Coach Tracking Thread

JasonMa · Jul 7, 2019

Season-by-season; Asterisks indicate years we missed the playoffs:

1. 2016 - Mastroeni - 1.706
2. 2002 - Hankinson - 1.534
3. 2010 - Smith - 1.533
4. 1999 - Mooch - 1.5
4. 2013 - Pareja - 1.5
6. 2011 - Smith - 1.441
7. 2005 - Clavijo - 1.406
8. 1998 - Mooch - 1.375
9. 2004 - Hankinson - 1.367
10. 2000 - Mooch - 1.344
11. 2003 - Hankinson - 1.333
11. 2009 - Smith - 1.333*
13. 2006 - Clavijo - 1.28125
14. 2008 - Clavijo/Smith - 1.267*
15. 1997 - Mooch - 1.1875
16. 2007 - Clavijo - 1.167*
17. 2012 - Pareja - 1.08823*
17. 2015 - Mastroeni - 1.08823*
19. 2019 - Hudson/Casey - 1.000
20. 2017 - Mastroeni/Cooke - 0.971*
21. 2014 - Mastroeni - 0.941*
22. 2018 - Hudson - 0.912*
23. 1996 - Houghton/Wegerle - 0.906*
24. 2001 - Hankinson - 0.885*

All-Time Overall:

1. Casey - 10 Games - 1.70
2. Smith - 104 Games - 1.43
3. Mooch - 128 Games - 1.41
4. Hankinson - 114 Games - 1.29
4. Pareja - 68 Games - 1.29
6. Mastroeni - 124 Games - 1.20
7. Clavijo - 114 Games - 1.18
8. Houghton - 31 Games - 1.06
9. Cooke - 12 Games - 0.92
10. Hudson - 43 Games - 0.77
11. Wegerle - 1 Game - 0.00

Playoff series records:

1. Smith 4-1 - .800 - Won MLS Cup
2. Clavijo - 2-2 - .500
3. Mastroeni - 1-1 - .500
4. Mooch 2-4 - .333 - MLS Cup appearance
5. Hankinson - 1-3 - .250
6. Pareja - 0-1 - .000
7. Houghton - Never qualified - N/A
7. Wegerle - Never qualified - N/A
7. Cooke - Never qualified - N/A
7. Hudson - Never qualified - N/A
7. Casey - Never qualified - N/A

JasonMa · Aug 5, 2019

Season-by-season; Asterisks indicate years we missed the playoffs:

1. 2016 - Mastroeni - 1.706
2. 2002 - Hankinson - 1.534
3. 2010 - Smith - 1.533
4. 1999 - Mooch - 1.5
4. 2013 - Pareja - 1.5
6. 2011 - Smith - 1.441
7. 2005 - Clavijo - 1.406
8. 1998 - Mooch - 1.375
9. 2004 - Hankinson - 1.367
10. 2000 - Mooch - 1.344
11. 2003 - Hankinson - 1.333
11. 2009 - Smith - 1.333*
13. 2006 - Clavijo - 1.28125
14. 2008 - Clavijo/Smith - 1.267*
15. 1997 - Mooch - 1.1875
16. 2007 - Clavijo - 1.167*
17. 2012 - Pareja - 1.08823*
17. 2015 - Mastroeni - 1.08823*
19. 2019 - Hudson/Casey - 1.000
20. 2017 - Mastroeni/Cooke - 0.971*
21. 2014 - Mastroeni - 0.941*
22. 2018 - Hudson - 0.912*
23. 1996 - Houghton/Wegerle - 0.906*
24. 2001 - Hankinson - 0.885*

All-Time Overall:

1. Casey - 14 Games - 1.50
2. Smith - 104 Games - 1.43
3. Mooch - 128 Games - 1.41
4. Hankinson - 114 Games - 1.29
4. Pareja - 68 Games - 1.29
6. Mastroeni - 124 Games - 1.20
7. Clavijo - 114 Games - 1.18
8. Houghton - 31 Games - 1.06
9. Cooke - 12 Games - 0.92
10. Hudson - 43 Games - 0.77
11. Wegerle - 1 Game - 0.00

Playoff series records:

1. Smith 4-1 - .800 - Won MLS Cup
2. Clavijo - 2-2 - .500
3. Mastroeni - 1-1 - .500
4. Mooch 2-4 - .333 - MLS Cup appearance
5. Hankinson - 1-3 - .250
6. Pareja - 0-1 - .000
7. Houghton - Never qualified - N/A
7. Wegerle - Never qualified - N/A
7. Cooke - Never qualified - N/A
7. Hudson - Never qualified - N/A
7. Casey - Never qualified - N/A

m vann · Aug 11, 2019

Petke canned. For the love of God, I hope they don’t go after him. Never a fan of his temperament. It always causes problems. Always impedes his coaching. That’s evident in the reasoning for his firing. Stay clear away, please!

Totoro · Aug 12, 2019

Is that guy going to get another job after this? There have been multiple temper tantrums, right? Then this last one was pretty bad. And he doesn't have Miguel Herrera's resume.

Centennial · Aug 14, 2019

Totoro said: ↑

Is that guy going to get another job after this? ...
Click to expand...

I sure hope not.

Bridgeman · Aug 15, 2019

You guys ever heard of Earl Weaver?

therapidsnumbernine · Aug 21, 2019

Montreal sacked Garde and hired Cabrera today.

https://www.impactmontreal.com/en/post/2019/08/21/head-coach-rémi-garde-dismissed

Centennial · Aug 21, 2019

therapidsnumbernine said: ↑

Montreal sacked Garde and hired Cabrera today.

https://www.impactmontreal.com/en/post/2019/08/21/head-coach-rémi-garde-dismissed
Click to expand...

So, in summary that article says they had so much respect for Remi but he sucks.

fortcollins · Aug 24, 2019

Montreal seems to be one of the teams that can't quite get traction. They have some decent players, a cool stadium, and passionate supporters. They always seem to be lacking key components of a team, and none of their head coaches can quite get them to the next level.

JasonMa · Aug 25, 2019

Since July 7th Casey's PPG average has fallen from 1.7 to 1.39.

JasonMa · Aug 25, 2019

Season-by-season; Asterisks indicate years we missed the playoffs:

1. 2016 - Mastroeni - 1.706
2. 2002 - Hankinson - 1.534
3. 2010 - Smith - 1.533
4. 1999 - Mooch - 1.5
4. 2013 - Pareja - 1.5
6. 2011 - Smith - 1.441
7. 2005 - Clavijo - 1.406
8. 1998 - Mooch - 1.375
9. 2004 - Hankinson - 1.367
10. 2000 - Mooch - 1.344
11. 2003 - Hankinson - 1.333
11. 2009 - Smith - 1.333*
13. 2006 - Clavijo - 1.28125
14. 2008 - Clavijo/Smith - 1.267*
15. 1997 - Mooch - 1.1875
16. 2007 - Clavijo - 1.167*
17. 2012 - Pareja - 1.08823*
17. 2015 - Mastroeni - 1.08823*
19. 2019 - Hudson/Casey/Fraser - 1.000
20. 2017 - Mastroeni/Cooke - 0.971*
21. 2014 - Mastroeni - 0.941*
22. 2018 - Hudson - 0.912*
23. 1996 - Houghton/Wegerle - 0.906*
24. 2001 - Hankinson - 0.885*

All-Time Overall:

1. Smith - 104 Games - 1.43
2. Mooch - 128 Games - 1.41
3. Casey - 18 Games - 1.39
4. Hankinson - 114 Games - 1.29
4. Pareja - 68 Games - 1.29
6. Mastroeni - 124 Games - 1.20
7. Clavijo - 114 Games - 1.18
8. Houghton - 31 Games - 1.06
9. Cooke - 12 Games - 0.92
10. Hudson - 43 Games - 0.77
11. Wegerle - 1 Game - 0.00
12. Fraser - 0 Games - 0.00

Playoff series records:

1. Smith 4-1 - .800 - Won MLS Cup
2. Clavijo - 2-2 - .500
3. Mastroeni - 1-1 - .500
4. Mooch 2-4 - .333 - MLS Cup appearance
5. Hankinson - 1-3 - .250
6. Pareja - 0-1 - .000
7. Houghton - Never qualified - N/A
7. Wegerle - Never qualified - N/A
7. Cooke - Never qualified - N/A
7. Hudson - Never qualified - N/A
7. Casey - Never qualified - N/A
7. Fraser - Never qualified - N/A

COMtnGuy · Aug 26, 2019

JasonMa said: ↑

Since July 7th Casey's PPG average has fallen from 1.7 to 1.39.
Click to expand...

Pretty outstanding given AH's player comments.

Man, Wish CC had gotten 1 more win to tie AH in that category.

JasonMa · Sep 12, 2019

Hudson - 33 points in 43 games in charge of the Rapids
Casey+Fraser - 34 points in 21 games in charge of the Rapids

JasonMa · Sep 21, 2019

Season-by-season; Asterisks indicate years we missed the playoffs:

1. 2016 - Mastroeni - 1.706
2. 2002 - Hankinson - 1.534
3. 2010 - Smith - 1.533
4. 1999 - Mooch - 1.5
4. 2013 - Pareja - 1.5
6. 2011 - Smith - 1.441
7. 2005 - Clavijo - 1.406
8. 1998 - Mooch - 1.375
9. 2004 - Hankinson - 1.367
10. 2000 - Mooch - 1.344
11. 2003 - Hankinson - 1.333
11. 2009 - Smith - 1.333*
13. 2006 - Clavijo - 1.28125
14. 2008 - Clavijo/Smith - 1.267*
15. 2019 - Hudson/Casey/Fraser - 1.219
16. 1997 - Mooch - 1.1875
17. 2007 - Clavijo - 1.167*
18. 2012 - Pareja - 1.08823*
18. 2015 - Mastroeni - 1.08823*
20. 2017 - Mastroeni/Cooke - 0.971*
21. 2014 - Mastroeni - 0.941*
22. 2018 - Hudson - 0.912*
23. 1996 - Houghton/Wegerle - 0.906*
24. 2001 - Hankinson - 0.885*

All-Time Overall:

1. Fraser - 5 Games - 2.40
2. Smith - 104 Games - 1.43
3. Mooch - 128 Games - 1.41
4. Casey - 18 Games - 1.39
5. Hankinson - 114 Games - 1.29
5. Pareja - 68 Games - 1.29
7. Mastroeni - 124 Games - 1.20
8. Clavijo - 114 Games - 1.18
9. Houghton - 31 Games - 1.06
10. Cooke - 12 Games - 0.92
11. Hudson - 43 Games - 0.77
12. Wegerle - 1 Game - 0.00

Playoff series records:

1. Smith 4-1 - .800 - Won MLS Cup
2. Clavijo - 2-2 - .500
3. Mastroeni - 1-1 - .500
4. Mooch 2-4 - .333 - MLS Cup appearance
5. Hankinson - 1-3 - .250
6. Pareja - 0-1 - .000
7. Houghton - Never qualified - N/A
7. Wegerle - Never qualified - N/A
7. Cooke - Never qualified - N/A
7. Hudson - Never qualified - N/A
7. Casey - Never qualified - N/A
7. Fraser - Never qualified - N/A

JasonMa · Sep 22, 2019

BTW, Fraser is now guaranteed to end the season with the best PPG average of Rapids coaches (in an extremely small sample size, obviously).

This season will finish somewhere between 13th and 17th all-time.

Rod1916 · Sep 22, 2019

JasonMa said: ↑

BTW, Fraser is now guaranteed to end the season with the best PPG average of Rapids coaches (in an extremely small sample size, obviously).

This season will finish somewhere between 13th and 17th all-time.
Click to expand...

It is interesting to see "years we missed the playoffs". This year is ending up better than years we made the playoffs. Wish we still had that ability to enter in the Eastern conference!

(and damn Hudson for such a poor start. We may have had some hope had he won at least a couple.)

JasonMa · Oct 6, 2019

Season-by-season; Asterisks indicate years we missed the playoffs:

1. 2016 - Mastroeni - 1.706
2. 2002 - Hankinson - 1.534
3. 2010 - Smith - 1.533
4. 1999 - Mooch - 1.5
4. 2013 - Pareja - 1.5
6. 2011 - Smith - 1.441
7. 2005 - Clavijo - 1.406
8. 1998 - Mooch - 1.375
9. 2004 - Hankinson - 1.367
10. 2000 - Mooch - 1.344
11. 2003 - Hankinson - 1.333
11. 2009 - Smith - 1.333*
13. 2006 - Clavijo - 1.28125
14. 2008 - Clavijo/Smith - 1.267*
15. 2019 - Hudson/Casey/Fraser - 1.232*
16. 1997 - Mooch - 1.1875
17. 2007 - Clavijo - 1.167*
18. 2012 - Pareja - 1.08823*
18. 2015 - Mastroeni - 1.08823*
20. 2017 - Mastroeni/Cooke - 0.971*
21. 2014 - Mastroeni - 0.941*
22. 2018 - Hudson - 0.912*
23. 1996 - Houghton/Wegerle - 0.906*
24. 2001 - Hankinson - 0.885*

All-Time Overall:

1. Fraser - 7 Games - 2.14
2. Smith - 104 Games - 1.43
3. Mooch - 128 Games - 1.41
4. Casey - 18 Games - 1.39
5. Hankinson - 114 Games - 1.29
5. Pareja - 68 Games - 1.29
7. Mastroeni - 124 Games - 1.20
8. Clavijo - 114 Games - 1.18
9. Houghton - 31 Games - 1.06
10. Cooke - 12 Games - 0.92
11. Hudson - 43 Games - 0.77
12. Wegerle - 1 Game - 0.00

Playoff series records:

1. Smith 4-1 - .800 - Won MLS Cup
2. Clavijo - 2-2 - .500
3. Mastroeni - 1-1 - .500
4. Mooch 2-4 - .333 - MLS Cup appearance
5. Hankinson - 1-3 - .250
6. Pareja - 0-1 - .000
7. Houghton - Never qualified - N/A
7. Wegerle - Never qualified - N/A
7. Cooke - Never qualified - N/A
7. Hudson - Never qualified - N/A
7. Casey - Never qualified - N/A
7. Fraser - Never qualified - N/A

Quinn 33 · Oct 9, 2019

So quickly glancing at some stats, @JasonMa may have better data than I do, but I think there is a compelling argument to be made that Hudson is quite possibly the worst coaching hire is MLS history...at least compared to guys that managed to coach at least one full season.

Hudson's career PPG with us was 0.77. The only guy I can find that had a lower PPG for a season or more was Bora Milutinovic at 0.64. Anybody that's lower than him was either an interim coach, or was shoved out the door before the end of their first season. Even the Brad Feiedel train-wreck still managed to scrape together a 0.94 PPG.

JasonMa · Oct 9, 2019

Quinn 33 said: ↑

Hudson's career PPG with us was 0.77. The only guy I can find that had a lower PPG for a season or more was Bora Milutinovic at 0.64.
Click to expand...

And at least Bora came with a track record that made hiring him somewhat logical for a MLS team.

TheWarmBurger · Oct 9, 2019

JasonMa said: ↑

And at least Bora came with a track record that made hiring him somewhat logical for a MLS team.
Click to expand...

Wait....you mean to tell me that Hudson’s pre-Rapids track record of 39w-31t-46l as gaffer for teams such as the Real Maryland Monarchs, Bahrain, and Newport County isn’t an exciting pedigree? Or that his best stints were as the Bahrain U23’s and New Zealand U23’s?

Now if you told me you were bringing him in as an assistant/youth developer of some kind that’s one thing.

But head coach? He’s actually part of what drove me to bigsoccer

Totoro · Oct 16, 2019

Quinn 33 said: ↑

Hudson's career PPG with us was 0.77. The only guy I can find that had a lower PPG for a season or more was Bora Milutinovic at 0.64. Anybody that's lower than him was either an interim coach, or was shoved out the door before the end of their first season. Even the Brad Feiedel train-wreck still managed to scrape together a 0.94 PPG.
Click to expand...

.77 PPG is pretty horrible in MLS. I was flipping through standings year by year, from 2012 on. (2012 was when the league went to 34 games --I made that cutoff because I didn't want to look more more than that/). Looks like there were 4 years of the 8 where a team did that poorly, 5 teams total:

Cinci in 2019
San Jose in 2018
Chivas and DC United in 2013 (banner year for bad clubs, TFC also did 0.85/game)
TFC in 2012.

Montreal was close in 2014 with 0.82/game.

Great job, Huddie!

fortcollins · Oct 16, 2019

Hey now. Remember that Hudson didn't have players with any talent.

Totoro · Oct 17, 2019

Is Hudson coaching the US men's national team?

COMtnGuy · Oct 17, 2019

Totoro said: ↑

Is Hudson coaching the US men's national team?
Click to expand...

If not they are religiously following his podcast on coaching/ attacking soccer.

JasonMa · Apr 11, 2020

Figured I might as well update this for the 2020 season

Season-by-season; Asterisks indicate years we missed the playoffs:

1. 2020 - Fraser - 3.0
2. 2016 - Mastroeni - 1.706
3. 2002 - Hankinson - 1.534
4. 2010 - Smith - 1.533
5. 1999 - Mooch - 1.5
5. 2013 - Pareja - 1.5
7. 2011 - Smith - 1.441
8. 2005 - Clavijo - 1.406
9. 1998 - Mooch - 1.375
10. 2004 - Hankinson - 1.367
11. 2000 - Mooch - 1.344
12. 2003 - Hankinson - 1.333
12. 2009 - Smith - 1.333*
14. 2006 - Clavijo - 1.28125
15. 2008 - Clavijo/Smith - 1.267*
16. 2019 - Hudson/Casey/Fraser - 1.232*
17. 1997 - Mooch - 1.1875
18. 2007 - Clavijo - 1.167*
19. 2012 - Pareja - 1.08823*
19. 2015 - Mastroeni - 1.08823*
21. 2017 - Mastroeni/Cooke - 0.971*
22. 2014 - Mastroeni - 0.941*
23. 2018 - Hudson - 0.912*
24. 1996 - Houghton/Wegerle - 0.906*
25. 2001 - Hankinson - 0.885*

All-Time Overall:

1. Fraser - 9 Games - 2.33
2. Smith - 104 Games - 1.43
3. Mooch - 128 Games - 1.41
4. Casey - 18 Games - 1.39
5. Hankinson - 114 Games - 1.29
5. Pareja - 68 Games - 1.29
7. Mastroeni - 124 Games - 1.20
8. Clavijo - 114 Games - 1.18
9. Houghton - 31 Games - 1.06
10. Cooke - 12 Games - 0.92
11. Hudson - 43 Games - 0.77
12. Wegerle - 1 Game - 0.00

Playoff series records:

1. Smith 4-1 - .800 - Won MLS Cup
2. Clavijo - 2-2 - .500
3. Mastroeni - 1-1 - .500
4. Mooch 2-4 - .333 - MLS Cup appearance
5. Hankinson - 1-3 - .250
6. Pareja - 0-1 - .000
7. Houghton - Never qualified - N/A
7. Wegerle - Never qualified - N/A
7. Cooke - Never qualified - N/A
7. Hudson - Never qualified - N/A
7. Casey - Never qualified - N/A
7. Fraser - Never qualified - N/A