I love both and think with the number of fixtures we need both. The question seems to be who should be first choice. I have decided a way to settle the score. After reading some of the bitter rants on football365.com, it seems easy. A fight. That's right. Every great team in every sport has the finess guys and the tough guys. We got the best finess guys we can hope for in Henry, DB10, Pires, Cole. We got tough guys like Sol, Lehmann, and Vieira. We need another tough guy and we could maybe set up a charity boxing match over the summer. (this is tongue in cheek of course) They say Gilberto is the bigger, better and tougher defender, but Edu has this 1930's mobster look to him when he gets mad. Just let'em fight it out.