Well, now you're getting into medical ethics and patient rights, and all I was talking about was why just eat fish on Fridays. And, why yes, since you ask, I do think change and progress can be a good thing, just like it can not be a good thing. But, hey, I think it's probably a good thing that we no longer have slavery and that we have medical advances that decrease the chances of of mothers and infants dying during child birth, and that allowed us to move away from using leeches and bleeding people in order to try to rid them of disease, and that being gay/lesbian is no longer classified as a mental illness, and that blacks and women can vote, and that heterosexuals can marry whoever they want, regardless of ethnicity, and that we have indoor plumbing, and ways to protect our food and water supplies, and a lot of other things that I'll save for later to list.
Well, I didn't mean to question the progress that has been made, just the attitude apparent in some that any change is indeed progress, that any new idea or philosophy is some ground-breaking revelation. You want to know how to become a successful philosopher? No? Well, I'll tell you anyway. Just scrap what everyone before you has said and make up something new. Throw in some big words that not everyone will know--it'll sound impressive. Or pretentious. Either way.
Well, I didn't say all change was good and progressive, now did I? Hmmmmmmm? I'm not so naive as to think that just because one changes something that it's necessarily a good thing, or that because we have the ability to keep a braindead person on life support for an infinite amount of time that it's a good thing. And what does being a successful philosopher have to do with eating only fish on Friday?
I never said you had that mindset. I'm simply rather inept at expressing myself. And what does philosophy have to do with fish on Friday? Well, we could argue about whether or not the Pope actually holds the authority of God to speak for Him and lead and guide us, but I don't want to. Besides, fish can have tons of mercury in it, and that can screw you up. Especially women that want to have children--mercury in the womb isn't safe to have. Not that that has much of anything to do with the whole argument. So yeah.
I just got my Eurosport.... they have "USA Women" foosball ornaments. Little foosball girls with ponytails, name and number. Part of me says "oooooooooo" and part of me says :|
Oh, okay. Who's arguing? I was discussing. I thought the Pope was appointed by the Cardinals. Unless I'm mistaken, none of them (or whoever it is who decides who the new Pope it) are God. And I don't think that they knew about the whole mercury in fish issue back in the day when the whole fish only on Friday thing was started. And if they did know, then why were they making people eat just fish on Fridays?
are you kidding? concraceptives are bad but then so is abortion so no sex at all for catholics til afte marriage (explains the irish)
Heh. Well, I misused the word 'argue' there when I truly should've said 'discuss' or something to that effect. The basic point about philosophy applying to fish Friday is that if the Pope isn't appointed by God in one way or another (one may decide to argue that if the cardinals held the authority of God, and if they used it correctly, then they would by proxy be appointing whomever God wanted to be Pope), then it's more or less a philosophical tenet. Just something that someone in power came up with because he thought it was something worth doing and had the power to make it so. If you take the authority of God out of any religion, what you have left is people making philosophical guesses based on scriptures and writings they possess. You have the base scripture, something all the members of church (hopefully--otherwise, why are they there?) agree on, being interpreted by someone who, lacking God's authority, isn't by default any better or worse than Random Q. Countryman. You basically have a philosophical discussion group with scripture instead of the writings of Kierkegaard or Kant. Which is basically how I feel most churches are.
um. i'm catholic. and mute is catholic. and mute goes to church every sunday and hasn't missed for 14 years. religion, as taught by my religion teacher at my catholic high school, is a vehicle. you find which vehicle suits you best to reach god, but by no means do you have to believe in every single word or edict. religion is merely a way to get to god. why would you let anyone tell you how and control how you talk to god?
Hey Bob, I found some more Abby pictures for you. RB, the ass picture is for you. LMAO!!! PS. Sorry General, I know you hate Abby *winks*, but I couldn't help myself.
But then sex is very, very (very) good, at least when done well, which in part explains contraceptives and abortion--not wanting an unwanted pregnancy to muss up one's lifestyle.
*brain fizzling over religious discussion...getting that Dubya foam at the corner of my mouth* I like Cocoa Puffs.
I'm more of a Cinnamon Toast Crunch man myself. I don't think chocolate was meant for breakfast--really, you should at least wait until 11 AM.
Right. Which is why I was asking about the fish on Friday thing. Like, where'd that come from, and why? What was the reasoning behind it. I guess I shoulda treated it like I do math -- just take it at face value, and don't ask why. Well, yeah.