I think he is a good defender. When tasked with only defending, he usually chases everyone to the other side. I have seen it many times where Aguero or Sanchez or whomever has had enough of him and heads over to the other side. 1v1, he is not that good. Almost nonexistent. Combining is ok if he gets the return ball and then crosses. If he gets the return and tries to 1v1, it goes sideways most often. So, he is not bad if you have other sources of creativity. He is not a winger. He is a serviceable right back. And he has a long throw in.