I could have made a poll here but people tend to vote without giving their views in words, and that's what I want here. Put all your loyalty to the skipper aside, close your "there's only one Keano" song books and look at this objectively: Does Keano deserve to be a starting player for Manchester United any more? The one part of his game (outside of his great influence as long-term captain) that hasn't dropped over the years is his great holding-up of the ball and accurate, if not always unlocking, passes. Yesterday, to my shock and horror, Keane actually gave the ball away on numerous occasions. He couldn't create from the middle (all our play led to final balls from the wing, which weren't too effective considering the dense City defence), his shooting was awful. IMO, SAF should be braver and put Klebs in the starting line-up. If people don't think Klebs is good enough to take Keane's place, then It's my stand that a January signing must do so. Keane is not good enough to continue holding a permanent starting 11 place for United.