Yeah I don't rate Davies either. We'll become even more leaky. But make no mistake we need to replace Mendy. Preferably by a guy similar to Dani
While I don't like people putting their magnifying glass on and focusing on Mendy, I do think he's a liability on the ball in general. I know you disagree, but for me it's exceptionally clear that this is the case. More specifically re the Clasico, I feel he was largely responsible for that first goal, which allowed momentum to shift completely towards Barca and introduced us to a complete collapse (which can be attributed to Lucas in large parts (individual mistakes matter!) and the rest of the team in general of course). These details are essential in such games, so it's valid criticism. I don't like the "ship him to country X or Y" stuff though. I think Mendy is a useful player to have in the squad.
Davies Kounde and Balde for Barca just suggests that this necessity for quality rather than depth in this position is wildly overstated for us.
🚨NEW: Carlo Ancelotti tried Ferland Mendy as midfielder in training this week. @marca pic.twitter.com/Iy3CTilsBA— Madrid Zone (@theMadridZone) November 8, 2024
Renewing him early in the summer was a mistake. The club should have waited because now, as things stand, he's going to be a burden for another 2-3 years.