I am late here, but the Falcao vs Pibe arguement is very interesting. If we asked in Colombia, Pibe would win and by a good margin. If we were to ask international voters, I think Falcao would take it home though. Europeans place a lot of weight o club success and I think they would undoubtedly go with Falcao. For me, Pibe is still the greatest and has to be dethroned prior to me choosing someone else.