Player ratings/motm v Everton

Discussion in 'Manchester United' started by Republic of Mancunia, Oct 29, 2011.

  1. Republic of Mancunia

    Aug 24, 2004
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    De Gea
    Jones
    Evans
    Vidic
    Evra
    Welbeck
    Cleverley
    Fletcher
    Park
    Rooney
    Hernandez

    Nani
    Berbatov
    Valencia


    Mods, please sticky. :p
     
  2. Invincible

    Invincible Member+

    Mar 28, 2004
    Sanctuary
    De Gea 7 -
    Jones 5 -
    Evans 6 -
    Vidic 2 - There's nothing worse than someone who doesn't know their own limitations. I don't care how many aerial balls he cleared, he has the IQ of a fly.
    Evra 5 -
    Welbeck 6 -
    Cleverley 6 - Take some Caltrate.
    Fletcher 1 - Has he had hip replacement surgery? There's nothing more annoying than a midfielder who cannot swivel and pass. It's made doubly worse when he's surrounded by team mates who can.
    Park 2 -
    Rooney 5 -
    Hernandez 6 - He will always score goals but his overall game outside of scoring and making runs is atrocious.

    Nani 3 -
    Berbatov 3 -
    Valencia 0 - Awful. Terrible. Astonishingly bad.
     
  3. Stud83

    Stud83 Member+

    Jun 1, 2005
    :D LMAO. It's as if Vince has rated the game before it even started. Giving Berbatov a better rating than Vidic or Fletcher is simply hilarious.
     
  4. benni...

    benni... BigSoccer Supporter

    Nov 23, 2004
    Chocolate City
    De Gea - 7 Solid.
    Jones - 6.5 Solid for the most part
    Evans - 6.5 a mistake here or there, but Solid
    Vidic - 8 Typical Vidic in this kind of games.
    Evra - 6
    Welbeck - 6.5 Kind of fell in love with his dribbling today, missing several options to pass
    Cleverley - 6 When on, did okay.
    Fletcher - 6 did okay as well. Another better performance than the last.
    Park - 5.5 Not really effective, but not that wasteful either.
    Rooney - 6.5
    Hernandez 6.5 - Made several good runs, but only few of them used.

    Nani -5
    Berbatov- 5
    Valencia -5
     
  5. googoo

    googoo Member

    Dec 22, 2008
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    England
    De Gea - 7

    Jones - 6.5
    Evans - 6 - a bit shaky here and there, largely OK
    Vidic - 8 - excellent, MoM
    Evra - 6

    Welbeck - 6.5
    Cleverley - 7
    Fletcher - 5 - has shown some improvement, still a long way to go
    Park - 6

    Rooney - 6.5
    Hernandez - 6 - the usual

    Nani
    Berbatov
    Valencia
     
  6. pourmood

    pourmood Member

    Sep 6, 2008
    Nat'l Team:
    Korea Republic
    De Gea - 7
    Jones - 7
    Evans - 7, good showing.
    Vidic -7.5, best of the backline.
    Evra - 6.5
    Welbeck - 7
    Cleverley - 6
    Fletcher - 6
    Park - 6.5, he played well in the middle.
    Rooney - 6.5
    Hernandez - 5.5

    Nani - 6
    Berbatov - 6, want to see more of him.
    Valencia - 5.5
     
  7. SyedZada

    SyedZada Member+

    May 14, 2008
    Santa Clara
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    De Gea- 7 Has he been our best player this season ? In consistency terms.
    Jones-6
    Evans-6
    Vidic-7 Dealing with Fellaini isnt easy, he is very good in the air.
    Evra-5 I dont know, I expect more I guess.
    Park-5 When you are played on the right wing, you know you are allowed to be in the right side of the field.
    Welbeck-6 Isnt a winger, can be a wing forward though.
    Fletcher-5 I just dont know what he adds to the team currently.
    Cleverley-6 Had some good opportunities to set something up, messed up alot of moves between himself and Welbeck.
    Rooney- 6
    Hernandez-6 Scored.
     

Share This Page