Polls like this are about as usefull as a who has better hair... Dunseth, Denton, or McBride circa 97, or Graziana 2002 So no, I won't take it seriously, I still say Michael Ritch.
Andrulis. His leadership has been so powerful and his presence so commanding on the side of the field that it almost seems like a 12th player is on for the Crew. . . . er...Buddle.
Who is the best Player on the Columbus Crew Dunseth, no wait, Buddle ... Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh (growling and bellowing beast noises).
Pretty soon it will go the way of Sanskrit and Aramaic. As for the topic at hand - Jeff Matteo; the guy won $35 for me. He's class all the way.
Probably the most proven is McBride. But I don't get the question, this season? Heck, that'd probably still be McBride. Also, best Crew player at what?