Howard - 6, Could do nothing for the goal Hibbo - 7, Excellent defending and put in the best Everton cross of the game, very unlucky to get subbed Jags - 3, Struggled all game and his passing was a nightmare Distin - 7, Kept Carroll at bay all game, someone should tell him he cant hit 40yd passes though! Baines - 5, Offered little going forward Ossie - 1, Awful, just ********ing awful Arteta - 2, One of his worst displays Heitinga - 4, He isnt a midfielder, please play him where he should be Pienaar - 6, Decent without being great Fellaini - 6.5, Much better 2nd half but he isnt a attacking midfielder Becks - 2, Struggled but to fair had no service whatsoever Subs Yak - 6, Offered a lot more, what a surprise that an international striker can hold the ball up Coleman - 2, Can people stop moaning for this kid, offered nothing going forward and was lucky to get away with a blatent pen Billy - 5, At least looked to offer something
minus the fact that I think the team in general was shit today, I roughly agree with most of your ratings, but I think you are a bit too hard on some players but whatever. You do know you can just add this to the game thread right? have all discussion in one spot? I don't care if you make new ones, just thought I'd point it out...
I always have done ratings threads, its a good way of seeing peoples different opinions without the discussion of the actual match thread