Group of death analysis

Discussion in 'FIFA and Tournaments' started by tomvandamn, Dec 5, 2005.

  1. tomvandamn

    tomvandamn New Member

    Apr 9, 2003
    new york
    This is assuming bilds 4 pots are corrected as listed below
    the brackets are just probablities before the draw starts once the procedure is revealed tommorow this could change


    Brazil (african country or australia)(2 euro teams possible),(any or none if 2 euros picked)
    Argentina (african country or australia) (2 euro teams possible),(any or none if 2 euros picked)
    Mexico (any),(2 euro teams possible),(asian team or none if 2 euros picked)
    Germany (any),(1euro team),
    France (any),(1euro team),
    Italy (any),(1euro team),
    Spain (any),(1euro team),
    England (any),(1euro team),


    Ivory Coast(any)(any)(any)
    Ghana(any)(any)(any)
    Tunisia(any)(any)(any)
    Angola(any)(any)(any)
    Togo(any)(any)(any)
    Paraguay(5euros or mexico) (any)(any)
    Ecuador(5euros or mexico) (any)(any)
    Australia(any)(any)(any)

    Holland (any)(any)(any)
    Portugal(any)(any)(any)
    Czech Rep.(any)(any)(any)
    Sweden(any)(any)(any)
    Croatia(any)(any)(any)
    Serbia(any)(any)(any)
    Ukraine(any)(any)(any)
    Switzerland(any)(any)(any)
    Poland (any)(any)(any)


    USA(5euros or bra,arg)
    Costa Rica(5euros or bra,arg)
    T&T(5euros or bra,arg)
    Japan(any)(any)(any)
    S.Korea(any)(any)(any)
    Iran(any)(any)(any)
    SArabia(any)(any)(any)



    Each bracket represents a pot 2,3 and 4


    Brazil (african country or australia)(2 euro teams possible),(any or none if 2 euros picked)
    Argentina (african country or australia) (2 euro teams possible),(any or none if 2 euros picked)
    Mexico (any),(2 euro teams possible),(asian team or none if 2 euros picked)
    Germany (any),(1euro team),(any)
    France (any),(1euro team),(any)
    Italy (any),(1euro team),(any)
    Spain (any),(1euro team),(any)
    England (any),(1euro team),(any)

    So who is going to get the 2 euro countries
    Brazil--unlikely but since theyre such big favorites fifa might give em two but if this happens dont expect holland/czech or sweden/portugal

    Argentina-they got england and sweden last time and got knocked out---

    Mexico-they will get their seed but this atleast on paper and politics seems the team destined to get 2 strong euro teams ala czech/portugal

    Brazil and Argentina have an 80% chance of getting an african team from pot 2 while mexico is guaranteed to get an asian team unless they draw a double euro

    Also whoever gets the 2 euro teams will consist of the following
    Brazil,EURO1,EURO2,(African country or Australia)
    Argentina,EURO1,EURO2,(African country or Australia)
    Mexico,EURO1,EURO2,(any team from pot2)

    The group of death can also consist of a group w/o 2 euro countries
    Brazil Ivory Coast Holland USA
    Argentina Ghana Sweden USA
     
  2. Andy TAUS

    Andy TAUS Member

    Jan 31, 2004
    Sydney, AUS
    Since AUS is moving to the AFC as at 1 January 2006, I predict that they (representing OCEANIA in this WC Finals) will be in the same pot as the four Asian teams (AFC), so as not to have them drawn against each other, in the group stages.

    I also predict that the three remaining non-seeded (Mexico being seeded) North/Central American teams will also be in the same pot, as the five teams above.
     
  3. JanBalk

    JanBalk Member+

    Jun 9, 2004
    The group of death is going whatever group gets one seeded and two Euros and the group which get US (who is clearly the strongest non-European non-seeded team (if teh seededs are done as the last WC)).

    If that happens to be the same group it will really live up to the name.
     
  4. Gibraldo

    Gibraldo Member+

    radnicki nis
    Serbia
    Nov 17, 2005
    Club:
    FK Crvena Zvezda Beograd
    I don`t think so:

    Mexico, Switzerland, Ukraine, Togo does not look like a group of death.
    Germany, Netherlands, Paraguay, USA seems more to be one.
     
  5. JanBalk

    JanBalk Member+

    Jun 9, 2004
    and the group which get US
    I fail to se how Germany, Netherlands, Paraguay, USA do not contain the US.

    Further I didn't mean to say that any groups that fulfill one of those conditions will be a group of death but that any group of death will fulfill one of those conditions.
     
  6. lump1

    lump1 New Member

    Jun 20, 2004
    I'm still not 100% sure I follow all the rules about groupings, but from what I've read, this sounds possible:

    Brazil, Ivory Coast, Netherlands, Portugal

    I hope it doesn't happen. This group would be such death it would almost spoil the tournament. In any case, with the Netherlands being not seeded, they are a necessary ingredient in every group of death. With Brazil being the best of the seeds, they are the other necessary ingredient. The only debate I'd entertain is about who the other two teams would be. And if I understand it right, one of them can be an unseeded Euro team. Besides Portugal I'd also consider the Czechs and Swedes as being pretty deathly. As far as the fourth team goes, I had the impression that Brazil must get an African team. If that's wrong and any non-Euro-or-South-American team would work, I'd say Korea. Ouch, what a death!
     
  7. ursula

    ursula Member

    Feb 21, 1999
    Republic of Cascadia

    It won't. Portugal and Holland are in the same pot and so can't be drawn with each other.
     
  8. fh 1

    fh 1 New Member

    Oct 14, 2001
    Croatia
    The group of death could be this time: Brazil, Australia, Netherlands, Serbia :eek:

    Anyways, the group with Serbia will be probably the strongest this time, as there'll be an additional European, which are all strong and one of Bra, Arg, Mex and these are anything but walkovers. There will also be an African side, which are improving from WC to WC or AUS or one of the weaker South Americans but strong enough to beat anyone.
     
  9. lump1

    lump1 New Member

    Jun 20, 2004
    Got it. The pot setup was made clear on a different thread. So I ammend my suggestion: Brazil, Netherlands, Serbia, (Korea or Japan)
     
  10. titanicsmarty

    titanicsmarty Member

    Nov 2, 2004
    This also can't happen -- Serbia cannot be in the same group as one of the teams from pot four.

    If you have Brazil, Netherlands and Serbia, the fourth team must be one of the Africans or Australia.
     
  11. o_l_coach

    o_l_coach New Member

    Jun 14, 2003
    USA
    Group of death MUST include USA

    A group of death should have at least 3 teams ranked in the top 15 in the world. With the way the pots are set up, the only candidates from pot 4 are the USA or Japan. The only candidates in pot 3 are the Czech Republic, Holland, Sweden or Portugal. No one in pot 2 is in the top 25.

    A group of death would include a combination of the 6 teams listed and a seed.

    From FIFA rankings, the highest ranking combination would be:
    Brazil, Tunisia, Czech Rep., USA

    On the other hand the lowest ranking combo would be:
    Germany, Angola, Ukraine, T&T
     
  12. Colm

    Colm Member

    Aug 17, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Tottenham Hotspur FC
    Nat'l Team:
    --other--
    theres always a group of death in each world cup

    1986

    Denmark
    West Germany
    Hungary
    Scotland

    1990

    England
    Ireland
    Holland
    Egypt

    1994

    Mexico
    Ireland
    Italy
    Norway

    1998

    Nigeria
    Paraguay
    Spain
    Bulgaria

    2002

    Sweden
    England
    Argentina
    Nigeria
     
  13. MassachusettsRef

    MassachusettsRef Moderator
    Staff Member

    Apr 30, 2001
    Washington, DC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    A "group of death" has always, in my mind at least, been defined as one where 4 teams of relatively equal quality that are all expected to progress far in the tournament (prior to the draw) are grouped together. A group with Brazil, Netherlands and the next two best possible teams (Ivory Coast and USA, maybe?) is a very, very tough group, but it's not a Group of Death because most rational people will overwhelmingly still pick Brazil and Netherlands to advance. Such a group would spell unfortunate death for the USA and Ivory Coast, but it would not be the vaunted "Group of Death"

    A true "Group of Death" should have most fans incapable of being certain as to which two teams will progress. 2002 provides a great example (England, Argentina, Sweden, Nigeria) as does 1998 (Spain, Nigeria, Paraguay, Bulgaria). The alleged "groups of death" from 1994 (Italy, Ireland, Mexico, Norway) and 1990 (England, Ireland, Netherlands, Egypt) were not really all that tough to predict, since three teams could progress and most were able to accurately predict that Norway and Egypt wouldn't make the second round.

    In my mind, because parity has increased so much in recent years, there are several different combinations that could constitute this year's Group of Death. First, because I think such a group shouldn't have Argentina, Brazil or Germany, because almost everyone expects those 3 to advance easily (from the seeds). I'd also leave aside Mexico for a second (although there is a scenario where Mexico could head the Group of Death). The toughest two teams, unquestionably in my mind, in the second pot are Ivory Coast and Paraguay. The third post does have the Dutch, but they are favorites in any group not headed by Brazil, so leave them aside and focus on the Czechs, Portuguese and Swedes. Finally, the USA, Koreans and Japanese are the toughest in Pot 4. So, a Group of Death will have some combination of the following teams:

    A England/Spain/France/Italy
    B Ivory Coast/Paraguay
    C Czech Republic/Sweden/Portugal
    D USA/Korea/Japan

    Any combination of 4 you make from those above teams and you have a group that most fans would disagree significantly on as to who would advance to the second round. Spain/Paraguay/Sweden/Japan would not contain any favorites to win the World Cup, but it would undoubtedly still constitute a true "Group of Death".

    Finally, Mexico could lead the Group of Death if it draws Serbia and any of the teams I listed from Pots B and C above. Again, there'd be no favorites to win the Cup from such a group, but most would have a difficult time deciding which 2 would progress.
     
  14. tamachan

    tamachan New Member

    Nov 26, 2005
    Australia
    This is the ultimate group of death!!!!

    Brazil
    Netherlands
    Ghana
    Serbia & Montenegro


    Even the Brasilians would be worried with this one :eek:
     
  15. sinner78

    sinner78 BigSoccer Supporter

    Nov 7, 2001
    Re: This is the ultimate group of death!!!!

    Id put ivory coast above ghana .But yeah that group is a real tough cookie.
     
  16. Fiorentina lives!

    May 5, 2004
    Let me try a guess:

    England
    Portugal
    USA
    Paraguay
    :D

    Or a decaf one:

    Mexico
    Serbia-Montenegro
    Sweden
    Paraguay
     
  17. Fiorentina lives!

    May 5, 2004
    On the other hand you could have the anti-death group:

    Germany
    Switzerland
    Togo
    Trinidad & Tobago

    Just to make sure the hosts are awrightie :p
     
  18. Team Melli forever

    Jul 11, 2004
    Nat'l Team:
    Iran
    Brazil
    Czech/Holland
    Paraguay/CIV
    Iran/US

    There's your group of death
     
  19. tamachan

    tamachan New Member

    Nov 26, 2005
    Australia
    If they draw pot 3 last cant Serbia be grouped with a team from pot 4?
     
  20. Autogolazo

    Autogolazo BigSoccer Supporter

    Feb 19, 2000
    Bombay Beach, CA
    Mexico Holland Serbia Paraguay

    That's one possible GofD

    Argentina Holland Serbia Ivory Coast

    That's pretty GofD-like, too.

    Basically, a group of Bra/Arg/Mex + Serbia + Holland/Portugal/Sweden/Croatia/Czech + Aus/Iv.C./Ghana/Paraguay is going to be a Group of Death. (Paraguay can only be with Mexico).

    I don't consider Ukraine-Switzerland-Poland or Togo-Angola-Tunisia-Ecuador to be Group of Death material.

    THUS, Argentina and Brazil each have a 1/3 shot at getting Serbia. Add to that a 5/8 shot at a tough Euro team. Add to that a 3/6 shot (can't get Paraguay or Ecuador) at a tough Pot 2 team. What's that make? 5/48.

    Looks like both Argentina and Brazil have about a 1/9 shot at a true group of death IF it's defined as having two Euros.

    Mexico has a 1/3 shot at Serbia, a 4/8 shot at a tough Pot 2 team, and a 5/8 shot at a tough Euro pot team. 5/48 or 1 in 9.

    If Mexico avoid Serbia, however, they stand an excellent chance of avoiding a Group of Death, as they can't face the USA and only Korea in Pot 4 (other than Serbia) is a side I think that could give people trouble.
     
  21. lamrof

    lamrof Member

    Apr 8, 2005
    Hard to believe England and Sweden made it out of this group.
     
  22. Colm

    Colm Member

    Aug 17, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Tottenham Hotspur FC
    Nat'l Team:
    --other--
    I wasn't suprised England made it out of the group, we were expected to come 2nd behind Argentina

    It was Sweden who suprised so many in that group.
     
  23. superdave

    superdave Member+

    Jul 14, 1999
    VB, VA
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Except, the Group of Death is often just the result of the media having months to talk about the World Cup, but no matches.

    In retrospect, CLEARLY the G.O.D. was Brazil, Turkey, Costa Rica, and (IIRC) China. In retrospect, US-Portugal-Poland-SoKo was arguably a tougher group.

    You know why that was considered the G.O.D., Colm? Because Nigeria was the only African team Europe respected. So the G.O.D. would be the toughest group that had either Mexico or Nigeria. But Nigeria just wasn't that good even coming into the World Cup. They just had alot of famous players, and had looked good in group play in '98 before being humiliated by Denmark.

    In reality, it was just a group where Sweden surprised in a good way and Argentina surprised in a bad way. Sorta like the Senegal-France group.

    Given the paucity of international matches in general, and especially the paucity of meaningful interconfederational matches, it's pretty tough to have an informed discussion.

    And since FIFA has decided that the 9th UEFA team can't be in the same group as the US or Japan, I don't think there will be a true G.O.D. this time. Sure, there will be a group that gets the label. The media have to discuss something. But unless Brazil is in a group with the Czechs or the Dutch, *AND* with Japan or the US, it'll be a false label.

    EDIT: or maybe Iran, too. But I think (and I'm sure the vociferous Persian contingent :D at BS will correct me if I'm wrong, since I'm too lazy to look it up) Iran's qualifying campaign wasn't that good.
     
  24. Colm

    Colm Member

    Aug 17, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Tottenham Hotspur FC
    Nat'l Team:
    --other--
    LOL!

    in terms of quality, Argentina, England, Nigeria and Sweden was easily the tough group, all very good teams in that group, It was easily the group of death, in each countries media it was the group of death.
     
  25. superdave

    superdave Member+

    Jul 14, 1999
    VB, VA
    Club:
    DC United
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Better than a group including the most dominant champion (by scorelines) ever, and a semifinalist, and a team that lost out to that semifinalist on GD??? Even the foul stench of China couldn't bring this group down to the Ar-Eng-Swe-Nig level.

    Please, lay down the pipe.
     

Share This Page