My top 5 most over rated in MLS this season 5. Abel Xavier, D, Galaxy, LA's back 4 is probably the worst in MLS 4. Landon Donovan, M, Galaxy, the king of inconsistency lost his captains arm band this year 3. Alecko Eskandarian, F, Salt Lake, cant seem to find that scoring touch anymore. 2. Carlos Ruiz, F, FC Dallas, 4 goals this year, he should be doing much better than this. 1. Claudio Reyna, M, New York, 3 assists this year in 17 starts. captain america has definately lost his touch.