Saturday 17 May 2025

Discussion in 'MLS: News & Analysis' started by Stuart95, May 17, 2025.

  1. Stuart95

    Stuart95 Member+

    Mar 11, 2012
    NoVA
    Club:
    Colorado Rapids
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    CBS Sports Top soccer picks today: FA Cup, MLS, NWSL best bets, odds, free predictions for Saturday, May 17

    Front Row Soccer RANKING THE DERBY MATCHES: All 30 of them between the Red Bulls and New York City FC

    GiveMeSport US Soccer, MLS approves pre-Club World Cup transfer window: Sources

    FanSided MLS news and rumors roundup for May. 16: Greg Vanney signs a new contract with the LA Galaxy and more

    Los Angeles Times Galaxy sign coach Greg Vanney to contract extension amid franchise-record winless start

    Goal.com LA Galaxy sign coach Greg Vanney to new contract despite winless start to MLS season

    LA Galaxy LA Galaxy Re-Sign Head Coach Greg Vanney and Invest in Soccer Operations Team

    Cincinnati Enquirer 'Game everyone wants to be part of.' FC Cincinnati visits Columbus for Hell is Real derby

    Goal.com 'A rivalry that is not manufactured' - NYCFC, New York Red Bulls Hudson River Derby hasn't reached the heights MLS hoped, but fans fight to keep it relevant

    Yahoo Sports Inside the Hudson River Derby: Can NYCFC overcome recent struggles vs. in-form Red Bulls? | The Cooligans

    STLtoday.com Doom and gloom for City SC: STL Soccer Talk

    Los Angeles Times For LAFC’s Mark Delgado, it’ll be ‘weird’ playing against Galaxy in El Tráfico

    Goal.com 'Highs are super high, lows are super low' - Houston Dynamo rising star Femi Awodesu on documenting his MLS journey, TikTok fame and life as a professional soccer player

    The Blazing Musket Revolution Sign Matt Polster to Contract Extension

    MLSsoccer.com LA Galaxy: From the beginning, kitman Raul Vargas has seen it all
     
    fortcollins, Mike03, AZUL GALAXY and 3 others repped this.
  2. Stuart95

    Stuart95 Member+

    Mar 11, 2012
    NoVA
    Club:
    Colorado Rapids
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Today's name the badge (thanks AeroNaught):
    [​IMG]
     
    xtomx repped this.
  3. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #3 falvo, May 17, 2025
    Last edited: May 17, 2025
    Club Atlético Aldosivi an Argentine club playing the Primera División ir the first division of Argentina.

    Former Argentine national team striker Martín Palermo coached them from 2021–2022.
     
  4. superdave

    superdave Member+

    Jul 14, 1999
    VB, VA
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Chesco United and Mike03 repped this.
  5. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #5 falvo, May 17, 2025
    Last edited: May 17, 2025
    Looking at his wiki , Tristan Blackmon has only been in Vancouver for three yesrs.

    Honestly, I don’t think it’s fair that it takes players 5+ years to get their citizenship and play for the USA while other national teams hand out papers at will.

    Why can’t the USA lineup some MLS foreign star players if that is the case?

    I think FIFA should start changing their rules.
     
    Chesco United repped this.
  6. ThreeApples

    ThreeApples Member+

    Jul 28, 1999
    Smurf Village
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    FIFA rules require a player obtaining a new nationality, without having a family connection, to have five years residence there before being eligible, even if the country will grant citizenship earlier than that.
     
    Nico Limmat, STR1 and Chesco United repped this.
  7. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #7 falvo, May 17, 2025
    Last edited: May 17, 2025
    I don't know if the rules have changed but I've seen many players play on World Cup teams and their only ties to the national teams were playing in the nations domestic clubs.

    Argentines Mauro Camoranesi and Mateo Retegui had been granted Italian citizenship but they had great grandparents who were Italian and other than that, no other family ties.

    Camoranesi played on Italy's 2006 WC tea but he was playing for Juventus at that time.

    Retegui was eligible to play for Italy through descent, in February 2023 and selected by Roberto Mancini but I don't think he ever stepped foot in Italy at that point.

    Italy has been choosing "Oriundi" since the 1930's.
     
    Chesco United repped this.
  8. superdave

    superdave Member+

    Jul 14, 1999
    VB, VA
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Because sports aren’t important enough to carve out special immigration laws just for them.

    If anyone is going to change this, it’s FIFA. And in fairness to it, they have tightened up this loophole somewhat. Otherwise Qatar would have fielded like 11 Argies and Brazilians in 2022.
     
    SetPeace and Chesco United repped this.
  9. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #9 falvo, May 17, 2025
    Last edited: May 17, 2025
    Portugal has done the same thing with Brazilian players.

    I've seen many other nations though, lineup foreign players in tournaments and many times, they don't have ties to the country other than playing for a club team.

    It seems like US laws prevent players from obtaining qucker citizenship papers as opposed to other nations but I don't see how fair that is when it comes time for national team selection for a given Copa America , World or Concacaf Cup
     
  10. jaykoz3

    jaykoz3 Member+

    Dec 25, 2010
    Conshohocken, PA
    Club:
    Philadelphia Union
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    A fair number of Italians immigrated to Argentina, among other South American Nations, towards the and after the end of World War II.
     
  11. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #11 falvo, May 17, 2025
    Last edited: May 17, 2025
    This is true.

    Italians have been immigrating to Argentina since the late 1800's.

    Most "Oriundi" who have been picked to play for Italy though, aren't really Italian with the exception of a great grand parent.
     
    Chesco United repped this.
  12. AZUL GALAXY

    AZUL GALAXY Member

    Aug 28, 2009
    Los Angeles
    Club:
    CDSC Cruz Azul
    It is true, a lot of Italians immigrated to America some to South America and some to Noth America but when people said America they think is a country but actually is a continent and a lot of people don’t know that.
     
    jaykoz3 repped this.
  13. ThreeApples

    ThreeApples Member+

    Jul 28, 1999
    Smurf Village
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    The US did it with Julian Gressel. No previous ties before joining the league, but he got his five years and obtained his citizenship and that was enough.
     
  14. Chesco United

    Chesco United Member+

    DC United
    Jun 24, 2001
    Chester County, PA
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    Argentina
    He actually played for Providence in the NCAA.
     
  15. Stuart95

    Stuart95 Member+

    Mar 11, 2012
    NoVA
    Club:
    Colorado Rapids
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Winner, winner!
     
    falvo repped this.
  16. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #16 falvo, May 17, 2025
    Last edited: May 17, 2025
    I don't know how it works now but I recall speaking with Preki when he first got called up and he was already in the US for years when he finally got his citizenship at age 33.

    That was a different time and the national team didn't have much depth in those days.

    Today though, if a foreign player starts his club career path in MLS at 18 , 19 or even 20 for example, 5 years isn't a long time but their time is short-lived if they have to wait the same amount of time starting at age 22, 23, or 24.

    It doesn't seem fair when so many other nations line up foreign players and hand out papers at will or at least in a much easier way than the US does.
     
  17. STR1

    STR1 Member+

    Atlanta United
    United States
    May 29, 2010
    Club:
    Real Madrid
    Per FIFA rules a player needs 5 years of continuous residency in a country to be eligible to represent that country. He can get Canadian citizenship earlier but won't meet FIFA requirements.
     
  18. Nico Limmat

    Nico Limmat Member+

    Oct 24, 1999
    Dubai, UAE
    Club:
    Grasshopper Club Zürich
    Nat'l Team:
    Switzerland
    Have you considered that the US has a bigger player pool than others? Given its citizenship laws? Almost no other developed country grants citizenship to someone merely by place of birth (jus soli).

    It’s how the USMNT got Musah and Balogun. Players with flimsy connections to the country at best with two foreign parents. Did either of them even live in the US for 5 years compared to the cases you are criticising?

    I think the FIFA rules are mostly ok, and the notion of “fairness” is multifaceted when it comes to concept of citizenship.
     
  19. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #19 falvo, May 18, 2025
    Last edited: May 18, 2025
    But I don’t care about citizenship.

    I’m mostly talking about how FIFA allows other nations to field these players and they give out citizenship papers freely so those players can be allowed to play on national teams.

    If that is the case, that isn’t fair at all because they are only doing it so those players can play for them and appear in a given tournament.

    Then I say rules should be changed and country should be allowed so all teams can be in the same boat and call up whomever they wish.

    In other words calling up green card holders or US residents.

    FIFA used to allow this so I am sure the rule can be changed again.

    Also, the US may have a lot of players to choose from but they aren’t all that great.

    I still keep coming back to Portugal fielding Brazilians and Italy picking Argentines freely or through ancestry but the US can’t do the same.

    That doesn’t seem at all fair to me.


    How new are these rules?

    If that’s the case , how is Canada allowed to pick Blackmon who’s only been in Canada three years or Italy Retegui who was never a resident?
     
  20. Nico Limmat

    Nico Limmat Member+

    Oct 24, 1999
    Dubai, UAE
    Club:
    Grasshopper Club Zürich
    Nat'l Team:
    Switzerland
    #20 Nico Limmat, May 18, 2025
    Last edited: May 18, 2025
    Well, it seems like you do.

    Citizenship is the point of reference for national team representation (as it should).

    As pointed out by others. FIFA requires 5 years consecutive residence for players that are not inherently eligible, either through jus soli (place of birth) or family ties.

    This rule has been in place for many years now (decades?) and isn't that different from the US citizenship journey for someone "fresh off the boat" so to speak. Compare that to my country (Switzerland) which requires a minimum of 10 years residence and doesn't consider jus soli.

    That is besides the point. Countries employing jus soli have a built-in advantage in player recruitment and representation. Here is a map. The concept seems to be mainly associated with the Americas: https://brilliantmaps.com/blood-jus-sanguinis-vs-land-jus-soli-based-rules-for-citizenship/

    The point is you will never have a level playing field when it comes to citizenship and representation, and the US is "better off" when it comes to player recruitment compared to others. The FIFA 5-year rule is a reasonable compromise given wildly different citizenship standards.
     
    jaykoz3 repped this.
  21. STR1

    STR1 Member+

    Atlanta United
    United States
    May 29, 2010
    Club:
    Real Madrid
    Retegui probably has a parent or grandparent that has Italian citizenship. It's how he qualifies. Since he can get that citizenship he didn't have to be living in Italy to represent them. Think of it like Dest who has never lived here but has America citizenship via his father.

    As for Blackmon, I have no idea. He won't be eligible to represent Canada based on FIFA rules. He can get his Canadian citizenship but needs the FIFA 5 year requirements. Eligible till 2027.

    Not the exact same scenario but Lucho Acosta was on a path to represent USMNT. He messed it up by breaking his residency by joining Liga MX. He lost his 5 year residency required by FIFA and broke it too for his path to US citizenship.
     
  22. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #22 falvo, May 18, 2025
    Last edited: May 18, 2025
    These are all great points and I understand them but I still don't see the fairness and that is why I’m saying they should change the rules.

    Retegui has a great grandparent I believe and that is how he was eligible to play for Italy.

    Look, I'm Italian -American, even lived and worked in Italy and have dual citizenship as my parents were born there.

    I'm thrilled that Retegui plays for Italy and is the Serie A's leader goal scorer.

    He even scored a beautiful game winner off a shot that hit the right post yesterday for Atalanta against Genoa , his former club.

    On the other hand, though, I still don't see how fair it is that Italy and Portugal can hand out citizenship or lineup Argentines and Brazilians respectively, on the basis of ancestry while in turn, teams like the US, can't do the same.

    The initial idea that Jules Rimet had when he came up with the World Cup concept was to field an all-star team of domestic players from each nation.

    That is virtually impossible today when you have a bunch of foreigners playing in each league.

    Heck Serie A clubs have few Italian born players per club.

    It is no wonder why Italy missed out on both the 2018 and 2022 World Cups.

    The only reason they won the Euro in 2021 was because of two old war horse defenders in Giorgio Chiellini and Leonardo Bonucci and that was a sort of miracle.

    The USA and/or MLS is in the same boat and they also missed out on the 2018 WC.

    Anyway, my main point is, sooner or later, top country's will not even be able field national teams because they can't field or find enough players playing top tier football.

    How can you field a national team of domestic players when your top or even bottom teams are aligned with a bunch of foreigners?

    Therefore, if that is the case, I'm betting FIFA will change their rules yet again some time in future.

    Maybe not now or in time for the 2026 WC but it will happen eventually otherwise, we can easily see the tournament suffering.
     
  23. Nico Limmat

    Nico Limmat Member+

    Oct 24, 1999
    Dubai, UAE
    Club:
    Grasshopper Club Zürich
    Nat'l Team:
    Switzerland
    #23 Nico Limmat, May 18, 2025
    Last edited: May 18, 2025
    As an Italian-American, now put on your Italian hat for a moment and try to see the other side. Italy does not use the concept of jus soli. Being born on Italian soil alone isn't enough. How is it fair that that the US has access to players that were born without a single American parent and barely lived in the country? How does that contribute to the "national identity" of the team? Which is more unfair, lax ancestry rules extending to a grandparent or lax birthright rules linked to location and timing?

    Now if you say Nico, how about we apply the 5 year rule to everyone you would have my immediate support. My country has some of the strictest citizenship rules in the world and we barely ever get to unearth a "gem" abroad. That's just how it is. If you crack down on ancestry you have to crack down on jus soli. That would include the likes of Musah, Balogun and Dest, who would have to play 5 years in MLS (not in Canada) before becoming eligible.

    But policing residence requirements for every single player in a FIFA sanctioned match sounds like a bit of a nightmare. How many residence certificate fraud cases would surface?
     
    jaykoz3 repped this.
  24. falvo

    falvo Member+

    Mar 27, 2005
    San Jose & Florence
    Club:
    San Jose Earthquakes
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    #24 falvo, May 18, 2025
    Last edited: May 18, 2025
    FIFA is already analyzing, scrutinizing or approving which players can or can't play for a given national team.

    Depending on your interpretation of the rules, there is or could be several violations and fraud in the case of some of these players that are allowed to play for a nation.

    Italy started picking Argentines in the 1930's.

    Lusito Monti played in the World Cup final in 1930 for Argentina and won the 1934 WC trophy for Italy on home soil.

    That was not fair because he played in two consecutive WC Finals for two different nations.

    The USMNT have picked many German Americans where their mothers had affairs or were married with US soldiers living on US Army bases in Germany.

    I.E. Thomas Dooely and Jermaine Jones.

    Jones even had 3 caps full Germany national team caps and that was unheard of previously.

    The main difference with the Argentines and Brazilians though is that those players are much better than their German American counterparts.

    Either way, both sets of rules are and still seem highly unfair and that is why I’m saying or advocating that the rules be changed.

    Even by FIFA’s standards of Fair play that they highly preach, neither system is or seems fair.

    Mostly because those same countries are signing up a bunch of ringers.

    They've changed the rules before and to believe or think that FIFA won't change them again, is highly naive.

    Maybe not by 2026 or even 2030 but it's inevitable that the rules will not be altered once again some day soon and I'm almost sure it will happen.
     
  25. AZUL GALAXY

    AZUL GALAXY Member

    Aug 28, 2009
    Los Angeles
    Club:
    CDSC Cruz Azul
    If that’s the rule, everyone in USA qualifies to play for their respective country of origin, except the natives Americans, USA is built by immigrants.
     

Share This Page