How about a "both picks were good" option? I think they were good moves. United needed a keeper, and we got our defensive midfielder of the future who's also a P40. Three P40 draftees is a good day in my opinion. Eskandarian, Stokes, Warren, and Carroll were all excellent collegiate palyers with potential to be good pros. I tip my hat to the United staff.
Carroll is a great player.. i think he and stokes will def produce more than esky.... i think esky will do well but not live up to the hype