msioux75 I'm the one who should be thanking you. I posted the final result of the Silver Ball published by Placar in the respective year. Sometimes, 3 (1972), 4 players per position (1975) are mentioned ... I think little. Soon, I take the previous edition of the magazine, still without the defined winners ... there are more suitors. When the classification is more complete (1973), I waived the search for more players.
Bola de Prata 1976 Edition 349 - 1976 final https://imgur.com/nzVpNrQ https://imgur.com/1Hhe51u Edition 348 - 1976 https://imgur.com/Lw6dG9O https://imgur.com/vyWMvgT https://imgur.com/Am8YgCx
Bola de Prata 1977 Edition 411 - 1977 final https://imgur.com/ABNEOUc https://imgur.com/46xowVN https://imgur.com/3jdErfI https://imgur.com/bkr1WBp https://imgur.com/ZGBCbug https://imgur.com/H7ye5mj https://imgur.com/SZfWmGf https://imgur.com/gzBC8SX https://imgur.com/9OXHApf https://imgur.com/j1ndYbR https://imgur.com/opCv1Rf https://imgur.com/Kv1jP2w Edition 410 - 1977 https://imgur.com/Yrzs4R1 https://imgur.com/I8PQCvH https://imgur.com/j67G1P0
You're welcome. Date is important, to know which round is the ranking provided and then work in the top-50 list.
Hello Msioux In fact the magazine did not publish the list of players ... only the Golden Ball https://imgur.com/wW8FO5Q https://imgur.com/30IcCs3 In edition 411, 3 games finished the Silver Ball: Londrina 2x2 CAM, Operário 1x0 SPFC and SPFC 0x0 CAM ... you can see that Peri (Operário) had 7.58 in the Silver Ball of edition 410 and then 7.65 in the end ... he went from 3rd to 2nd position on the Ponta Esquerda ... there was no correction in the Medio Volante function ... Cerezzo kept the average grade but the doubt is about the final grade of Chicão (SPFC).
Bola de Prata 1979 Placar 505 final https://imgur.com/rtJWNCv https://imgur.com/DXFWkft https://imgur.com/G309B2Y In the confused championship of 1979, Inter were champions with 23 games played. Vasco was runner-up with 14 games and Palmeiras, 4th place with 5. And the Silver Ball would not be immune to confusion ... adopting the criterion that the winner would have played 70% of the team's games (2/3 at least), Palmeiras, with only 5 games, had 4 winning players : Pedrinho, Pires, Jorge Mendonça and Jorginho. Placar 504 https://imgur.com/tjVAIdh
Bola de Prata 1980 Placar 527 final https://imgur.com/1I5pQVK Placar 526 https://imgur.com/26CBbZK https://imgur.com/lOwalEM https://imgur.com/N1KquBB
Bola de Prata 1981 Placar 573 final https://imgur.com/oWsWe5b https://imgur.com/Cp0imAk https://imgur.com/mLAvXWw Placar 572 https://imgur.com/wYfEYN6 https://imgur.com/K971Fje https://imgur.com/sb85rhe Placar 571 https://imgur.com/EmPhB77
Bola de Prata 1982 Placar 623 final https://imgur.com/6kyU1hg https://imgur.com/e2Fzj2h Placar 622 https://imgur.com/cl93zWh
Bola de Prata 1983 Placar 680 final https://imgur.com/OTpchc6 https://imgur.com/NqajEVq https://imgur.com/tlfIz36 https://imgur.com/yUQ5hfw Placar 679 https://imgur.com/tllenYz https://imgur.com/mUydSlV https://imgur.com/JEhSClO https://imgur.com/MpJLgsE https://imgur.com/gis0jXI https://imgur.com/O7jO7Hb
Bola de Prata 1984 Placar 732 final https://imgur.com/89RDGgy https://imgur.com/eGFV4tQ Placar 731 https://imgur.com/c8DeEE4
Bola de Prata 1985 Placar 794 final https://imgur.com/0dn0mBj https://imgur.com/1RHTjFi https://imgur.com/WB1DdqH Placar 793 https://imgur.com/lB3EdkV
Bola de Prata 1986 Placar 875 final https://imgur.com/0ebFyHk https://imgur.com/Omzi3Rn https://imgur.com/8sOsgGH Placar 874 https://imgur.com/rjX6Bp8
Bola de Prata 1987 Placar 916 final https://imgur.com/TvBVrtt https://imgur.com/wJj9zye https://imgur.com/vV0bbVg Placar 915 https://imgur.com/DujG3uA https://imgur.com/Ac5RmQe
1972 N°144 (December 15). Missing 2 rounds, also SemiFinals and Final. For Placar, minimum required was 22 matches. Finalists clubs played 30 matches. Semifinalists 29 matches. Second Phase 28 matches. First Phase 25 matches.
Brasilerao 1972, was played between Sep 09 and Dec 26. Ratings for players were from 3 to 10. I'd personally considered 67% of the games, this is 19 matches. Top 50 players - Brasilerao 1972 (Final rankings)
Brasilerao 1972 (Unnoficial Best XI) --------------------------- Leao Aranha --- Ancheta --- Figueroa --- F.Marinho ------------ Piazza ----------------------- Ademir Valdomiro --- Ze Roberto --- Leivinha --- Paulo Cesar Instead Bola de Prata 1972, I include (Ancheta x Beto; Valdomiro x Osni, Leivinha x Alberi) Bola de Ouro - Elías Figueroa 5 stars (1) - Figueroa. 4 stars (4) - Ze Roberto, Ademir, Paulo César, Rivelino. 3 stars (10) - Piazza, Roberto Meneses, Ze Carlos, Ancheta, Luis Pereira, Aranha, Dico, Leao, Beto, Alberi 2 stars (23) - Eurico, Leivinha, Givanildo, Renato, Dario, Luciano, Badeco, Tostao, Marinho, Buttice, Hermes, Edu, Baiaco, Helio, Claudio, Pescuma, Afonsinho, Vantuir, Dica, Dutra, Carpegiani, ze María, Felix. Low Rating: Obberti, Carlos Alberto, Madurga, Fischer, Doval, Dirceu Guimaraes, Roberto Batata, Forlán, Walter Machado. Few matches (<22): F.Reyes, Dirceu Lopes, Ramos Delgado, Cejas, Clodoaldo, P.Rocha, Roberto Dias, Gerson, Jairzinho, Perfumo. Pelé (Hors concurs)
Just to remark Jairzinho and Rocha cases. They did notable feat this season, but it seems, they doesn't get the 22 matches required to make the list.
Brasilerao 1973, was played between 25/08/73 and 20/02/74. Ratings for players were from 3 to 10. Teams at First Phase played 28 matches. Those qualified to Second Phase played 37 matches, and Finalists played 40 matches. Top 50 players - Brasilerao 1973 (Final rankings)
Brasilerao 1973 (Unnoficial Best XI) --------------------------- Cejas Ze María --- Ancheta --- L.Pereira --- F.Marinho ------ P.Rocha ---- Chicao --- Dirceu Lopes Zequinha ------- Mirandinha ----------- Mario Sergio Instead Bola de Prata 1973, I include (L.Pereira x Alfredo; Chicao x Pedro Omar) Bola de Ouro - Cejas & Ancheta 5 stars (0) - None. 4 stars (4) - Ancheta, Cejas, P.Rocha, L.Pereira. 3 stars (8) - Leao, Jairo, Ademir da Guia, Mario Sergio, Dirceu Lopes, Amaral, Andrada, F.Marinho 2 stars (18) - Alfredo, Pedro Omar, Chicao, Toinho, Figueroa, Leivinha, Carpegiani, Flamarion, Baiacoo, Mirandinha, Clodoaldo, Ze Carlos, Tuira, Fito, Edu, Vicente, Ramon, Perfumo. Low Rating: Carlos Alberto, Nelinho, Dirceu Guimaraes, Zico. Few matches : F.Reyes, Paulo Cesar Caju, Tostao, Ramos Delgado, Rivelino, Doval, Roberto Dias, Forlán, Gerson, Jairzinho, Darío, Fischer. Pelé (Hors concurs)
Looking for Carlos Alberto Torres ratings, honestly, it isn't too low or poor for someone that is regarded as one of the greatest right back ever and one of the very best brazilian defenders ever? How good was CAT before 1970? I admit that I know little about CAT before 1970.
It seems that Carlos Alberto prime years were in the second half of the 1960s, before Placar started its rankings