News: Dutch players at home and abroad worthy to be tracked in connection with the Dutch NT - Part 4

Discussion in 'The Netherlands' started by DRB300, Sep 2, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. thatkid

    thatkid Member

    Jun 21, 2010
    Netherlands
    Club:
    --other--
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    You didn't watch the Southampton vs United game?
    van Dijk vs Martial was.. :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:


    Brenet, just for the record, is absolutely shit and shouldn't be mentioned in this thread.

    Tete btw is not going to contain Ronaldo or Neymar, ever. He is not that good, I think he will become a very good subtop player. like DRB, I expect more for the other two upcoming Ajax right backs, but for the next 3 - 4 years, Tete looks more than enough for this NT.
     
  2. DRB300

    DRB300 Member+

    Sep 21, 2007
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    Yeah that was bad. His game against Swansea was an improvement though. Also scored. The problem with all our defenders is that they make mistakes at their club. Non are elite. Is Bruma so much better? De Vrij is injured and not selected.
     
  3. thatkid

    thatkid Member

    Jun 21, 2010
    Netherlands
    Club:
    --other--
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    We were talking about how or our defenders would perform against top class attackers and with van Dijk we already have an example. Also keep in mind that against swansea there was little pressure on Southampton defence, because the midfield (and Tadic) was incredible.

    Absolutely ********ing not! :thumbsdown:
    I'd take even Veltman over Bruma.
     
    Orange14 repped this.
  4. DRB300

    DRB300 Member+

    Sep 21, 2007
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    Ah, I understand. No the CB discussion was a result from what Keko said, the Tete discussion regarding how he would do vs Ronaldo and Neymar atc was a result of the claim from JC-14 in another post. Two separate things.

    So regarding the CB discussion we were discussing if Dijk pushes Blind to 5 instead of playing on 4 for the NT as he currently does for his club. Keko likes a de Vrij Dijk center while I think I prefer Blind on 4 and as de Vrij is injured I suggested we can also play van Dijk next to him. Veltman is the same to me. Also a defender who makes his mistakes. I have not seen too much to of him recently so I take it he is doing fine.

    What is your backline configuration for the upcoming qualification games?
     
  5. Orange14

    Orange14 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Apr 27, 2007
    Bethesda, MD
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    Well Ajax have only conceded two goals in the league so far this season and have seven straight clean sheeets at home going back to last season. The defenders must be doing something right. I'm not sure that Veltman is the greatest defender but he's certainly better than Bruma. van Beek should also be in the mix for the right side as well.
     
  6. Laurent75

    Laurent75 Member

    Aug 2, 2014
    #2906 Laurent75, Sep 27, 2015
    Last edited: Sep 27, 2015
    It's funny cause we have another example : Bruma was absolutly great against Martial few days earlier.

    Van Dijk had a bad game but it's not like he scored a own goal, conceded a penalty and got a red card on Martial, he just had problems like every player can have, who are the world top defenders then ? Ramos ? I can't count how many times he was shit in his career, Thiago Silva had some awful periods...

    It's not really fair to judge players on their form/bad games, I prefer to judge them on their qualities and defects. Actually I see more potential in Bruma than Veltman. Bruma is strong, can mark quite well and got a certain pure speed. His passing is poor though.
    Veltman passing is better but Veltman is soft, slow and inspire no confidence at all, big lack of power charisma/authority...

    Knowing that we spent the last 10 years with defenders like Mathijsen and Heitinga and talways had to rely on Van der Saar/Stekelenburg to save our ass, I prefer to work with Bruma and try to get a new Vlaar rather than with Veltman. What can we try to get with Veltman ?

    That's also why I mentionned Brenet here. He made horrible blunders in the past and isn't very reliable yet but I see a very interesting material to exploit. I see speed, I see power, I see grit, I see a good projection forward.
     
  7. Orange14

    Orange14 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Apr 27, 2007
    Bethesda, MD
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    Bruma and speed don't belong in the same sentence; he also lacks some quickness that Veltman has. Veltman's principal problem is that he's a touch too lightweight and small. Cannavaro made up for his short stature with incredible strength and positioning that could keep opposing strikers off balance. There is nobody on the Dutch NT that has those skills.

    If you are talking about the last 10 years of the NT you need to include Oojier who was grossly underrated as a central defender. I also think you are exaggerating the role of the keepers. If you go back to the 2006 WC and look at the main tournaments, I don't think the defense was all that bad. 2006 - lost to Portugal in a messy match with bad officiating; the Maniche goal was not the fault of the central defenders. 2008 - van Basten was way out managed by Hiddink. 2010 - down to 10 men and it still took a special goal by Iniesta to winit 1-0. 2012 - disaster all around in the Euros. 2014 - van Gaal put in a pretty good defensive system and had Mascherano not intervened, Robben would have had the game winner.
     
  8. Laurent75

    Laurent75 Member

    Aug 2, 2014
    Bruma is definitly not quick or agile but he got pure speed, just like Vlaar. I'm sure he beats Veltman on a 100meters sprint, Veltman got no muscles to run.

    To talk about our keepers and defenders performances...I agree that it wasn't that bad in 2006, even if I remember Mathijsen making a couple of fouls in the box on Drogba, using his arms many times and being lucky that no penalty was given...But it was globally ok.
    2008 ? Van Der Sar was very important. Everyone focused on the goals and counters against Italy and France but he had a couple of crucial saves in those games as well. Against Russia he definitly saved our ass, Russia had 11 shots on goal, it could be worse than 3-1.

    2010 the defence was bad. Van Bommel-Nigel gave a sentiment of security and we had a lot of possession but I can rembember Japan was going to equalize in the last minutes, against Slovakia Stekelenburg had a great save in the last minutes as well, we were suffering and they even scored after. Against Brazil the defence started awful and took a first goal and Stekelenburg had a great save on Kaka, it could be 2-0 before half time. Against Spain Stek had a good save again at the beginning on a header by Ramos. Two other ones on shots by Fabregas and Navas. They could score before.

    2012 the defence was terrible and Stek had some good saves again against Germany, the scoreline could be worse.

    2014 the team defended very well and gave few work to Cillessen, it was the best dutch defending since EC2000 and we can mainly thank Vlaar for this...
     
  9. bunbohue

    bunbohue Member+

    Apr 5, 2005
    What about Rekik Van Dijk as CB and Blind in front of them for the last 2 qualification matches for a try?
     
    Sam_TO repped this.
  10. Sam_TO

    Sam_TO Member

    May 14, 2014
    Nat'l Team:
    Canada
    I like this pairing as well.

    Or even Rekik/Bruma can work as they're already familiar with each other during their time at PSV, but I see more potential in van Dijk than Bruma.
     
  11. Rinus127

    Rinus127 Member

    Sep 8, 2015
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
    Ziyech involved in 25 of last 26 Eredivisie goals for Twente. I am absolutely convinced that he will be a world class player . And for once I agree with Johan Derksen , he could be the playmaker of the national team for ten years. Potentially better than Afellay , Klaassen , and all the current clique.
     
  12. Rinus127

    Rinus127 Member

    Sep 8, 2015
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
  13. DRB300

    DRB300 Member+

    Sep 21, 2007
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    I don't like this reasoning. It puts the right mentality upside down. He is selected when he is selected and no ulterior motives should be at play. Actually we get to see what players are made of the right stuff and are really into playing for the NT. Do we want guys that can potentially do what happened to is in 1996? Do we want an Afellay that seems to have had a wrong influence on the group process? If 2014 learned us 1 thing it is that the group process is vital. With modest material we still got pretty far. Patience is its own filtering process to weed out the not optimal motivated.

    Let Ziyech enjoy his qualification games in Africa and maybe one day he might even play a WC. No way we should bend our selection principles for such players or any players.
     
    thatkid and Rinus127 repped this.
  14. Orange14

    Orange14 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Apr 27, 2007
    Bethesda, MD
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    But neither Afellay or Klaassen are playmakers so I don't understand this statement.
     
  15. Rinus127

    Rinus127 Member

    Sep 8, 2015
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
    Seriously, we can quibble about the positions of each other on the field , but clearly Affelay , Klaasen and Sneijder are its competitors in the Blind list. Ziyech is better than the first two named IMHO .
     
  16. thatkid

    thatkid Member

    Jun 21, 2010
    Netherlands
    Club:
    --other--
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    Yes, I agree for the most part. We have to draw our own lines. Dutch-moroccan talents shouldn't get any special treatment. However I do think Ziyech should have been selected months ago, he was being ignored unfairly. And he drew his conclusions based on the selection of a player like Klaassen before him (even binging back an Anita), I can see how frustrating that must have been.

    I'll still follow Ziyech. He is a wonderful player to look at and I think he might be next to make it big since Afellay.. As for Morocco, unfortunately I don't think he'll last long against african player for very long.
     
  17. Laurent75

    Laurent75 Member

    Aug 2, 2014
    Did anybody see how Amrabat played against Real last weekend ? He could definitly be a strong winger for us
     
  18. thatkid

    thatkid Member

    Jun 21, 2010
    Netherlands
    Club:
    --other--
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    You are talking about Nordin Amrabat right? He is a Moroccan international..
     
    Brilliant Dutch repped this.
  19. Keko

    Keko Member

    Jul 17, 2014
    Chicago
    Club:
    Feyenoord
    Is there any good article that explain what happened then?. I often hear references or allusions to that event but never knew what happened in detail, other than Davids being sent back to Holland after he insulted Hiddink.
     
  20. Well, that's my problem with gossips like about Afellay, it is all from hearsay, but not one source we have to confirm it. It is more like the appearance for the outside world that gets translated to his socalled influence. The same thing was with Klaas Jan Huntelaar. He got a load of rubbish about his "bad influence" too. I like to stick to the facts.
     
  21. Rinus127

    Rinus127 Member

    Sep 8, 2015
    Club:
    AFC Ajax
    What about Michael Kramer and Marten De Roon guy ?According echoes from Italy, De Roon realize decent performance in Bergamo
     
  22. DRB300

    DRB300 Member+

    Sep 21, 2007
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    Regarding Kramer, we also have Dost in that department. Since El Ghazi is probably going to be selected, put him in striker position.
     
  23. DRB300

    DRB300 Member+

    Sep 21, 2007
    Nat'l Team:
    Netherlands
    I think that the story was that a sense of injustice at Ajax carried over to the NT. The black players did not felt equally rewarded in terms of money than some of the white players, while I think it was a seniority problem. Blind and de Boer brothers being older than some of the black players, in any organisation the seniors make more than the juniors. I think there was also something of a bonus structure in play, but I am not sure. Anyway, things heated up further in the NT and in the end Davids went into auto destruct mode and let that issue go at the cost of the group process, the tournament and the fans.

    Apart form some details maybe being different from what I just wrote, I want to make a much bigger point. That era with Seedorf, Davids, Kluivert, Bogarde etc. had a wrong atmosphere for me at times. It were some troubled kids that did not like Dutch society so much (my claim/feeling, not theirs). Sneijder also referenced the period he came into the NT as not nice when he was eating with some people. The communication to the press was at an all time low once I saw an interview between Davids and van Dorp. Stopping early, every question was like a land mine, negative, aggressive, unsympathetic and what not. I felt as a fan that I had to be happy when 1 normal sentence was produced. There was also a misplaced arrogance from Seedorf. There is a lot of revision concerning that player, but he went into stroll mode often when playing for the NT. To me, it was all a bit toxic.

    The player that let me breath again was Dirk Kuyt. When he came into the NT and fought for every ball, it was like we finally had a guy again that would run himself off a cliff to fight for the shirt. That did not expect to be thanked and what not, but felt it was a great honor to put the shirt on. I realized how important it is to have the right culture in the NT. It is an honor, not an obligation. You don't really ant it? Excellent, Next.

    That mechanism is now also preying with the Dutch Moroccan players that might be lured into the NT. I don't want to waste time with kids that do not like Dutch society or are angry with society, or have emotional unresolved issues and have to compensate their inferiority complex by acting all arrogant in the group, creating a bad group cohesion. In the end the group of 2014 got further than the group of 1998 or all attempts of that generation. The group process is a huge thing and that starts with the right mentality. The Orange shirt must motivate, not be an institution to hijack and use as a platform for any resentment or anger or whatever. No way I want to be part of any stupid drama from some guys that happen to have a lot of talent. Rather watch to less talented people who at least ensure the right culture.
     
  24. Laurent75

    Laurent75 Member

    Aug 2, 2014
    But he could play for Holland few years ago
     
  25. Keko

    Keko Member

    Jul 17, 2014
    Chicago
    Club:
    Feyenoord
    Really interesting. It may sound a bit odd to you, but despite the apparent (or obvious) lack of a good attitude from Davids, if I had to name a player that gave his all and more ON the field like kuyt did, that one was Davids. I even remember how one time he blocked with his head a long range shot that could have easily broken a neck. Probably all the good he did on the field was overshadowed by his behavior off the field. Maybe that's why I felt he never had the recognition I thought he deserved.
     

Share This Page