Absolutely right. And truthfully, I DID! But the difference is that I knew nothing of Fisher and was assessing him entirely based on those early terrible games. Unfortunately, I have seen Ellis play for 4 or 5 years, and have come to that same inescapable conclusion.
Fisher's early horrible games were when he played on the left side - he is not a good defender on that side, and he hits a better cross with right foot as well.