CONCACAF Qualifying For World Cup 2018 Prediction Contest: Round 2 [R]

Discussion in 'CONCACAF' started by EvanJ, Apr 11, 2015.

  1. bartecky

    bartecky Member

    Jun 6, 2009
    New York, USA
    Club:
    KP Legia Warszawa
    Nat'l Team:
    Poland
    I'm not suggesting any changes now. These were just my ideas. I think it takes more knowledge to predict Aruba- Barbados game than USA-Canada for example.
     
  2. zenryan

    zenryan Member

    Jun 23, 2008
    Orlando,Fl
    not to give you more work but are you planning on doing this for the Gold Cup?
     
  3. EvanJ

    EvanJ Member+

    Manchester United
    United States
    Mar 30, 2004
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    I'm traveling during some of the Group Stage, and I don't want to evaluate score predictions quickly. Maybe I'll do something for bracket predictions for the Quarterfinals on. If somebody else wants to do a prediction contest you are welcome to do it. Only 9 people predicted Gold Cup 2013, which is fewer than the amount of people who predicted WCQs for 2018 so far.
     
  4. EvanJ

    EvanJ Member+

    Manchester United
    United States
    Mar 30, 2004
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    #54 EvanJ, Jun 29, 2015
    Last edited: Jun 29, 2015
    http://www.fifa.com/governance/news...d-for-fielding-ineligible-player-2654185.html says Barbados had to forfeit their second leg due to using a player who was suspended. Aruba was given a 3:0 forfeit win and advanced on aggregate 3:2. Because of this, the second leg predictions and the predictions of who would win the aggregate between those teams will be taken out of the prediction contest. The first leg win by Barbados will remain in. As a result, the aggregate winner predictions now result in scores that are exact to the nearest tenth rather than repeating decimals. You got 0.5 per aggregate winner you got correct:

    1. bartecky: 4.0
    Tied 2. EvanJ: 3.5
    Tied 2. IASocFan: 3.5
    Tied 2. PaulieJay: 3.5
    Tied 5. dynamo_zagreb: 3.0
    Tied 5. ChaChaFut: 3.0
    Tied 5. drt2k3: 3.0
    Tied 5. Outburstz: 3.0
    Tied 5. jagum: 3.0
    Tied 5. chec: 3.0
    Tied 11. blacksun: 2.5
    Tied 11. SetPeace: 2.5
    Tied 11. Dr. Gamera: 2.5
    Tied 11. Sebsasour: 2.5
    Tied 11. ioppolo: 2.5
    Tied 11. italiancbr: 2.5
    Tied 11. zenryan: 2.5
    Tied 11. barnabyjonez: 2.5

    I have more scores to post later. I deleted the Round 2 Google Docs spreadsheet.
     
    ChaChaFut and Dr. Gamera repped this.
  5. EvanJ

    EvanJ Member+

    Manchester United
    United States
    Mar 30, 2004
    Club:
    Manchester United FC
    Nat'l Team:
    United States
    Here are Round 2 score prediction results out of 4 points with the top person automatically given a perfect score (the same was true for the aggregate winners in my previous post):

    1. bartecky: 4.000
    2. dinamo_zagreb: 3.778
    Tied 3. ChaChaFut: 3.000
    Tied 3. ioppolo: 3.000
    Tied 5. jagum: 2.778
    Tied 5. chec: 2.778
    Tied 7. IASocFan: 2.667
    Tied 7. SetPeace: 2.667
    Tied 9. blacksun: 2.556
    Tied 9. Sebsasour: 2.556
    Tied 9. drt2k3: 2.556
    12. EvanJ: 2.444
    13. zenryan: 2.222
    Tied 14. Dr. Gamera: 2.111
    Tied 14. PaulieJay: 2.111
    Tied 14. italiancbr: 2.111
    17. barnabyjonez: 2.000 (only predicted some of the round)
    18. Outburstz: 1.889

    Here are the results for both parts of Round 2 combined out of 8 points:

    1. bartecky: 8.000
    2. dinamo_zagreb: 6.778
    3. IASocFan: 6.167
    4. ChaChaFut: 6.000
    5. EvanJ: 5.944
    Tied 6. jagum: 5.778
    Tied 6. chec: 5.778
    8. PaulieJay: 5.611
    9. drt2k3: 5.556
    10. ioppolo: 5.500
    11. SetPeace: 5.167
    Tied 12. blacksun: 5.056
    Tied 12. Sebsasour: 5.056
    14. Outburstz: 4.889
    15. zenryan: 4.722
    Tied 16. Dr. Gamera: 4.611
    Tied 16. italiancbr: 4.611
    18. barnabyjonez: 4.500 (only predicted some of the round)

    In the cumulative standings out of 12.2 points, Barbados forfeiting their second leg knocked me out of the lead. The new leader, who didn't even predict all of Round 1, is bartecky. Here are the standings (a * means you didn't predict the whole contest):

    1. bartecky: 9.836*
    2. EvanJ: 9.826
    3. dinamo_zagreb: 9.723
    4. ChaChaFut: 9.500
    5. jagum: 9.405
    6. blacksun: 9.256
    7. drt2k3: 9.247
    8. chec: 9.214
    9. ioppolo: 9.127
    10. Sebsasour: 8.874
    11. PaulieJay: 8.666
    12. Dr. Gamera: 8.366
    13. italiancbr: 8.175
    14. Outburstz: 7.344
    15. IASocFan: 6.167*
    16. SetPeace: 5.167*
    17. zenryan: 4.722*
    18. barnabyjonez: 4.500*

    Congratulations @bartecky
     
    bartecky and ChaChaFut repped this.
  6. bartecky

    bartecky Member

    Jun 6, 2009
    New York, USA
    Club:
    KP Legia Warszawa
    Nat'l Team:
    Poland
    Thank you EvanJ. I feel sorry for Barbados players. They won on the field 4:0, but lost because of clerical error. It happened to my club last year in CL qualifications and it is still painful memory for me.
     

Share This Page