General boots question/review thread [6] - all questions/reviews pictures on any boot brand here pls

Discussion in 'Soccer Boots' started by appleCORR7, Oct 6, 2013.

  1. jayc23

    jayc23 Member+

    Dec 2, 2011
    Singapore
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    Singapore
    Ace 17.1. I'd say to go for the AG Pro opus 2s as well.
     
  2. Jaxinho

    Jaxinho Member

    Chelsea
    France
    May 16, 2017
    Sacramento, CA
    Maybe try the Hypervenom Phantom I or Phantom II in FG, Hypervenom Phantom III AG-Pro, Obra II AG-Pro, or the Opus II AG-Pro (the Phantoms will have a more locked-down feel than the Magistas but will still be wide).

    From adidas maybe the Copa line or the Ace 17 if you want synthetic but that’s more narrow.

    I can’t think of any other boot models that have purely rounded studs...maybe the Mizuno Morelia Neo or Neo 2.
     
  3. MRBA

    MRBA Member

    Oct 27, 2014
    Club:
    Chelsea FC



    Thanks for the suggestions. The Hypervenom 3 and Opus are too narrow, and I've already got a pair of Obra AG-Pro. I don't know if they perform well enough on natural grass however.

    I'll look into the Ace.

    What about Adidas' other models-
    The newest Predator? X? I know their studs aren't completely round, but maybe enough to turn while planted?

    Right now I'm using Morelia 2 and I love them. Just thought I'd try something a bit more responsive.
     
  4. Jaxinho

    Jaxinho Member

    Chelsea
    France
    May 16, 2017
    Sacramento, CA
    The X and Nemeziz are your best bets. The X 17.1 is a pretty mediocre boot, so I suggest going with the X 17+ (or 16+). The Nemeziz, in my experience, has a lot of rollover. I did not feel locked-down in them. But it’s worth a try if your feet are wide.

    You might want to look into the Morelia Neo or the Monarcida Neo. I’m just about to get my pair so I can’t say anything about them now but I have high expectations! I also own a Morelia 2 and I found them sloppy after a couple months.
     
    derbyyank13 and jayc23 repped this.
  5. jayc23

    jayc23 Member+

    Dec 2, 2011
    Singapore
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    Singapore

    oh this changes everything. just grab a pair of Morelia neo 2s. much more responsive and crazy lockdown whilst still giving you conical studs. unless you REALLY want a synthetic, then go for the X17+ Purespeeds. like Jax has said the X17.1s are pretty trash at its price.
     
    derbyyank13 and Jaxinho repped this.
  6. BBeast10

    BBeast10 Member

    Chelsea
    United States
    Mar 18, 2016
    Club:
    Chelsea FC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    I think either the Adidas Predator 18.1 or the Nike Hypervenom Phantom 2 v2 might fit the bill. They aren't necessarily really padded but I think you might like them.
     
  7. Jaxinho

    Jaxinho Member

    Chelsea
    France
    May 16, 2017
    Sacramento, CA
    I got suddenly curious. No matter how careful you are in tightening/tying your laces, wouldn’t thin laces* be able to tear the lace hole more than a wide pair of laces? I mean, the tendency for the lace hole to tear would be greater with a thin pair of laces, right? Or am I overthinking it?

    *in theory, small surface area with force will equal more pressure
     
  8. Batigoal_92

    Batigoal_92 New Member

    Arsenal
    Brazil
    Apr 5, 2018
    How about Puma Vigor1 or PumaFuture?
     
  9. Batigoal_92

    Batigoal_92 New Member

    Arsenal
    Brazil
    Apr 5, 2018
    Maybe you're tying it too tightly? The laces should just about keep your feet feeling snug with the boots firmly wrapping your feet and not pressuring into them
     
  10. MRBA

    MRBA Member

    Oct 27, 2014
    Club:
    Chelsea FC
    Both employ bladed studs, unfortunately.
     
  11. derbyyank13

    derbyyank13 Member+

    Nov 8, 2008
    Niigata, Japan
    Club:
    Derby County FC
    @jayc23 talked about "neutralish" reviews in another thread. I was wonder who you guys all watch/read for reviews.

    I normally watch Unisport and SR4U and read SoccerCleats101 (though full disclosure I have written articles for SC101).
     
  12. appleCORR7

    appleCORR7 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Jul 3, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    England
    I tend to go for Unisport if I wanted to see and hear what a new boot is like.

    I have watched SR4U before but just find it all a bit annoying for me (sorry if you are on here!) they seem to have a video on EVERYTHING like why a player would blow his nose a certain way when at the end of the day they don’t know they are just speculating like everyone else but they’ve made a 20 minute video on it. Plus I saw a video of him just sliding around on some concrete in some FG boots ruining them for no reason at all. We all know studs will wear down if you do that on concrete so what were going to learn from it exactly? One thing I will give him is he doesnt care if he might offend the major brands by saying he doesn’t like their products where as other reviewers don’t want to bite the hand that feeds them.

    I know things have changed but a long time ago we’d look on here for reviews and options. Reviews on here don’t happen too much anymore. But we are the consumer who can say whatever we want about a product without having to sugar coat it. If it’s crap it’s crap and we can say that.

    But YouTube/webwise it would be Unisport all day for me.

    appleCORR
     
    derbyyank13 and newone88 repped this.
  13. monta

    monta Member

    Oct 19, 2009
    CA
    Club:
    Real Sociedad de Fútbol
    I watch Unisport to get a general idea but they aren't my first choice for reviews. SR4U is the only one who goes really in depth about the cleats because thats all he does. Unisport is more entertainment and about showcasing the cleats.
     
    Batigoal_92, derbyyank13 and jayc23 repped this.
  14. newone88

    newone88 Member

    May 2, 2006
    San Francisco
    I posted something similar a while back about him as well :)
    I'm tired of all these 20 minute videos with no substance. I know they want to generate as many clicks as possible to make more money but after a while, it gets annoying. Everything is INSANE and CRAZY...everyone is trying to be comedian.
    I know it takes a lot of time and effort to do these reviews and I appreciate the work behind. Also, most of these reviews are either walking around in your house wearing a cleat or kicking a ball for an hour in brand new cleat. It is very hard to judge a cleat just after wearing them for few minutes.
    Also, you see it many times someone giving a cleat a very bad review but then have a link about an incredible deal to buy them :)

    Sorry for the long rant from and old timer :)
     
    derbyyank13 repped this.
  15. appleCORR7

    appleCORR7 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Jul 3, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    England
    I remember back in the day we used to have to ask people to wait until they had worn the boots a few times before they posted a review on here because everyone would have 'new boot syndrome' where there wasn't a single error with them and they were amazing - but then 2 weeks later the same person would be posting saying how bad they thought the boots were and pointing out where improvements needed to be made. That's why if i do write a review i wait a bit so i can give my honest opinion.

    I still like how Unisport do things - I like the comedy element they throw in. It's easy viewing but the facts are there for you to take in. I want to know how they fit and anything else is a bonus.

    appleCORR
     
    newone88, gusgorman, Jaxinho and 2 others repped this.
  16. jayc23

    jayc23 Member+

    Dec 2, 2011
    Singapore
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    Singapore
    when it comes to reviews (regardless of format) the top tier ones will always be SR4U + kohei's blog Football. i find that TEPY does have pretty indepth reviews but theirs comes in once every 5 blue moons.

    Re SR4U - I get the complaints and the lame speculation videos don't do much for me, but we do have to remember he is also catering to younger kids that don't have our experience. regardless he gets a large pass + mileage from me simply because he tends not to repeat the jargon that other reviewers (*coughElegantTouchButterySoftUpperCough*) and more importantly, calls it like it is. He's been vocal from Day 1 about laceless boots not giving you the best performance wise, but you'll almost never hear that from other reviewers in the actual boot review. And as much as i'd like to disagree, he rarely falls for the hype as well, considering how he's always gone on about how MiJ boots don't really feel head and shoulders above the made in Indonesia ones + doesn't justify the price.

    When it comes to Unisport, as much as i Love Jaymike, at the end of the day, its a football site looking to sell football boots. They're not going to have anything more than very contrived negatives in their actual boot reviews. He's great and entertaining in the reviews but they tend to not tell you that much and if a boot isn't great he just doesn't review it at all - the Visaro 2s for example, they had a first impressions boot but nothing else. Having said that, if you actually power through and watch the other videos like Unisport uncut or his top 5 lists, that's where Jaymike really shines as a boot nerd and you do get some insights as to why some boots are better and why. but jaymike, if you see this, please an 'elegant' touch really doesn't mean anything HAHA

    the rest are just crap. maybe the freekickerz are okay if i really need something to go off on, but mostly. just no.
     
  17. appleCORR7

    appleCORR7 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Jul 3, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    England
    Football boots are another awful channel on youtube. I can't remember if they actually review anything but they sure do love cutting stuff up!

    appleCORR
     
  18. derbyyank13

    derbyyank13 Member+

    Nov 8, 2008
    Niigata, Japan
    Club:
    Derby County FC
    Unisport is pretty good for the most part.

    Re: SR4U He is definitely geared towards a younger audience and that's why he has so many videos the seem to be clickbaitish. Not that I'm defending him. In fact several times he has (in so many words) called me a liar.
    I called him out on him complaining about the World Cup ball. I pointed out how long this has been going on (almost every World Cup ball since '98) and that the pros don't just put air in the ball. He didn't agree and said he saw a study saying it makes no difference what the ball is filled with, but he never provided me with any evidence.

    Personally, he does come across as a bit of a know it all (not that I have much room to talk!!). Granted he gets almost every boot that releases but he always seems to act like he knows more than everyone and whenever I've pointed out he's wrong, he gets fairly defensive.

    He also almost never does the in-depth reviews he used to. But like @jayc23 says he gets a massive amount of credit of because he almost never buts the hype when it comes to that so I'll definitely give him that!

    JayMike is great. He's a boot nerd without being overbearing on anybody. He's made the Unisport channel geared towards more older boot nerds. I will agree that there are mostly there to sell boots but I do appreciate that they have gotten louder with their criticisms of high boot prices.

    Freekickerz is great. I like their content I just wish their videos were longer.

    Kohei's blog is top tier for me. He never rushes his reviews and they are some of the most in-depth reviews I have seen. I also like that he doesn't try to review everything and he seems to have very biases. I always feel his reviews give boots the best crack of the whip.

    Football Boots is an awful channel. I've asked them questions several times and never gotten a response. They also "sell" their services as boot experts.
    From their website:
    What is a Boot Expert Consultation?
    1. It is a quick, easy to set-up, infomative chat with one of our boot experts about your football
    2. You get 15 mins one on one to talk to one of our experts about what boots are right for you.
    3. It's basically FEEE - the standard text live chat costs £15, we will save you that at least that much on your next boots*
    4. Video chat upgrade is available for extra £10, talk face to face with one of our boot expert
    I cannot believe they are actually selling services like this.
     
    appleCORR7, newone88 and jayc23 repped this.
  19. derbyyank13

    derbyyank13 Member+

    Nov 8, 2008
    Niigata, Japan
    Club:
    Derby County FC
    Meant to say Kohei has very few biases!
     
    jayc23 repped this.
  20. gusgorman

    gusgorman Member

    May 14, 2013
    Bristol, UK
    This is the most important thing for me. I don't think my opinions about a boot are really formed until I've played 5 or more hours in them. I doubt many (any?) of the boot reviewers ever do this.

    The only exception to this that springs to mind are the MiJ Morelias which were obviously great after about 2 mins, and the way they felt didn't really change much over the next few hours.
     
    derbyyank13, newone88 and Jaxinho repped this.
  21. Jaxinho

    Jaxinho Member

    Chelsea
    France
    May 16, 2017
    Sacramento, CA
    I can not even explain how much I disdain Football Boots. Their videos all look like the target audience is a bunch of 6-year-olds, and the hosts obviously know little about boots. I absolutely hate the segments they put up where there’s a TV and they just talk next to it because they’re flashing an image of a boot they have yet to acquire. Also when they ruin boots and all these ‘hacks.’ They will also most likely benefit from new microphone sets for the hosts.
    Didn’t even know they charged for their ‘boot expertise.’ Please.
     
    derbyyank13, newone88 and jayc23 repped this.
  22. appleCORR7

    appleCORR7 Moderator
    Staff Member

    Jul 3, 2004
    UK
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    England
    'Know it all' were the words I was looking for to describe SR4U. It's as if he's above the actual boot company and knows more than them about the boots they have taken years to design. Which would be impossible!

    Football Boots is very poor - I did watch them cut some genuine new Superfly up and put a fake Vapormax sole on it (whats the point?) But when they were mentioning something about not having a fake Superfly, but when they did come available they would do a review on it. Who wants a review on a fake football boot? I find that they struggle for content because like people have said they don't actually know that much about football boots. They've just got a decent branding for their youtube page with the black/orange shirts that people can recognise. But some of the stuff they put up is just sloppy.

    It's like I said this board when I first joined was THE place to be if you loved boots there wasn't social media so the first look you got of up coming boots was on here. The community was also really tight everyone was lovely. And although they don't look at the board anymore I'm still good friends with quite a few people from the early days. But saying all that this place is still the place I will come too if I want to know how a boot fits, the durability etc because although there aren't as many of us anymore and I don't have to check the board every day like I used too as a mod to check for arguments etc. I know I will get a decent answer and the advise I get from you guys will be spot on. I'll get a pair of boots that fit me from the advice I've been given on here. I'll know what studs are best for AG. I don't get that 'personal' advice from YouTube. But I know I will on here.

    appleCORR
     
    MRBA, derbyyank13, Jaxinho and 1 other person repped this.
  23. derbyyank13

    derbyyank13 Member+

    Nov 8, 2008
    Niigata, Japan
    Club:
    Derby County FC
    You are dead on about SR4U.
    There are tons of people have working for these companies for years who want to get into product design and the fact that he acts like he knows better than anyone comes across as insulting!

    FootBoots branding is really the only thing they have going for them IMO.

    I do miss the days when this board was more active but I agree with you that its still the best place to go online for boot info. People on here are ridiculously knowledgeable about football boots!
     
    Oli Coultas, appleCORR7 and newone88 repped this.
  24. Jaxinho

    Jaxinho Member

    Chelsea
    France
    May 16, 2017
    Sacramento, CA
    This is what the next-gen Concave Volt+ is gonna be. I guess they’re riding the knit game pretty late.
     

    Attached Files:

    BBeast10 repped this.
  25. BBeast10

    BBeast10 Member

    Chelsea
    United States
    Mar 18, 2016
    Club:
    Chelsea FC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    They've been on the knit game since January, but your point still stands. I thought the TechStitch upper was decent, hopefully they have improved it for this version of the Volt.
     
    Jaxinho repped this.

Share This Page