Offical Crew vs United 10/4 Player Grades Thread Clint Baumstark Brandon Prideaux Bryan Namoff Ryan Nelsen Bobby Convey Earnie Stewart Jose Alegria Eliseo Quintanilla Marco Etcheverry Ronald Cerritos Thiago Martins Hristo Stoitchkov Galin Ivanov Here are my grades: Clint Baumstark - 6 Brandon Prideaux - 6 Bryan Namoff - 6 Ryan Nelsen - 6 Bobby Convey -6 Earnie Stewart - 6 Jose Alegria - 5.5 Eliseo Quintanilla - 5.5 Marco Etcheverry - 6.5 MOTM ( Yes I said Marco was the MOTM) Ronald Cerritos - 5.5 Thiago Martins - 5.5 Hristo Stoitchkov - 6 Galin Ivanov - 5.5
Clint Baumstark- 4.5 Brandon Prideaux - 6 Bryan Namoff- 7 Ryan Nelsen - 7.5 MOTM Bobby Convey - 6 Earnie Stewart - 6 Jose Alegria - 6 Eliseo Quintanilla - 5.5 Marco Etcheverry- 6.5 Ronald Cerritos - 5.5 Thiago Martins- 6 Hristo Stoitchkov - 6 Galin Ivanov - 5.5 Hudson/Trask- 8
Baumstark - 5 Prideaux - 6 Namoff - 7 Nelsen - 7 Convey - 6 Stewart - 5.5 Alegria - 5.5 Quintanilla - 5.5 Etcheverry - 6.5 Cerritos - 4.5 Martins - 5.5 Stoitchkov - 5 Ivanov - 5
I have to side with the Mod with a great ass on this one. I pretty much feel spot on with the ratings she gave.
Clint Baumstark - 6 way to tenative coming off his line, hopefully gets better with time spent communicating with the D. But couldn't ask for more conidering the circumstances. Brandon Prideaux - 6.5 solid as always Bryan Namoff - 6 shaky moments but usually recovered just in time Ryan Nelsen - 7 Bobby Convey - 6 much improved over last couple games Earnie Stewart - 6 good steadying factor in the midfield. Jose Alegria - 7 best game I've ever seen Alegria play, after he came out our pressure ont he ball and possession dropped. Eliseo Quintanilla - 5.5 needs to do better with his shot. Marco Etcheverry - 7.5 MOTM Is this what we can always expect from a well rested etcheverry? He owned the midfield tonight and set up the important goal. Ronald Cerritos - 5.5 worked hard, just not clicking tonight Thiago Martins - 5 good work ethic, clumsy on the ball and lots of giveaways. Hristo Stoitchkov - 6 played some great crosses late in the 2nd half. Galin Ivanov - NR
Clint Baumstark- 5.5 Brandon Prideaux - 6 Bryan Namoff- 7 Ryan Nelsen - 7 Bobby Convey - 6 Earnie Stewart - 6 Jose Alegria - 6 Eliseo Quintanilla - 5.5 Marco Etcheverry- 6.5 Ronald Cerritos -5.5 Thiago Martins- 6 Hristo Stoitchkov - 6 Galin Ivanov - 5.5
Baumstark 5.5 Prideaux 6 Namoff 6.5 Nelson 7 Convey 6.5 Stewart 6 Alegria 6.5 Quintanilla 6.5 Etcheverry 7.5 MOTM Cerritos 6 Martins 6.5 Stoichkov 5.5 Ivanov 5.5
Clint Baumstark 5 Brandon Prideaux 6 Bryan Namoff 6 Ryan Nelsen 6 Bobby Convey 5 Earnie Stewart 7 Jose Alegria 6 Eliseo Quintanilla 5 Marco Etcheverry 6 Ronald Cerritos 5 Thiago Martins 6 Hristo Stoitchkov 5 Galin Ivanov 5
I agree with her too ... but I can't call an ass great until I make a first hand assessment Nelson pretty much took Air-McBride out of the game ... gotta love that
Clint Baumstark - 5 didn't communicate really well with Nelson at first, but Nellie handled it Brandon Prideaux - 6.5 stopped alot of attacks, Edson who? Bryan Namoff - 7 MOTM very active, stepped up nice, stifled attack after attack, good transition to keep the offense going Ryan Nelsen - 6 good captaining, keeping it as organized as possible back there Bobby Convey - 6 Earnie Stewart - 5.5 great team player, doesn't need to "shine" Jose Alegria - 5 Eliseo Quintanilla - 5 Marco Etcheverry - 6.5 excellent game in a different role, he handled himself nicely, if he had some strenth left in that leg, would have set up a bunch of counters, still great vision Ronald Cerritos - 5 Thiago Martins - 5 Hristo Stoitchkov - 5 Galin Ivanov - 5.5 La Norte - 8.6
Clint Baumstark - 6.0 Nothing spectacular, steady Brandon Prideaux - 6.0 Solid game. No mistakes Bryan Namoff - 6.0 Solid game, no mistakes Ryan Nelsen - 6.0 Solid game, no mistakes Bobby Convey - 5.5 Would deserve higher, but considering what he is capable of on the pitch. He needs to get back to his pre HotSpurRejection form Earnie Stewart 6.5 - Great game especially getting back on defence. Jose Alegria - 6.0 - Solid Game Eliseo Quintanilla 5.5 - Good game. Marco Etcheverry 8.5 - This is the Marco we all want to know and love. Have not seen this from him in a while Ronald Cerritos - 6 Solid game. Thiago Martins - 6.0 Solid game Hristo Stoitchkov 6.5 - If only people could anticipate his passes better. I wish I could have seen him play in his prime at Barcelona Galin Ivanov - N/A
United @ Columbus Crew, 10.4.03 Average Grades Clint Baumstark 5.39 Brandon Prideaux 6.12 Bryan Namoff 6.50 Ryan Nelsen 6.61 Bobby Convey 5.89 Earnie Stewart 6.06 Jose Alegria 5.94 Eliseo Quintanilla 5.50 Marco Etcheverry 6.89 Ronald Cerritos 5.39 Thiago Martins 5.72 Hristo Stoitchkov 5.67 Galin Ivanov 5.36 DC United 5.93