Now we end it: Am I the only person who DIDN'T think Royal Tenenbaums was amazing

No, it was a crap movie.

 

It's a Texas movie, so obviously you Yankees and Yankee-in-laws (that's you, montreal) won't "get it."

 

I will admit it pettered out at the end. But all Wes' films are great.

I must grudgingly give it but four stars.

 

I loved the hell outta this movie. I read interviews with Anderson afterwards where he was talking about JD Salingers Glass family. Watching it in that context makes me like it even more.
Now David Lynch, there is a pretentious director.

 

Re: Re: Now we end it: Am I the only person who DIDN'T think Royal Tenenbaums was amazing

So he stumbled a bit with "Firewalk with My Ego."

Give the guy a break.

 

Royal Tenenbaums is great. just watched BottleRocket (wes anderson's first movie) again today, and man that thing is funny

 

Lots of people felt similarly about "The Royal Tenenbaums" being subpar from Mr. Wes. It had some moments, but the whole thing felt episodic and contrived. Way too many characters and quirks to care about any of them. "Rushmore" and "Bottle Rocket" are both superior.

At least "The Royal Ts" is a flawed early work from a young and impressive director. He'll have more hits than misses I think.

 

tenenbaums was one of the best movies on 2001

 

Pretty dead on. "Rushmore" is my favorite movie. But Royal Tenenbaums didn't really do it for me. There was just something a bit smug about the whole thing...

 

Re: Re: Now we end it: Am I the only person who DIDN'T think Royal Tenenbaums was amazing

Just wondering, but how/why did this change your view of the movie? I had known about that context going in, and it did nothing for me (and I was a big Salinger fan back in the day). The Glass family in Salinger's novels had much more depth and feeling from what I recall, than the Tenenbaums. I think RT needed to be about 3 hours to do justice to the various characters and relationships.

 

From start to finish I just wanted to punch my friends for talking me into seeing that movie. It sucked and was a total waste of $15 (had to pay for the girlfriend too.)

 

I loved all of Salinger's Glass book ("Franny and Zooey" is the best!) and I thought that Royal Tenenbaums was the best film I saw last year. I can see why people think that it is ostentatious but that's probably the same reason why I like it so much. The scene with the tennis player in the bathroom cutting his beard with "Needle in the Hay" playing (don't want to give too much away) was great.

 

Royal Tenenbaum is, in my opinion, the best character Gene Hackman has ever played. That's considering Popeye Doyle and Norman Dale. I found that the humor was more subtle than Rushmore, the kind of funny that you find in Metropolitan.

 

It was criminal that Hackman was overlooked for an Oscar nomination for 'The RTs."

It was also my favorite movie of last year. The DVD is amazing, with interviews of all cast members, running commentary by Wes, a "making of" special and even an interview with the artist that painted those wack paintings in Eli Cash's apartment (hint...they were not painted for the movie...)

I can see where some people wouldn't like it. My boss walked out of it. Those people tend to like more normal and accessible fare.

 

I think that was one of the things that bothered me about the movie, the characters, whether Royal, Ben Stiller's little carbon copies, Luke Wilson or the others, they were all great. Its rare that so many great characters pop up in a movie, yet the final product doesn't come near what the sum of its parts should have been.

I sum RTs up as great characters, waste of a movie.

 

So I've been duped, tricked eh? They pulled one over on me.