A moot point: in some ways, yes; in some ways, no. From my position, as one who objects to war in just about any context, yes, it is a moot point. And it is also moot to suggest that the legality matters to this administration. But I don't think we should dismiss that aspect as the question of legality matters in terms of justifying what actions may or many not be taken, past of future. I also think it matters in terms of how members of Congress speak about this war, and how we interpret their position. And I think even as liberal as we may be, those who are from Europe who are posting here have a different view on the question of legal v. illegal and what that means to them.
None of it will matter unless he's impeached and removed from office. Everything else is just shouting into the wind. Same comment as above.
Actually, I don't think he really cares. He has no goals in Iran that he wants to achieve. He just wants to be seen as a global strongman now that he's discovered the joys of being commander in chief and the toys he gets to play with in that role. Trump breaks, he doesn't build. His plan will be to somehow "win" in Iran and then head off to Cuba for another decapitation.
I honestly don't think Trump recognizes objective reality as something which exists outside of his own desires and preferences.
He absolutely cares, because he wants someone who bows to him. That's the end goal. He doesn't care if they are democratic or a theocracy. As long as they now to him at all times. He will sell it as being friendly to America, but he means him ultimately.
The interesting thing is Grant only required unconditional surrender once — at Fort Donelson. At Vicksburg and Appomattox, Grant engaged in negotiations and agreed to terms, paroling the Confederates rather than taking them as POWs. In World War II despite the Casablanca Declaration, the only true unconditional surrender was Germany (though Goebbels, Himmler, and Goering all attempted negotiations). The Japan surrender though called unconditional did have assurances that the emperor would remain on the throne. Japan though occupied also retained a civilian unlike Germany (where soon after the surrender the Flensburg government was arrested and its members put on trial). Italy’s surrender was not unconditional.
Oil surges 35% this week for biggest gain in futures trading history dating back to 1983 https://www.cnbc.com/2026/03/06/iran-us-war-oil-prices-brent-wti-barrel-futures.html What did I just tell you guys about the other shoe that's gonna drop?
It's a good thing the Trump administration is aggressively pushing all those green energy initiatives the Biden administration put in place! Oh, wait ...
You're forgetting the important thing - he and his friends are probably going to make a lot of money off of oil prices spiking! What could be more important than that?
Yep and the US stock markets dropped too. Up until today the oil and stock markets weren't that bad considering there was a war on. Felt like they were giving the powers that be the benefit of the doubt. Seems like patience is running out. A week in and we are no closer to knowing how it will end, or what the end could look like. If oil keeps rising and stock markets falling I wouldn't be surprised if the White House doesn't declare a unilateral "Unconditional Surrender" next week.
So both the Russians and the Chinese provide Iran the eyes in the sky by giving information of the whereabouts of the US forces (not of the Israeli forces?) What use is that, if you don't deliver the missiles, capable to hit them.
Thinking about that...why hasnot that mock nobel prize institute grabbed the opportunity to "award" him with something like that.
Well, lots of things came out today to effect the market. The employment numbers (and revisions), the GCC suggesting an unwillingness to work with the US, contradictory messaging from a couple of Fed speakers, late in the day an Oracle/OpenAI announcement (data center not being cancelled), and, of course, oil (which is causing inflation worries). Beyond that, I think the big worry is the lack of clarity with an end point.