaola, Bernasconi, Ocwirk, Selmonsson, Becattini, Morin, Skoglund, Bandini, G.Nordhal.


Arguably 3-stars: C.Maldini, Hamrin, Vonlanthen, Ghezzi.
Arguably 2-stars: Boniperti, D.Arce, Ghiggia, Bredesen, Montuori.

 

For Argentina, 1965 is the oldest. In this thread, I'm working in 1958-59 season.

For 1956-57, averages I posted, seems inflated, even with some adjudments, Liedholm will have 7,65 (a bit higher, but more credible, than 7,50 that someone got in La Liga)

For this season, I think Ocwirk was in decline, also was playing in a more offensive role that he used to being played.

 

Serie-A 1958-59

According the original source, for overall points, the top players were:
1. Bernasconi - 261 points
2. Angelillo - 252.5 points
3. Maldini - 249.5 points
4. Liedholm - 249 points
5. Robotti - 247 points
6. Panetti, Seghedoni & Brighenti - 242.5 points
9. Ghezzi - 241 points
10.Selmonsson - 240.5 points

This time, there were 5 players by role and 5 for multi-role.

 

Serie-A 1958-59 season, based on average performances.

Nº ------ Player--------------Role----Club---Country--Games--Rating

01) LIEDHOLM, Nils--------------- RM----- AC Milan--- Sweden --- 30 -- 8.30
02) BONIPERTI, Gian Piero-------- IR------ Juventus ------ Italy----- 26 -- 7.73
03) BERNASCONI, Gaudenzio -- CB ---- Sampdoria ---- Italy ----- 34 -- 7,68
04) ANGELILLO, Antonio------- CF/IR ------ Inter---- Argentina-- 33 -- 7.65
05) LOJACONO, Francisco ------ IL/IR--- Fiorentina--- Arg/Ita--- 28 -- 7.63
06) PANETTI, Luciano-------------- GK------- Roma-------- Italy------ 32 -- 7.58
07) GHEZZI, Giorgio---------------- GK------- Genoa------- Italy------ 32 -- 7.53
08) SEGHEDONI, Gianni----------- CB-------- Bari--------- Italy------ 33 -- 7.35
09) BRIGHENTI, Sergio ------------ CF ------ Padova ----- Italy ------ 33 -- 7.35
10) MALDINI, Cesare--------------- CB-------- Milan------- Italy------ 34 -- 7.34

11) GRILLO, Ernesto--------------- IL------- Milan---- Argentina -- 27 --- 7.33
12) ROSA, Humberto -------------- IR------ Padova----- Arg/Ita ---- 30 -- 7.30
13) BUGATTI, Ottavio-------------- GK------ Napoli-------- Italy ----- 32 -- 7.30
14) SELMONSSON, Arne ---------- LW/IL ---- Roma ----- Sweden --- 33 -- 7,29
15) ROBOTTI, Enzo ----------------- RB --- Fiorentina ----- Italy ---- 34 -- 7.26
16) MAZZONI, Mario--------------- RM ------- Bari --------- Italy ---- 33 -- 7.24
17) CAMPANA, Sergo------------ IL/CF --- Vicenza ------ Italy ----- 31 -- 7,19
18) BERNARDIN, Giorgio--------- CB ---- Triestina ----- Italy ------ 31 -- 7,18
19) CASTELLETTI, Sergio-------- LB ---- Fiorentina----- Italy ----- 32 -- 7,17
20) ZAGLIO, Franco---------------- LM------- Roma------- Italy ------ 30 -- 7,17

21) SARTI, Benito ------------------ LB----- Sampdoria----- Italy ----- 31 -- 7,16
22) JANICH, Franco -------------- CB -------- Lazio -------- Italy ----- 32 -- 7,16
23) CARRADORI, Franco ------- RM ------- Lazio -------- Italy ----- 32 -- 7,14
24) CORSINI, Giulio -------------- LB ------- Roma -------- Italy ----- 31 -- 7,11
25) MAGNANINI, Enzo --------- GK ------- Bari ---------- Italy ---- 33 -- 7,11
26) SEGATO, Armando-------- LM/IL--- Fiorentina----- Italy----- 29 -- 7.10
27) CUCCHIARIONI, Tito ------ LW --- Sampdoria - Argentina - 29 -- 7,10
28) CHARLES, John---------------- CF ----- Juventus ----- Wales --- 29 -- 7,09
29) HAMRIN, Kurt ---------------- RW --- Fiorentina --- Sweden -- 32 -- 7,08
30) CONTI, Raúl -------------------- IL -------- Bari ------ Argentina - 28 -- 7,05

31) TAGNIN, Carlo ------------ IR/LM ---- Lazio ------- Italy ---- 29 -- 7,05
32) PENTRELLI, Luis -------------- RW ---- Udinese -- Argentina - 31 - 7,03
33) MAZZOLA, José Altafini ----- CF ------ Milan ------ Brazil --- 32 -- 7,02
34) GHIGGIA, Alcides ------------- RW ------ Roma ---- Uru/Ita --- 29 -- 6.98
35) BURELLI, Guglielmo ---------- RB ---- Vicenza ------ Italy ---- 34 -- 6.97
36) FONTANA, Alfio----------------- RB ------ Milan------- Italy ---- 34 -- 6.97
37) GRIFITH, Giovanni ------------ RB ------ Roma ------- Italy ---- 33 -- 6.97
38) VICINI, Azeglio --------------- LM/IL - Sampdoria --- Italy ---- 34 -- 6.96
39) ZAGATTI, Francesco ---------- LB ------ Milan ------- Italy ---- 33 -- 6.95
40) GALLI, Carlo ------------------ IR/RW ---- Milan ------- Italy ---- 30 -- 6.92

41) BONIFACI, Antoine------------- LM------- Torino -- France -- 33 -- 6,91
42) FOGLI, Romano -------------- RM/LM -- Bologna --- Italy --- 30 -- 6.88
43) MARIANI, Amos ---------------- RW ----- Padova ---- Italy --- 31 -- 6.85
44) PIN, Antonio ---------------------- GK ----- Padova ---- Italy --- 34 -- 6.82
45) GRECO II, Elia ----------------- LB/CB --- Napoli ----- Italy --- 34 -- 6.82
46) TOZZI, Humberto --------------- CF ------- Lazio ---- Brazil --- 33 -- 6.77
47) DANOVA, Giancarlo ------- LW/RW --- Milan ----- Italy --- 30 -- 6.77
48) DI GIÁCOMO, Benjamino ------ IR ----- Napoli ----- Italy --- 33 -- 6.74
49) PASCUTTI, Ezio ------------------ LW --- Bologna ---- Italy --- 31 -- 6.74
50) SAVOINI, Giulio ----------------- LW ---- Vicenza ---- Italy --- 34 -- 672
.

 

Ideal team 1958-59 (Corriere dello Sport unnoficial)
-------------------------- Ghezzi
Robotti --------- Bernasconi ----------- Castelletti
------------- Liedholm ------- Segato
------- Boniperti ------------------ Lojacono
Hamrin ---------- Angelillo ------------- Selmonsson


Arguably: L.Buffon (GK), Cervato (LB), Vukas (IL)

 

Serie-A 1958-59 (Stars not making the top-50)

The player with less matches making the CdS ranking was Boniperti with 26 games, who finished fifth in his Category by points, but #2 by average.

Players with high-probability to make the top-50:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
x > 7,50 there are: Bredesen (20g), David (21g), Vukas (21g), Buffon (25g), Cervato (25g)

Players with medium-probability to make the top-50:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
7,33 > x > 6,50 there are: D.Arce (23g), Sivori (24g), Ocwirk (25g), Del Vecchio (25g), Pilmark (26g)

Players with low rating:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
6,50 >x, there are: Szoke (28g), Vinicio (28g), da Costa (27g), Schiaffino (27g), Montuori (27g), Lindskog (27g), Barison (27g), E.Bearzot 6,33 (33g)

Less than 20 matches:
Albertosi, Burgnich, Salvadore, Losi, Abaddie, Bulgarelli, Vonlanthen, Maschio, Palmer, Corso, Skoglund.

 

The ratings seems inflated, but overall a stronger season than 2 years before.

So, my estimation about best players in Serie-A 1958-59:

5 stars(1): Nils Liedholm

4 stars(6): Boniperti, Bernasconi, Angelillo, Lojacono, Panetti, Ghezzi

3 stars(22): Seghedoni, Brighenti, Maldini, Grillo, Rosa, Bugatti, Selmonsson, Robotti, Mazzoni, Campana, Bernardin, Castelletti, Zaglio, Sarti, Janich, Carradori, Cuchiarioni, J.Charles, Hamrin, Pentrelli, Altafini, Ghiggia

2 stars(18): Corsini, Magnanini, Segato, R.Conti, Tagnin, Burelli, Fontana, Griffith, A.Vicini, Zagatti, Galli, Bonifaci, Fogli, Mariani, Pin, Greco II, H.Tozzi, Pascutti.


Arguably 3-stars: Buffon, Cervato, David, Bredesen, Vukas.
Arguably 2-stars: Pilmark, del Vecchio, Ocwirk, D.Arce, Dino da Costa, Montuori, Sivori.

 

Yeah, even inflated, if I didn't make any mistakes on calculations, it looks, like Liedholm get two world class (at least) seasons in the above posts.

About Maldini, until this season, he seems had been playing as fullback at both sides. But he get his prime playing as a centerback.

 

Serie-A 1959-60

According the original source, for overall points, the top players were:
1. J.Charles - 243 points
2. Hamrin - 238.5 points
3. Losi - 232.5 points
4. Anzolin - 228 points
5. Marchesi - 227.5 points
6. Bugatti - 227 points
7. Pavinato - 224 points
8. Guarnacci - 223.5 points
9. Cervato - 220 points
10.Sarti - 219.5 points

This resume considered until the 31 round (last 3 are missing).

 

Serie-A 1959-60 season, based on average performances (31ºround).

Nº ------ Player--------------Role----Club---Country--Games--Rating

01) CHARLES, John---------------- CF ----- Juventus ----- Wales ---- 31 -- 7,84
02) SÍVORI, Omar------------------- IL------- Juventus -- Argentina-- 28 -- 7.80
03) HAMRIN, Kurt ---------------- RW --- Fiorentina ---- Sweden -- 31 -- 7,69
04) LOSI, Giácomo------------------ CB ------- Roma--------- Italy----- 31 --- 7.50
05) EMOLI, Flavio ----------------- RM------ Juventus------- Italy----- 28 -- 7.38
06) ANZOLIN, Roberto----------- GK------ Palermo-------- Italy----- 31 -- 7.35
07) SEGHEDONI, Gianni------- CB/LM------ Bari---------- Italy----- 27 -- 7.35
08) MARCHESI, Rino-------------- LM------ Atalanta------- Italy------ 31 -- 7.34
09) CASTELLETTI, Sergio--------- LB ---- Fiorentina------ Italy ----- 27 -- 7,33
10) BUGATTI, Ottavio------------- GK------- Napoli-------- Italy ----- 31 -- 7.32

11) COLOMBO, Umberto------ LM----- Juventus---- Italy --- 28 --- 7.32
12) BONIPERTI, Gian Piero---- IR/RW--- Juventus ---- Italy----- 29 -- 7.28
13) PAVINATO, Mirco------------ LB----- Bologna------ Italy ---- 31 -- 7.23
14) PIN, Antonio ---------------------- GK ------ Padova ------ Italy ---- 30 -- 7,22
15) GUARNACCI, Egidio ------ LM/RM ---- Roma ----- Italy ---- 31 -- 7.21
16) ORZAN, Alberto--------------- CB ---- Fiorentina --- Italy --- 30 -- 7.18
17) CARLINI, Rino------------------ CB ------ Genoa ----- Italy ---- 29 -- 7,17
18) JANICH, Franco ----------------- CB -------- Lazio -------- Italy ----- 30 -- 7,15
19) TAGNIN, Carlo --------------- IR/IL/RM ----- Bari --------- Italy ---- 28 -- 7,14
20) CHIAPPELLA, Giuseppe----- RM---- Fiorentina---- Italy --- 29 -- 7,14

21) MASCHIO, Humberto ------- IR------ Atalanta--- Argentina -- 27 -- 7,13
22) POSIO, Celso ------------------ LM ------ Napoli ------- Italy ------ 29 -- 7,12
23) CERVATO, Sergio ------------ CB ----- Juventus ------ Italy ----- 31 -- 7,10
24) SANTARELLI, Attilio ------- GK ------ Bologna ------ Italy ----- 28 -- 7,09
25) LOJACONO, Francisco ---- IL/IR--- Fiorentina--- Arg/Ita---- 29 -- 7.09
26) SARTI, Giuliano---------------- GK---- Fiorentina------ Italy------ 31 -- 7.08
27) FONTANA, Alfio-------------- RB -------- Milan-------- Italy ----- 30 -- 7,07
28) VERNAZZA, Santiago---- RW/CF -- Palermo - Argentina --- 31 -- 7,06
29) CORSO, Mario ---------------- LW ------- Inter ---------- Italy ----- 28 -- 7,05
30) CUCCHIARIONI, Tito ------ LW --- Sampdoria - Argentina -- 29 -- 7,05

31) NICOLE, Bruno -------- RW/IR ---- Juventus ----- Italy ---- 28 -- 7,00
32) BRIGHENTI, Sergio --------- CF -------- Padova -------- Italy ----- 28 -- 7.00
33) CORRADI, Giuseppe ------ RB -------- Genoa ------- Italy ---- 29 -- 6,95
34) FRANZINI, Bruno ----------- IL --------- Lazio -------- Italy ---- 31 -- 6.90
35) VICINI, Azeglio ------------- LM ----- Sampdoria ---- Italy ---- 30 -- 6.88
36) MASSEI, Oscar------------ IL/IR -------- SPAL---- Argentina - 29 -- 6.88
37) MIALICH, Giovanni ----- RM/CB ---- Bologna ------ Italy ---- 29 -- 6.88
38) BURELLI, Guglielmo ------ RB ------- Vicenza ------- Italy ---- 30 -- 6.87
39) DE BELLIS, Antonio ------ RB -------- Palermo ------ Italy ---- 29 -- 6.84
40) BELTRANDI, Rodolfo ---- RM --------- Napoli ------- Italy ---- 31 -- 6.82

41) MORBELLO, Egidio--------- LW------- SPAL ------- Italy ---- 30 - 6,82
42) PENTRELLI, Luis ----------- RW ---- Udinese -- Argentina - 31 - 6,81
43) BOZZAO, Gianfranco ------ LB ------- SPAL ------- Italy ---- 31 -- 6.81
44) BETTINI, Lorenzo ----------- CF ----- Udinese ------ Italy ---- 28 -- 6.80
45) MENTI, Luigi --------------- IR/IL --- Vicenza ------ Italy ---- 28 -- 6.80
46) RONZÓN, Pierluigi ---------- IL ----- Atalanta ----- Italy ---- 31 -- 6.79
47) PIQUÉ, Luciano ------------- RM ------- Genoa ------ Italy ---- 31 -- 6.77
48) SKOGLUND, Lennart ------- IL --- Sampdoria -- Sweden -- 29 -- 6.76
49) MICHELI, Dante ------------- RM ------ SPAL ------- Italy ---- 31 -- 6.76
50) ALTAFINI, José -------------- CF ------- Milan ------ Brazil --- 30 -- 6,75

Bonus
ANGELILLO, Antonio------- CF ------ Inter---- Argentina-- 30 -- 6,68
SELMONSSON, Arne ---- LW/IL --- Roma ---- Sweden --- 28 -- 6,52
MORA, Bruno ---------------- RW -- Sampdoria --- Italy ----- 30 -- 6,50
.

 

Ideal team 1959-60 (Corriere dello Sport unnoficial - missing 3 rounds.
------------------------ Anzolin
Fontana --------- Losi ----------- Castelletti
------------ Emoli ------- Marchesi
------- Boniperti ---------------- Sívori
Hamrin ---------- Charles ---------- Cucchiaroni


Last 3 rounds:
To increase: Hamrin (4g), Cucchiaroni (2g), Nicole (2g), Skoglund (2g), Altafini (3g), Firmani (4g), Manfredini (3g), Demarco (3g), Rozzoni (4g)
To decrease: Gustavsson (32º 1og, 33º loss 0-5)
.

 

Serie-A 1959-60 (Stars not making the top-50)

The players with less matches making the CdS ranking were Seghedoni, Castelletti 6 Maschio with 27 games, whom finished fourth in their Category by points, but make it top-20 by average.

Players with high-probability to make the top-50:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
x > 7,50 there are: David (21g), Firmani (21g), Grillo (22g)

Players with medium-probability to make the top-50:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
7,33 > x > 6,50 there are: Manfredini (22g), G.Rivera (23g), Liedholm (26g), Barison (23g), Montuori (24g), Lindskog (25g)

Players with low rating:
Considering the #points of the last-ranked in his role.
6,50 >x, there are: del Vecchio (26g), Maldini (28g), Gustavsson (28g), Demarco (26g), Ocwirk (27g), Vinicio (27g), Picchi (27g)

Less than 20 matches:
D.Arce, Ghezzi, L.Buffon, Bulgarelli, Abaddie, da Costa, Schiaffino, H.Tozzi, Burgnich, Salvadore, Trapattoni, Pascutti, Ghiggia

 

Again, ratings seems inflated, but as the previous one, another strong season with less disparity between ratings.

So, my estimation about best players in Serie-A 1959-60:

5 stars(0): -

4 stars(3): Charles, Sivori, Hamrin

3 stars(21): Losi, Emoli, Anzolin, Seghedoni, Marchesi, Castelletti, Bugatti, Colombo, Boniperti, Pavinato, Pin, Guarnacci, Orzan, Carlini, Janich, Maschio, Cervato, Lojacono, Vernazza, Corso, Cuchiaroni

2 stars(25): Tagnin, Chiapella, Posio, Santarelli, G.Sarti, Fontana, Nicolé, Brighenti, Corradi, Franzini, Vicini, Massei, Mialich, Burelli, de Bellis, Beltrandi, Morbello, Pentrelli, Bozzao, Bettini, L.Menti, Ronzon, Skoglund, Altafini, Angelillo.


Arguably 3-stars: David, Grillo, Firmani.
Arguably 2-stars: Manfredini, G.Rivera, Liedholm, Barison, Montuori, Lindskog, del Vecchio, Maldini
.

 

Serie-A 1960-61

According the original source, for cummulative points, the top players were:
1. Lindskog - 239.5 points
2. Marocchi - 239
3. Seghedoni - 237.5
4. Tagnin - 236.5
5. Guarneri - 235.5
6. Bugatti - 233.5
7. Vincenzi - 233
8. Salvadore - 223
9. Tagliavini - 233
10.Losi - 232

This resume considered the 34 rounds:
- Missing Juve-Inter (rescheduled from 28r after the 34r).
- Promotion games between 14th, 15th and 16th places (2 extra games)

 

Serie-A 1960-61 season, based on average performances (missing 1 match).



Notes:
In the rescheduled match Juve-Inter played after the 34ºR, Internazionale lineup a B-team (S.Mazzola debut), meanwhile Juventus lineup his A-team (ranked players as Charles, Sarti and Mora, and also Sivori who scored 6 goals this match).

Not appears in his role by Total Points due to less matches played.
Maybe Top-10: Maschio IR-24, Cervato CB-27.
Maybe Top-15: Demarco IR-23, Sivori IL-27.
Maybe Top-25: Liedholm RM-25, Skoglund IL-24, Gustavsson CB-29, Boniperti IR-27, Lojacono IL-27.
Maybe Top-50: Firmani CF-28, Maldini RB-30, Picchi RB-30, Vernazza RW-29, Selmonsson LW-23.

 

Ideal team 1960-61 (Corriere dello Sport unnoficial.
-------------------- L.Buffon
Vincenzi --------- Losi ----------- Trebbi
----------- Tagnin ------- Balleri
------ Ocwirk --------------- Lindskog
Hamrin --------- J.Charles ---------- Corso


Arguably:
Cervato-CB, Maschio-IR, Sivori-IL (especially the latter two).