What's our best formation?

Let's say all of our players are healthy, what would you guys consider the best formation and players playing in them?

I am starting to think the 3-4-3 get's outplayed by fast, strong and athletic teams like the european giants, and if we want to compete we need to start thinking about them too instead of just Argentina and Brasil.

Not sure who would be our best CB's so I'm leaving it blank, but these guys should fight for those spots: Jara, Ponce, Contreras, Fuentes, Gonzalez. I think a 4-2-1-3 would be a good formation with a line up like this, tell me waht you guys think:

--------------------------Bravo--------------------
Vidal---?-------------------------------?---Baousejour (a la Roberto Carlos)
--------------------Medel------Carmona--------- < CDM's
------------------Valdivia/Fernandez----------------
Sanchez-----------------Suazo-------------Gonzalez

Players that should be looked at real seriously to see if they can take a starting spot IMO are Pinilla, Isla, Estrada, Tello, orellana

 

Medio sin Carmona?
De que Munoz hablas? Del de Wanderers? Tampoco lo pondria ensima de Sanchez/Pinilla or Chico Mark

 

Vidal en el mundial jugo de wing isquierdo, por lo cual lo iso mas o menos, mejor que Jara, much mejor. Y no jugo por la derecha por que puso a Isla a jugar en el mismo lado que Sanchez como en Udi.
Pero siempre se dijo que rinde mucho mas por la derecha.
Yo se que mi defensa es algo inconvencional, es mas, yo no creo que baousejous nunca a jugado en ese puesto. Pero digo que lo pondria ahi para provar, para ver si puede imitar lo que iso roberto carlos en Brazil (mas o menos en defensa, pero mejores wings atacando de la historia).
Pero lo de Vidal es seguro que si rinde en ese puesto. Loco en Bayern juega de defensa, medio y ahora asta de delantero. Se iso tremendo golazo el otro dia de cabeza. Imagina: Vidal y Baousejour por las bandas y defendiendo con la rapides que tienen y atacando por las bandas.
No se si trabaja lo de bose, pero si ase 70% lo de R Carlos, el lado isquierdo estaria solido.

Y yo personal mente pienso que Carmona > Medel jugando como CDM. Medel jugo tremendo como CB en el WC y si la formacion tiene a 2 CDM's pueden jugar los 2 en mi opinion.

 

Me gusta tu primera formacion. La segunda seria muy devil en defensa. Los partidos que visto a Pizarro jugar para el roma, el no pone nada de presion se tira al area a defender. Y como es tan chico que no sirve atras. On attaque si serian letales, la rapides mental que tiene es muy buena, los pases los piensa antes de recibir la pelota. Que lata que aya renunciado a la seleccion, podria ser co capitan con bravo por su experiencia y forma de jugar.

 

I'm going to type it in english because I'm much faster at typing in english:

When you play 4 defenders in the back and the players are attacking wings then you have a method to rotate players. For instance, let's say your RWD goes up by the wing then your LWD would stay back, not only that but the formation becomes a 3 - 1 - 1 - 2 - 3.
If your RWD goes up you have an option of having your right CDM covering his spot, leaving it with 4 in the back, or he also can go up and you stay with 3 defending. Your left CDM would become a center CDM (in the 3 def attack), your RWD would stay in the wing with your RFW. Your right CDM would become an attacking mid along with your other attacking mid. Your left forward wing would stay on the left side for cambios de juego. It's so much easier explaining it on a board with X's and O's but it would look something like this.

LFW--------CF---------RFW
----AM------R CDM
-----------------------RDW
---------L CDM (stays back)
LDW-------LCB-------RCB

For this you attack with 6 players with your CDM that stays back lagging behind to have a safety to play to.

attacking on the right is just the opposite. And defending it becomes a:

-----------CF-------------
LFW----------------RFW
----------AM-------------
-----L CDM----R CDM------
LDW---LCB----RCB----RDW

Now Im not sure if this is what he meant, but this is what I mean when I said I like a formation of 4-2-1-3

 

I don't like him. He's slow and commits too many mistakes. He plays with the goalie way too much, even when he has an open mid or def next to him. It's annoying how much he slows the game down IMO.

 

Well, Osvaldo Gonzalez impressed me the one time I'e seen him vs Ukraine. The guy that was wearing 3 in that game is 6'1" and is like 19 y/o I forgot his name, so he has potential, but you can tell he has a long way to go. He marked real good, but commited stupid mistakes. Osvaldo is 6 feet but is all bones. I Fuentes is also 6 feet, haven't seen much of him. Our CB's are our biggest problem IMO. I wish in Chile they started over feeding the defenders at age 9 so they can be monsters by the time they're adults, a la Americana or western europeans.