If you could pick ONE player to be the biggest flop in USMNT history that based on hype/reputation that has at least earned one USMNT cap but has fallen off the radar completely, who would it be? For this, I ask that each voter pick a different player, and at the end of the month, we decide who won. My pick: Santino Quaranta There was a lot of hope that Quaranta would be in the next category of Beasley and Donovan. Also, he has shown glimpses that hype might be true, but he never was able to be a consistent force. Ultimately, he retired and earns my vote for biggest flop.