Comme's History of the World Cup- Switzerland 1954

Discussion in 'FIFA and Tournaments' started by comme, Feb 19, 2006.

  1. comme

    comme Moderator
    Staff Member

    Feb 21, 2003
    Switzerland 1954

    In 1954 the World Cup returned to a Europe still adjusting after the Second World War. Perhaps it was natural then given the events of previous years that neutral Switzerland should be chosen as host, although the fact that Switzerland was also home to FIFA celebrating its 50th anniversary in 1954 may also have played a part.

    After 1950’s tournament without a final,the tournament evolved yet again in Switzerland , and yet again the changes were contentious. FIFA retained the group structure of 4 groups of four teams, but now two teams in each group were seeded and so did not have to face each other. However, with each side only playing two games the possibility of two teams achieving the same number of points always existed and as it was this resulted in a number of extra play-off games.

    The favourites from the start were Hungary, the “Magical Magyars”, who were the Olympic Champions and had not lost since 1950. In their 28 games without defeat the Hungarians had most notably beaten England 6-3 at Wembley, the first time England had ever lost to a foreign team in England, and then annihilated them 7-1 at home in their last game before the World Cup. The significance of these results cannot be overstated. Until the game at Wembley all of England still believed they were the world’s greatest side, despite their poor showing at the 1950 World Cup in Brazil. That match shattered the aura of invincibility forever and sent shockwaves around the footballing world. The key to victory on that occasion was Nandor Hidegkuti, Hungary’s deep-lying centre-forward but he was far from their only superb player. Their captain and inspiration was the fabulous Ferenc Puskas, a short, rotund man whose stature belied his genius and who possessed a canon of a left foot. Leading the line alongside him was Sandor Kocsis, nicknamed the “Golden Head” for his aerial prowess but who also possessed superb talent on the deck. Wide on the left was Zoltan Czibor, blessed with blistering pace and mesmerising ball control he provided many of the crosses from which Kocsis had earned his name. Their playmaker was right-half Josef Boszik whose range of passing was exceptional and was so often able to find his great friend and Honved team-mate Puskas. Their other great star was goalkeeper Gyula Grosics who though infrequently called upon always met the challenges he was presented with.

    Also well fancied were Uruguay the defending champions and still possessing, in Pep Schiaffino and skipper Obdulio Varela, two of the game’s leading lights. Brazil, runners up four years earlier had brought a strong team, but one without their sensational forward line of Zizinho, Jair and Ademir that had wowed the world before. Instead they now had Didi whose fohla seca free-kicks became a trade mark and who was able to pull the strings from midfield. In addition Julinho, a sensational outside-right was in the squad, while at the back Nilton Santos, the “encyclopedia of football”, and Djalma Santos stood strong. England were in attendance again and for the first time Scotland participated, deigning to take part despite finishing second in the Home Championship again.

    West Germany were allowed back into the fold, having been excluded from 1950 due to their warmongering. They were not widely considered a major threat though despite possessing in Fritz Walter an excellent inside-right and captain and had qualified against Norway and the ultimate minnows, the Saar. Their cousins the Austrians were also there, but their team centred on centre-half Ernst “Clockwork” Ocwirk and Ernst Happel. The Austrians were an excellent team, the second Wunderteam, but there was a feeling in some quarters that they were not quite at their best.

    Group stages

    Group A


    The tournament got underway in Lausanne as France faced rivals Yugoslavia. France were sorely missing Rene Vignal of Racing Club, Antoine Cuissard of Nice and Cesar Ruminski of Lille, but had been impressive in qualifying. Yugoslavia took the lead after 15 minutes through a low drive from Milutinović, and they continued to press but were thwarted by Remetter the French goalkeeper. Sadly for France they offered little going forward and failed to really threaten the Yugoslav goal. The game ended 1-0.

    Meanwhile Mexico faced Brazil in the group’s other game in Geneva. The Brazilians went in front through Baltazar midway through the first half as he smashed the ball past Mota from the edge of the area. Didi doubled their advantage shortly after with a trademark free kick, before ********** scored two goals to give Brazil a 4-0 lead at the break. Right at the death Julinho scored an exceptional goal after bamboozling two defenders with clever trickery and then firing in an accurate shot into the top left-hand corner. It was an impressive start for Brazil’s campaign.

    When France played Mexico both sides knew that they needed to win and hope for a decisive scoreline in the clash between the group’s other two teams. Jean Vincent gave France an early lead, toe poking the ball past Carbajal after a powerful run. Then shortly after half-time Cárdenas turned the ball past his keeper and doubled the French advantage. Lamadrid pulled one back for the Mexicans before Balcázar hit a powerful low shot past Remetter with just 5 minutes remaining. Yet the French came back themselves and when a Jean Vincent shot was aimed at goal Mexican defender Narciso Lopez dived and saved the ball with his hand. Raymond Kopa took the resultant penalty and calmly tucked it away sending Carbajal the wrong way.

    Brazil and Yugoslavia’s encounter produced fewer goals, but it was arguably the best game in the group as two quality teams met. Branco Zebec put the Eastern Europeans ahead shortly after half-time, but from then on the Brazilians attacked with great drive. Didi hit the post at one stage before putting Brazil back on level terms. Despite a draw being enough for both sides to qualify they were for some reason forced to play extra-time which produced no further goals.


    19-JUN-54 GENEVA France:Mexico
    3:2 (1:0) Charmilles
    19-JUN-54 LAUSANNE Brazil:Yugoslavia
    1:1 a.e.t (1:1, 0:0) La Pontaise
    16-JUN-54 GENEVA Brazil:Mexico
    5:0 (4:0) Charmilles
    16-JUN-54 LAUSANNE Yugoslavia:France
    1:0 (1:0) La Pontaise

    Group B


    In Zurich Hungary met South Korea in one of the most lopsided affairs to occur ever at the World Cup. Kocsis scored a hat-trick, Puskas netted twice as did Palotás, who was playing in place of Hidegkuti. Perhaps the best goal was a rocket of a free-kick from Lantos, while Czibor also got on the score-sheet in an incredible 9-0 victory.

    Turkey were the other seeded team in the group despite having qualified in farcical circumstances. The Turks had been paired with Spain in qualifying and after going down 4-1 in Madrid they managed to win 1-0 at home. Despite Spain holding a 4-2 advantage overall a play-off was ordered which was to be played at the Olympic stadium in Rome. That game ended in a 2-2 draw, after which it was decided that lots should be drawn, and the task fell to a blindfolded child. The result was that the Turks went to Switzerland while the Spaniards went home disappointed.

    The Turks’ game against W Germany was held at the Wankdorf stadium in Berne, and the Turks found themselves a goal up after just 2 minutes thanks to Mamat Suat. Hans Schafer the German outside-left put them back on level terms soon after, and further goals from Klodt, Ottmar Walter and Max Morlock gave the Germans a comfortable victory.

    The match between Hungary and W Germany has attracted great attention in the following years but it is difficult to know quite what impact it had at the time. The game itself saw Hungary almost as rampant as they had been against the hapless Koreans, 3 goals up after just 20 minutes. Kocsis scored 4 and Hidegkuti 2 in an 8-3 demolition. However, far more significant than the scoreline was the loss of Puskas to an ankle injury. It has been argued since that Sepp Herberger, the German manager deliberately set out to lose the game, notably here though that debate rages to this day.

    The Koreans’ tournament did not get any better against Turkey who destroyed them 7-0, thanks in part to a hat-trick from Sargun Burhan. That set up a play-off match with the Germans who had already played and beaten the Turks. Hans Schafer created the first German goal, with a buccaneering run down the left-flank and his cross left Ottmar Walter with an easy finish. Schafer then netted himself with a low drive after 11 minutes to increase the German lead. Mustafa reduced the arrears with a powerful header soon after but it was not enough to stop the flow of German goals. Max Morlock hit a hat-trick while Fritz Walter and Schafer completed the German scoring. There was time for Kucukandon Lefter to add a consolation goal but it was no more than that. The result was seen by some as rough justice for the Turks, having qualified in such contentious circumstances.


    23-JUN-54 ZURICH Germany FR:Turkey
    7:2 (3:1) Hardturm
    20-JUN-54 GENEVA Turkey:Korea Republic
    7:0 (4:0) Charmilles
    20-JUN-54 BASEL Hungary:Germany FR
    8:3 (3:1) St. Jakob
    17-JUN-54 ZURICH Hungary:Korea Republic
    9:0 (4:0) Hardturm
    17-JUN-54 BERNE Germany FR:Turkey
    4:1 (1:1) Wankdorf

    Group C


    Against Austria’s ageing Wunderteam Scotland, playing in their first ever World Cup, battled well. The only goal of the game was scored by Erich Probst after a good pass from Alfred Koerner. After the game Scottish manager Andy Beattie resigned leaving his team in a rather difficult position, as they still had to face the reigning World Champions Uruguay.
    The Uruguyans themselves made a slow start in their game against Czechoslovakia. They struggled to find any rhythm until Oscar Miguez headed in after a good cross from Javier Ambrois. That kick-fired the Uruguayans into life and Juan ‘Pep’ Schiaffino scored with a powerful freekick to make their victory secure.

    The game between Scotland and Uruguay proved complete opposites to their opening match encounters. While the Scots had started well and the Uruguyans sluggishly the roles were reversed at the St.Jakob Stadion in Basel. Borges and Miguez put the champions 2-0 up at half-time and they completed a wonderful display in the second-half with Borges able to hit a hat-trick in a 7-0 victory. The architect as was so often the case was Schiaffino, whose intuitive passing an incisive balls were simply too much for the Scots. Tommy Doherty the Scottish defender would later blame their heavy kit, but in truth it would appear unlikely to have been the deciding factor.

    In the group’s deciding game the Austrians destroyed Czechoslovakia 5-0. Erich Probst scored a hat-trick and Ernst Stojaspal a brace in a comfortable win. The great question was what kit the Czechs might have to blame.


    19-JUN-54 ZURICH Austria:Czechoslovakia
    5:0 (4:0) Hardturm
    19-JUN-54 BASEL Uruguay:Scotland
    7:0 (2:0) St. Jakob
    16-JUN-54 ZURICH Austria:Scotland
    1:0 (1:0) Hardturm
    16-JUN-54 BERNE Uruguay:Czechoslovakia
    2:0 (0:0) Wankdorf

    Group D


    Group D’s opener of England-Belgium proved to be a true classic which ebbed and flowed and was certainly not short on goals. Leopold Anoul put the Belgians ahead after just 6 minutes, but England showed commendable spirit and came back as Ivor Broadis bravely latched on to a superb through pass from Stanley Matthews (now 39). Before half-time England took the lead with Tom Finney crossing for Nat Lofthouse, the “Lion of Vienna”, to score with a wonderful diving header. Broadis scored again and England appeared to be cruising to victory but Henri Coppens and Anoul scored to level the game and force extra-time. England scored almost immediately after the start of the extra-period as Lofthouse netted having been fed by Broadis. Then disaster struck as Jimmy Dickinson headed into his own net from Marcel Dries’ free-kick. The final score was 4-4, perhaps appropriate in a game neither team deserved to lose.

    The group’s other game was between hosts Switzerland and Italy, but it proved to be a bad-tempered affair. Robert Ballaman put the homeside ahead with a header after 18 minutes but the Azzuri were level just before half-time when Giampiero Boniperti scored. Mario Viana, the Brazilian referee, was the centre of most attention in the second half, in particular for his controversial decision to deny Italy’s Benito Lorenzi a goal for offside. It proved to be a crucial decision as Josef Hugi was later able to seize upon a mistake by Giovanni Giocomazi to score the game’s only goal.

    England booked their place in the quarter finals with what proved to be a comfortable victory over Switzerland on a stifling day in Berne. Jimmy Mullen put England in front shortly before half-time and Dennis Wilshaw, his Wolves team-mate, added a second to make the win secure.

    Belgium played Italy knowing that a point would be enough for them to ensure a place in the quarter finals. However, that hope was soon shattered as Egisto Pandolfini scored from the penalty spot just before half-time. Galli headed Italy into a 2 goal lead shortly after the break, and Amleto Frignani and Lorenzi put them four up. A small consolation for the Belgians was that Leopold Anoul got on the score sheet shortly before the end. The result mean that Italy would have to play the Swiss in a play-off.

    That game was scheduled for just three days later, with most hoping that the game would be a more disciplined affair than their earlier encounter. That it was perhaps reflected well on Benjamin Griffiths the Welsh referee. Josef Hugi put the hosts ahead after 14 minutes before Robert Ballaman headed the Swiss further ahead in the opening minutes of the second half. Fulvio Nesti dragged Italy back into the game with a header of his on 67 minutes following a bout of pinball in the box, but Hugi and Fatton scored late goals to ensure that Switzerland progressed to the next round. A delighted home crowd swarmed on to the pitch to congratulate their heroes.


    23-JUN-54 BASEL Switzerland:Italy
    4:1 (1:0) St. Jakob
    20-JUN-54 BERNE England:Switzerland
    2:0 (1:0) Wankdorf
    20-JUN-54 LUGANO Italy:Belgium
    4:1 (1:0) Comunale di Cornaredo
    17-JUN-54 BASEL England:Belgium
    4:4 a.e.t (3:3, 2:1) St. Jakob
    17-JUN-54 LAUSANNE Switzerland:Italy
    2:1 (1:1) La Pontaise


    Quarter finals


    The quarters finals at the 1950 World Cup through up some of the most entertaining, exciting and contentious matches the games has ever seen.
    Perhaps the game most notable for all the right reasons was Switzerland’s clash with Austria, which enjoyed no fewer than 12 goals, a World Cup record. Robert Ballaman put the Swiss in front with a fine effort from long range after 16 minutes. Josef Hugi scored one a minute later and then another which went in off the bar. Theodor Wagner pulled one back for the Austrians with a low drive which Eugene Parlier, the Swiss keeper, might well have saved before Robert Koerner scored the goal of the game, a fabulous strike from distance. Wagner hit a second and then Ernst Ocwirk stepped up and put the Austrians ahead! Koerner put a penalty wide to the left for the Austrians before half-time but they still went in leading 5-3. In comparison the second half was a disappointment, yet it yielded only a further four goals, 2 more for each side. Kurt Schmied the Austrian goalkeeper was so badly afflicted by sunstroke that he did not even know which team had one after the game. It was his side though that progressed to the semi-finals.

    The game between Uruguay and England pitted the world champions against the game’s creators and Uruguay made the brighter start going in front after just 5 minutes. Schiaffino played in left winger Carlos Borges who got to the by-line and produced a deep cross which went through a crowd and fell to Julio Abbadie whose snap shot was going well wide until it fell to Borges who turned it in despite being in an offside position. Borges was actually off the pitch when Abbadie struck the ball, but this was lost on the English defence, not to mention the officials, and so the goal stood. England though hit back and after a delicate through ball from Dennis Wishaw, Nat Lofthouse put England on level terms with a low shot. England now began to take control of the game and should have taken the lead when Maspoli spilt a long-range effort from Lofthouse and Wishaw, following in, shot wide when it was easier to score. It was Uruguay though who went in ahead at half-time when Obdulio Varela scored with a fine strike from outside the penalty area. Schiaffino put the South Americans further in front shortly after the restart but England should have been awarded a penalty when Tom Finney was plainly tripped in the area. Finney, demonstrating his own determination, stayed on his feet and nothing was awarded, England’s attack fizzling out. England were able to pull one goal back when Finney scored a scrappy goal from a tame Lofthouse shot, and Uruguay should have been reduced to ten men when Luis Cruz lunged two footed at Nat Lofthouse. However, the referee again refused to give anything and Uruguay were able to secure their win minutes later when Amrois scored with a low shot from the right hand side of the area. Uruguay were good value for their win, despite the many calls that went in their favour. At least in this game England showed some of the class which had seen them held in such esteem previously.

    The game between Brazil and Hungary on the 27th June has gone down in infamy as the “Battle of Berne”. However, its start was certainly not bad-tempered and Nandor Hidegkuti smashed the Hungarians into an early lead after Brazil had dwelt on the ball in the box. They were two up after just seven minutes when Kocsis scored a trademark header, and the Brazilians were in shock. However, the Brazilians pulled one back shortly after when they were awarded a penalty after Indio was sandwiched by two Hungarian defenders in the box. Djalma Santos stepped up and sent Grosics the wrong way to make the score 2-1 at the interval. Shortly after the break Hungary had a penalty of their own when Pinheiro was adjudged to have handled Czibor’s cross for Kocsis. The handball was debateable, but Mihaly Lantos coverted the spot-kick with a thunderous shot into the roof of the net. Julinho then displayed why he was commonly considered to be the game’s outstanding outside right with a fabulous strike which was a carbon copy of his goal against Mexico. Then midway through the half, with game increasingly being halted by niggly fouls, Josef Boszik and Nilton Santos, two of the game’s all-time greatest figures were dismissed for fighting. Sandor Kocsis settled the game with little time remaining through yet another header, but there was still time for Humberto Tozzi to be dismissed by English referee, Arthur Ellis, for kicking Lorant. After the game all hell ensued, with the Brazilians entering the Hungarian dressing room and Ferenc Puskas, who had missed the game through injury, allegedly smashing a bottle in the face of Pinheiro. Gustav Sebes, the Hungarian coach, found his face cut by a football boot in a series of incidents which did little for the reputation of the sport.

    In comparison with the other three games Yugoslavia’s encounter with W Germany was a relatively modest affair. Most believed that the Yugoslavs would find the game comfortable but they found themselves behind after 10 minutes. After Max Morlock had nodded a high ball towards goal Ivan Horvat, the Yugoslav defender, attempted to head the ball back to his keeper Beara, not realising that he had come off his line, and the ball beat him and rolled into the empty net. The Yugoslavs tried in vain to force an equaliser and with just minutes remaining the Germans managed to break away. When the ball fell to Helmut Rahn he coolly smashed the ball past Beara on the half-volley. It was enough to see the Germans through, and they were mobbed by their supporters in recognition of their achievement.


    27-JUN-54 GENEVA Germany FR:Yugoslavia
    2:0 (1:0) Charmilles
    27-JUN-54 BERNE Hungary:Brazil
    4:2 (2:1) Wankdorf
    26-JUN-54 BASEL Uruguay:England
    4:2 (2:1) St. Jakob
    26-JUN-54 LAUSANNE Austria:Switzerland
    7:5 (5:4) La Pontaise


    The semi-finals


    When Hungary met Uruguay in Lausanne, it was a match up which embodied everything the World Cup was created for. The World Champions took on the Olympic Champions, in a game which had none of the animosity that had soured the Magyars’ victory over Brazil. Despite both sides missing arguably their most influential player, Puskas of Hungary and Varela of Uruguay, the game proved to be a classic, with more than one twist in the tale. It was Hungary who scored first, as was their wont they were ahead in the opening minutes when Czibor broke the deadlock. Hidegkuti had received the ball just inside the Uruguyan half and his lofted ball was headed on by Sandor Kocsis to Czibor, his slightly scuffed volley rolling past the despairing Maspoli and into the net. The Hungarians doubled their advantage shortly after half-time when Budai, playing in place of the injured Toth, crossed and Hidegkuti buried the ball and himself with a wonderful diving header. The Uruguyans though showed their composure and proved why they had become World Champions in the first place. Pep Schiaffino began to involve himself more in the game and when he released Juan Eduardo Hohberg, the naturalised Argentinian calmly slotted the ball to Grosics’ left and draw his side back into the game. Then with just minutes remaining Hohberg rounded Grosics and evaded two defenders on the line with a shot which bulged the roof of the net. In extra-time Hohberg raced in for his hat-trick, from another Schiaffino pass, but he was denied by the post. The Hungarians eventually emerged to victorious, Sandor Kocsis saw to that. He headed two decisive goals in the second half of added time to ensure their place in the final.

    The game between Austria and W Germany was commonly perceived as being a less balanced affair. The W Germans were perceived to have over-achieved in beating Yugoslavia, to test the Wunderteam would be a step up again. Yet the Germans surprised their neighbours as Max Morlock sent Fritz Walter bounding down the right touchline and when he crossed Hans Schafer brilliantly steered the ball past Walter Zeman on the half-volley. Austria’s most dangerous attack of the half came when Thodor Wagner drove with the ball at the German defence, but was cynically brought down by Schafer just outside the box. The resulting free-kick from Ernst Ocwirk was easily dealt with by Toni Turek, the Germans goalkeeper. The W Germans then went in one up at half time but they increased their lead shortly after when Max Morlock leapt highest at a Fritz Walter corner and was able to get in between Ocwirk and Karl Koller to head home. Yet the Austrians remained a threat and that was reaffirmed just moments later when Wagner showed neat footwork in the box and Turek lost the ball to Erich Probst who took advantage. Fritz Walter though restored the German cushion with a penalty in the 54th minute putting the ball to Zeman’s left as he dived the wrong way. Then his brother Ottmar extended their lead with a glancing header at the new post from a corner. Helmut Rahn broke through in search of another goal in the 64th minute, but as he rounded Zeman he was brought down and Fritz Walter stepped up to score again, this time Zeman getting within inches of pulling off a brilliant save. Ottmar Walter added a sixth goal in the final minute, with another header. It was a harsh blow for the Austrians who didn’t deserve to be on the end of such a rout.

    The third-fourth play-off may have meant little to the players who looked jaded throughout, but the fans certainly cared. Thirty-two thousand packed in to see them, while those left outside resorted to climbing surrounding trees in order to get a view. Austria took the lead through the spot after Robert Dienst was brought down when surging through the Uruguyan box. Ernst Stojaspal stepped up and easily sent Gaston Maspoli the wrong way. Walter Kollman then came close to increasing their lead, but this time Maspoli pulled off an excellent save to tip the ball round the post. Uruguay drew level though after 22 minutes when Eduardo Hohberg’s long-range effort somehow beat Kurt Schmied, back in the team in place of Zeman, despite having little pace to it. The Austrians did regain their lead in the second half when the unfortunate Luis Cruz turned the ball past his own keeper. Ocwirk settled the game for Austria in the dying moments, and they could take some small comfort in finishing third.

    30-JUN-54 BASEL Germany FR:Austria
    6:1 (1:0) St. Jakob
    30-JUN-54 LAUSANNE Hungary:Uruguay
    4:2 a.e.t (2:2, 1:0) La Pontaise
    03-JUL-54 ZURICH Austria:Uruguay
    3:1 (1:1) Hardturm

    The Final


    The prime question in the build up to the final was whether or not Ferenc Puskas would be fit to play. He was the diamond that shone most brightly in a stellar Hungarian side and the Magyars were desperate for him to be fit. Not of course that the Germans were really perceived as being a realistic threat, even if the Hungarians were without the “Galloping Major” they were still clearly a better side than W Germany. As it was Puskas declared himself fit to play and so it was that he led his team out against the Germans on the 4th July 1954.

    The other apparent factor was the weather. Switzerland had enjoyed an incredible summer which had seen players suffer with sunstroke in previous games, but sadly the final was hit by torrential rain that left the pitch a far from ideal surface.

    When the match got underway it appeared that Puskas had been right to play as he managed to put the Hungarians in front after just 6 minutes. When a shot from Sandor Kocsis was blocked by Horst Eckel, the ball fell kindly to Puskas who easily fired past Turek. Barely a minute had passed when the Hugarians doubled their advantage as Werner Kohlmeyer and Toni Turek were involved in a farcical mix-up, the ball split free and Zoltan Czibor, the Hungarian left-winger was there to pounce.

    What had looked an uphill task for W Germany now looked Mission Impossible, but within two minutes they scored a goal of their own. The Germans played some neat inter-passing and when Hans Schafer attempted a speculative effort from the left Boszik’s attempt tp play the ball safely back to Gyula Grosics only served to play in Max Morlock who slid the ball past the advancing keeper. They were on level terms within two minutes as Max Morlock’s driving run forced a corner which Hungary were unable to deal with. Instead they conceded another corner and when Grosics flapped uncharacteristically Helmut Rahn netted from within the 6 yard box.

    The Hungarians then began to reassert their control over the game, and after a wonderful dummy from Nandor Hidegkuti from Boszik’s pass, Puskas had his effort blocked by Kohlmeyer. When the ball fell to Puskas again Kohlmeyer was there once more to block on the line. The Hungarians continued to press their claims and when Toth hit a deep cross Kocsis leapt at the back post and headed against the bar.

    W Germany though somehow managed to take the lead with just 5 minutes remaining when Helmut Rahn picked up the ball and cut in to the Hungarian box, driving the ball low to Grosics’ right. Still though the Hungarians pressed and in stoppage time they thought they had levelled the game, when Toth lit a long through ball which Puskas ran onto and while sliding he hit the ball under the body of Toni Turek. The Welsh assistant had raised his flag though and the goal was disallowed in a decision that still rankles today.

    Since the match many accusations have been thrown around including drug use by the W German team (though no drug laws were in place in 1954), yet none can take away the simple fact that on that day the “Miracle of Berne” occurred and Fritz Walter was able to hold aloft the famous Jules Rimet trophy. Just 4 years earlier W Germany had been excluded from participating for their part in the war, now, and against all odds, they were World Champions.

    04-JUL-54 BERNE Germany FR:Hungary
    3:2 (2:2) Wankdorf



    FIFA’s Official Page

    Full Line-ups, scorers and much more

    [​IMG]
     
    msioux75 repped this.
  2. comme

    comme Moderator
    Staff Member

    Feb 21, 2003
    For some reason BigSoccer censors the Brazilian goalscorer P i n g a 's name.

    Is that an offensive word in the States?
     
  3. Knave

    Knave Member+

    May 25, 1999
    I don't know why that's censored. I'll see if it can't be changed.

    Copied to the Soccer Journal.
     
  4. Sagy

    Sagy Member

    Aug 6, 2004
    Comme,

    Any idea why the Quarter finals match up had (what I think were) the group winners Brazil(A on GD), Hungary(B), Uruguay(C on GD), England(D) play each other? Did they have a different method to determine the group winners in 1954?

    Thanks in advance.
     
  5. comme

    comme Moderator
    Staff Member

    Feb 21, 2003
    That is a very good question. To be honest, I don't know off the top of my head, but I will endeavour to find out. If I was to guess I would suggest it was simply another example of the woeful organisation at the time, but the fact that it happened in both cases would suggest otherwise.
     
  6. tpmazembe

    tpmazembe Member

    Jun 13, 2002
    The Midfield (S.Fla)
    From my records I'm concluding that pairings were drawn after the first round (like the UEFA CL matchups are today, except without seedings).

    For example, in Roberto Porto's biography on Didi he mentions how the the Brasilian delegation was anxiously awaiting the results of the "drawing" and hoping against an early matchup with the Hungarians.
    In some parts of the Spanish speaking Carribean it refers to the male genital organ.

    I once dated a Cuban girl....when she used the term around me it was never offensive :)
     
    msioux75 repped this.
  7. tpmazembe

    tpmazembe Member

    Jun 13, 2002
    The Midfield (S.Fla)
    Nilton Santos many years later told the story of how he and Boszik ended-up taking showers in the same dressing room after being sent-off. Naked, and sharing the same soap, they sealed their peace with a handshake.

    Another interesting side note on the Battle of Berne - on the heals of the 1950 loss to Uruguay, this game fathered a disturbing post-mortem dossier in the bowels of the CBD regarding the "mental" capacity of Brasilian players. This study, sometimes referred to as the KKK File due to its racism, recommended that players of black, mulatto and native stock no longer be called up to the Selecao for important games. It suggested that only white players had the physical, mental and spiritual make-up to deal with high-pressure games such as do-or-die WC matches.
     
  8. argentine soccer fan

    Staff Member

    Jan 18, 2001
    San Francisco Bay Area
    Club:
    CA Boca Juniors
    Nat'l Team:
    Argentina
    I wonder how Brazil's lineup would have looked in 58, had they heeded the racist report. No Pele, no Garrincha, no Didi, no Santos, etc, etc. It is safe to say that they probably wouldn't have gotten too far in the tournament, if indeed they even could have managed to qualify for it. I guess the game of football owes a lot to whoever made the decision to disregard that report.
     
  9. comme

    comme Moderator
    Staff Member

    Feb 21, 2003
    I'd like to hear from Greg on this, given the idea that W Germany played to lose against Hungary, with an easier draw in mind.

    Thanks for the clarification ... and the anecdote ;)
     
  10. Gregoriak

    Gregoriak BigSoccer Supporter

    Feb 27, 2002
    Munich
    I have just ordered the AGON book on the 1954 World Cup at my library. I will check what is being said about the drawing rules. Won't get the book before Thursday, though.

    Reading the Kicker reports from 1954, it was known already before the second game vs. Turkey that West Germany was to play against either Brazil or Yugoslavia in the second round if they would win their match vs. the Turks.
     
  11. Gregoriak

    Gregoriak BigSoccer Supporter

    Feb 27, 2002
    Munich
    Four renown football experts each compiled their own selection for Germany`s "Kicker" football magazine. They were Dr. Friedebert Becker, Dr. Willy Meisl, Dr. Paul Tröger and Dr. Fritz Weilenmann. From their selections, Kicker compiled the "definitive" World selection 1954.


    Dr. Friedebert Becker`s Teams:

    Team A:

    ----------Czibor-----------Hidegkuti----------Julinho

    -------------------Kocsis------------Puskas

    -------------------Ocwirk------------Bozsik

    --------Andrade-------------Wright------------D.Santos

    -----------------------------Turgay


    Team B:


    ----------Schäfer-----------Hügi-----------Klodt

    ------------------Schiaffino-----------F.Walter

    ------------------Cajkovski------------Eckel

    --------Crnkovic------------Horvath------------Stankovic

    -----------------------------Beara

    His commentary:
    "The best players were the linkmen. The two Hungarians Puskas and Kocsis, the Uruguayan Schiaffino and our own Fritz Walter can only be chosen according to the alphabet, for who would want to favour any of them? Even Maxl Morlock is approaching these world class players, in terms of shooting accuracy, he can take on even goal champion Kocsis! Wings didn`t shine as brightly as they did in 1934 (Lehner, Orsi, Puc, Guaita), but Schäfer and the Bernie Klodt of the Turkey match can be compared with any of the Greats from Overseas or central Europe. But the best winger of this tournament was without a doubt the Brazilian Julinho."


    Dr. Willy Meisl`s Teams:

    Team A:

    ----------Czibor-----------Hidegkuti----------Julinho

    ----------------Schiaffino------------F.Walter

    -------------------Andrade------------Cajkovski

    ---------Neury-------------Wright------------D.Santos

    -----------------------------Grosics


    Team B:


    ----------Schäfer-----------Stojaspal----------Matthews

    -------------------Kocsis--------------Puskas

    ------------------Ocwirk--------------Bozsik

    ------no player named-------Lorant------------Lantos

    -----------------------------Parlier

    His commentary:
    "The best player? This is an unanswerable question. One could at best try to classify groups of players. But if I have to answer: number 1 was the bearer of a name of a player who already once before overshadowed every other player at a World Cup: Andrade is the complete footballer, a real 'black diamond'. Technically completed, an athlete and sportsman from head to toe, tactically, a football pitch-marshall. He is equally perfect at passing and taking balls, in destruction as in built-up."


    Dr. Paul Tröger`s Teams:

    Team A

    ---Schäfer-----Hidegkuti------Budai II

    ----------Kocsis--------F.Walter

    ----------Ocwirk--------Bozsik

    ------Andrade----Liebrich----Kohlmeyer

    -----------------Turgay

    He didn`t list enough players for a second team. The players he listed additionally were: Grosics (goalie), Horvath (stopper), Eckel (half), Schiaffino (linkman), Hügi (centre forward).

    His commentary:
    "Kocsis' inimitable way of scoring headers was the most impressive thing for me. He was the most dangerous forward of the tournament (Morlock was close in terms of jumping power as well as in the exactness of his heading). Uruguay`s Schiaffino (even if Milan just paid 300,000 Marks to Penarol) does not just reach him (maybe because he`s missing the accompanying players). Best strategic: Fritz Walter, who literally hypnotized his accompanying players, to act according to his ideas. Best performance in terms of defence: Liebrich in Geneva and Basel (despite Uruguay`s giant Santamaria, despite the self-sacrificing Neury). No goalie was outstanding. Decisive however were: Turek against Yugoslavia in the positive, Merrick (England vs. Uruguay) in the negative."


    Dr. Fritz Weilenmann`s Teams are a bit too complicated to put into a tactical scheme. I will just quote what he said about his selections plus the general comment.

    Goal: Beara, Turgay, Turek
    Full Backs pair: Crnkovic-Stankovic
    Left Full Back: Kohlmeyer
    Right Full Back: Neury (he remarks that he unfortunately didn`t see D.Santos play)
    Stopper: Liebrich, closely ahead of Horvath (he remarks that he didn`t see Wright play)
    Halves pair: three almost equal pairs, Bozsik-Zakarias, Ocwirk-Koller & Cajkovski-Boskov.
    Single half: Eckel (he remarks that Uruguay`s Andrade does not exactly belong into this position, but he wants to call him "the king of the classical outside-marking half backs")
    Outside Right: Julinho, Milutinovic
    Outside Left: Schäfer, Zebec, Czibor
    Inside forwards/linkmen: F.Walter, Kocsis, Puskas (all equal), then Schiaffino
    Centre forwards: Hügi (as executor), Hidegkuti (as "thinking" player), Stojaspal (as "gapless commuter").

    His commentary:
    "The best attack? The Hungarians, but closely followed by the Germans. Only the inside forward trio of Kocsis-Hidegkuti-Puskas outdid the German inside trio Morlock-O.Walter-F.Walter (from the 6-1 bashing of Austria). Kocsis is just unstoppable! Puskas is equalled by F.Walter as a selfless teamplayer and strategic. The best outside forwards: at the right doubtlessly Brazil`s Julinho, at the left Schäfer despite Czibor."


    From the selections of these four gentlemen, Kicker magazine then went on to compile the 1954 "World XI".

    Goal: Beara
    Full Backs: D.Santos, Kohlmeyer or Crnkovic
    Stopper: Wright
    Halves: Ocwirk or Cajkovski or Bozsik (who would want to decide between them?)
    Outside forwards: Julinho, Czibor or Schäfer
    Inside forwards: Kocsis, F.Walter, Puskas or Schiaffino.
     
    msioux75 repped this.
  12. dor02

    dor02 Member

    Aug 9, 2004
    Melbourne
    Club:
    UC Sampdoria
    Nat'l Team:
    Italy
    Cool.

    Cazzo. It's works when I type it in.

    I don't understand why the Austria vs Switzerland Quarter-Final isn't rated very highly in terms of the all-time greatest World Cup matches. We will never see a goal glut like that in a World Cup again.
     
  13. Excape Goat

    Excape Goat Member+

    Mar 18, 1999
    Club:
    Real Madrid
    For people who are interested for this WC, I recommend this movie.

    Wunder von Bern, Das or the Miracle of Bern.

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0326429/

    The movie was more on the social context of West Germany in the 1950s than soccer. It just used the WC Finals as a background. Nevertheless, they did duiscuss how West Germany won the WC Finals.
     
  14. Fulham Fan

    Fulham Fan New Member

    Apr 26, 2004
    Bay Area
    That's very sad. I still remember Pele in his autobiography describing the national team's psychologist in 1958. He asked all the players to draw a picture of a man, and if your picture wasn't very good, he told the coach you were a moron and suggested you not play.

    The Brazilian federation's fascination with intelligence (and color) represents a kind of counterpoint to the notion that Brazilian soccer is all fun and flair, and that Brazil wins World Cups for fun and no one gives a thought about it. The history is a lot more complex and sometimes scarier than that. The players deserve a ton of credit on many levels for what they've achieved and what they've put up with and overcome.
     
  15. tpmazembe

    tpmazembe Member

    Jun 13, 2002
    The Midfield (S.Fla)
    Nice post.

    When comme opens his Sweden 1958 thread I'll try and post a couple of stories on the psychological testing you alluded to with that 1958 squad (its also discussed in Garrincha and Didi's biographies).

    Its really not uncommon for people - even on these boards - to continue to imply that Brasilian players lack a "tactical" acumen that somehow exists within European players. Very condescending.

    I'm convinced that Brasilian football on the pitch has reached colour-blindness (if there is such a word). The greatest evidence of this IMO is the number of black goal-keepers springing up all over the place. For decades after the loss to Uruguay in WC 1950 it was a position not entrusted to players of colour. No longer the case today.

    Not that it is all good; the extreme lack of coaches of colour in Brasilian professional football - no matter the reasons one can attempt to provide - is evidence of serious institutional impediments IMO.
     
  16. herewego

    herewego Member

    Jun 1, 2004
    That was not the question for coach Herberger.
    Nobody ever thaught that there would be a realistic chance to beat Hungary.
    But losing against Hungary would have had the result to have to play an extra qualification game against Turkey.

    He might have seen, that losing would have meant an easier knock out stages draw, but first he had in mind to rest the A for the most probably upcoming qualifier against Turkey and so fielded the reserves team against Hungary because that game seemes to be unwinable already.
     
  17. comme

    comme Moderator
    Staff Member

    Feb 21, 2003
    Before posting that I must confess that I lent heavily on Rui Castro's Garrincha for much of my information about Brazil's preparations. I would still love to see your thoughts on the matter though.
     
  18. Gregoriak

    Gregoriak BigSoccer Supporter

    Feb 27, 2002
    Munich
    Today I got to look at the 1954 World Cup book at my library (unfortunately couldn't take it home so I only browsed thru the relevant articles plus made a photocopy of one of the pages).

    Several things I noted:

    1. The Qualification groups were not drawn, but decided upon by FIFA (who used regional closeness as their guide - did not work out well in all groups, e.g. Portugal vs. Austria or Spain vs. Turkey).

    2. Ridiculously, FIFA decided that goal differentials would not be used at any stage of the competition (including qualification). This meant that e.g. Austria - who beat Portugal 9-1, if they had lost the second game 0-1 - would have had to play a play-off game. If that had ended in a draw, a coin would have decided the outcome. This is what happened to Spain vs. Turkey.

    3. FIFA also decided which teams would be seeded before the qualification was over. Spain was among those seeded teams, and when they failed to qualify, Turkey became the seeded team. If Malta had been the Spaniard's opponent, Malta would have been a seeded team. A ridiculously silly way of handling things by FIFA.

    4. Before the final tournament started, FIFA had already decided upon which groups would be set against each other in the quarterfinals. What they had not decided, though, was which exact team of group X would meet which exact team of group Y, e.g. the first placed of group X vs. the second placed of group Y, like it would be done today. No, FIFA drew the quarterfinal ties after the group phase was finished. This meant that Brazil knew they would either face West Germany or Hungary, or that West Germany knew they would either face Brazil or Yugoslavia. That was the only certainty after the group phase was finished and this also explains the comments made by Didi.

    5. FIFA also decided that no draws would be allowed - which meant that undecided games had to go into extra-time in the group phase. Two games were affected by that: Brazil 1-1 Yugoslavia and England 4-4 Belgium. Notable that both games ended undecided even after extra-time.


    All told, the 1954 World Cup was a "what-to-avoid" blueprint for any World Cup organizer that followed.
     
    schwuppe repped this.
  19. minorthreat

    minorthreat Member

    Jan 1, 2001
    NYC
    Club:
    Real Madrid
    Nat'l Team:
    Spain
    Presumably you also learned what "papaya" means in Cuba as well, then. :D
     
  20. tpmazembe

    tpmazembe Member

    Jun 13, 2002
    The Midfield (S.Fla)
    Informative post Gregoriak...helps put context around the reference in the Didi biography.
    Indeed.

    My favorite fruit; I avail myself to it as often as possible. A treat at any time of the day.... ;)
     
  21. msioux75

    msioux75 Member+

    Jan 8, 2006
    Lima, Peru
    I will make a resume for this match. Called by some as the "Best Match in the history of the World Cup".
    At least among the classical ones.

    Here are some interesting quotes about Rodríguez Andrade performances
     
  22. comme

    comme Moderator
    Staff Member

    Feb 21, 2003
    msioux75 repped this.
  23. msioux75

    msioux75 Member+

    Jan 8, 2006
    Lima, Peru
    Hungary vs Uruguay: preamble

    The match between the european superpower (with a 4 years unbeaten record and the best ELO of alltime) vs the reigning world champions (and unbeaten in WC games) takes place 3 days after the infamous "Battle of Berne" in which the hungarians had many players injured, in fact the Toth brothers (wingers) missed this match due to this. Also their leading captain and star, Ferenc Puskas wasn't available due to a severe injury in a previous match vs West Germany in the Group Stages.

    The Puskas lost, caused that in the match vs Brazil, Czibor filled the Inside Left role and after the Toth injury, Palotas (Hidegkuti's predecessor in the Deep Lying Centreforward role) comes to the starting XI.


    One day before to the Hungary match in Quarter Finals, Uruguay defeat to England in its QF match, in a notable performance which ended result in a phyrric victory, because the uruguayans lost their captain by an injury, the formidable Obdulio Varela, also were injured the great right winger Julio César Abaddie and the right half Víctor Rodríguez Andrade. It was decided for the SF match the sub of the skilled centreforward Omar Míguez, who was totally owned by Billy Wright in the QF match, for the goalscoring Inside Forward, Juan Eduardo Hohberg.


    Since the Aranycsapat or Magycal Magyars used to interchange positions among its players during a game, can be seen at times to Palotas performing the D-L-CF role and Hidegkuti in the Puskas role. Also, Czibor playing sometimes that role, meanwhile Palotas was in the Left Wing. Or Kocsis withdrawing deeper, even in his own half.

    For the charrúas, the usual Inside Right, Hohberg, played this match as a Centreforward, due to his goalscoring skills, he almost scores a hat-trick that day!!!. The "Outside marking Halfbacks" (quoting Dr. Weilenmann) played as defensive minded Sides Halves in the Pyramid formation, due to the dangerous hungarian attacking line. And its Pyramid fullbacks pairing, in the usual uruguayan style (#2 doing the covering and the #3 facing first the attacks at the center)


    Here's the line-ups (player & shirt's number):

    HUNGARY (WM variant = WW). Read from North to South

    -------------------------- Grosics (1)

    Buzansky (2) ----------- Lorant (3) ----------- Lantos (4)

    ------------------------------------- Zakarias (6)
    -------------- Bozsik (5)

    ------------------------ Hidegkuti (9)
    Budai (16) --------------------------------------- Czibor (11)
    ------------- Kocsis (8) ------------- Palotas (19)



    URUGUAY (Pyramid = 2-3-5). Read from South to North

    Borges (11) ------------- Hohberg (8) ------------- Souto (18)
    ----------- Schiaffino (10) ----------- Ambrois (19)

    ------------------------- Carballo (16)
    ----- Cruz (17) --------------------------- R.Andrade (4)

    -------------- Martínez (3)
    ----------------------------- Santamaría (2)

    ---------------------- Máspoli (1)
     
    themightymagyar and Chesco United repped this.
  24. msioux75

    msioux75 Member+

    Jan 8, 2006
    Lima, Peru
  25. msioux75

    msioux75 Member+

    Jan 8, 2006
    Lima, Peru

    part 3 (2nd half)


    part 4 (2nd half)


    part 5 (extra-time)
     

Share This Page