I made my previous post because I have done a lot of research and have struggled to find information relating to specific matches where Orth...
I have said this before in refence to Orth and I will say it again. I would love to see any specific match reports or observations from specific...
Bobby Walker. Had a bit of an late career throwback and was MOTM vs England in some of the reports I read.
Found this very interesting. I am not surprised Xavi and Modric are less progressive than Pirlo and Kross as they are the teams metronomes who...
Hope you get a chance to continue this, great stuff.
I think we may have discussed this before but I am not sure it is this straightforward. I think in Britain, even before WWI and throughout the...
I don't think it is very clear, but not De Vecchi. I would go with Caligaris above De Vecchi and Rava. For a continental player I would go with...
https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coppa_dell%27Europa_Centrale_1927
There is no good method, I have tried to keep the competition as a whole at the end of the season, but some years I felt the need to split the...
I like this a lot. Slight adjustments in my eyes would be Eto'o a little higher and Shearer a little lower.
I think the modern players in Salah and Greizmann can be moved up significantly, although this is a very deep group. My strongest opinion here is...
I think Giggs is a bit to high here, especially compared to Di Maria. I think in the big picture Beckham was a more influential player that Giggs...
I have found your previous opinion and arguments on Iniesta being a bit overrated persuasive, and I would not have him higher than #3 on this...
Really strong group through 14. I think the top 2 are locked in and the 3 through 14 could be arranged in a number of ways. I personally would...
I think Rodri can already make the list, especially with the relatively weakness of 25-30. I think a few players are too high based on longevity...
Much better quality here all the way through 30 when compared to fullback. A lot more difficult decisions here between players, and personally I...
Based on your endorsement of Alves at #2, a player who receives criticisms of his defensive ability but has exceptional offense contribution, I...
Very interesting looking through theses. I will give some specific thoughts for each list but each list to me also brings up some trends in your...
Like many have said here players should be ranked all time based on how they compared to their contemporaries, and I agree that no one player...
I have been thinking a little bit about the top players of this period and the dissonance between players with a great career of constant...
Accident on my part. I would have him as 4th center forward.
Positions get weird with Hungary all time teams because so many players are from pre 1960 playing either WM or pyramid. My rough thoughts, listed...
I agree with most of your suggestions and I have been giving the pantheon more thought, as well as trying to categorize players by role across all...
I will expand on this and list my possible contenders for a 23 man shortlist for attacking players. Podium Contenders Lionel Messi: 37 goals and...
Greaves is definitely an inside forward, exclusively so at the club level. With spurs he always played off a tradition in the box center forward...