PDA

View Full Version : Ok to all the ignorant people listen up


Tottenham4life
24 Mar 2009, 02:03 PM
THIS ARTICLE I FOUND VERY INTERESTING AND DECIDED TO POSTED ON HERE, I READ SOMEWHERE ON ONE OF THE FORUMS OF THIS SITE THIS FEW YANKS TALKING RUBBISH ABOUT OR SAYING THAT IN THE STATES AT LEAST THEY DIDN'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT HOOLIGANS AND ROWS AT THEIR FOOTBALL MATCHES LIKE WE DO IN EUROPE, I THINK IS BOLLOCKS AND HERE IS THE PROVE THAT THEY DO HAVE HOOLIGANS IN AMERICA WAY FAR A LOT WORST THAN HERE IN EUROPE SO PLEASE READ ON AND WAKE UP PEOPLE YOU YANKS ARE NOT SAINTS, AND SORRY IF I OFFEND ANYONE, IT IS NOT MY INTENTION

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

A few weeks ago I was in a Philly pub with a mixed party of Brits and Americans when I mentioned in passing the fact that US sports have a far worse hooligan problem that UK sports (http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2005/dec/07/ussport.football).
This made one British woman very angry. How dare I compare proper British hooligans to the obviously inferior American brand? The Americans present seemed confused. Wasn't every single English soccer game a seething maelstrom of racism, hatred and knife violence?
Which got me thinking: what if one were to write about American sports hooliganism the way the US media talks about soccer hooliganism?
Is Europe in danger of being swamped by a tidal wave of US style sports fan thuggery? I ask because of a recent letter about American fan violence (http://www.velonews.com/article/86102/readers--letters-on-philly-week-masters-racing-and) in the competitive cycling mag Velo News. Referring to fan-on-fan violence at the U.S. Cyclocross Nationals (http://www.velonews.com/photo/86090) in December, Jim Wheeler of Cupertino California wrote: "I've never heard of such a thing happening in Europe … It's just terrible and all participants should be ashamed. This is the kind of crap I expect to see in US-dominated sports like baseball and football, and it's also why I no longer follow those sports."
Barely a day goes by without yet another example of American fan thuggery. Take for instance last week's much anticipated college basketball game between Wake Forest and Clemson. Not only was the game spoiled by the sort of violence more usually associated with mixed martial arts, but when a Wake Forest player lost his footing, he was treated to a brutal body slam by a crop-haired hoodlum in the crowd (http://rivals.yahoo.com/ncaa/basketball/blog/the~sep~dagger/post/Clemson-fan-tackles-Wake-Forest-player?urn=ncaab,135081).
These are not isolated incidents. As California Congressman Dan Lungren put it: "America is, by far, the most violent country in the [industrialised] world … Violence is deeply rooted in our society and has become woven into the fabric of the American lifestyle."
And nowhere is this more apparent than in American sport. Bestial supporter behaviour is the norm across all sports and at all levels. Here are just a few examples of North America's out-of-control berserker fan culture taken from the last 13 months:
January 2008: a San Francisco man was shot to death when he left his daughter's high-school basketball game to have a cigarette (http://cbs5.com/crime/sacred.heart.shooting.2.628790.html).
In April Montreal Canadiens fans celebrated with a riot that involves the mass torching of police cars (http://www.nationalpost.com/sports/nhlplayoffs/story.html?id=463718). And Red Sox and New York Yankees fans once again set about trying to kill each other (http://deadspin.com/381980/you-know-its-baseball-season-when-fat-yanks+red-sox-fans-are-killing-each-other).
In May a Yankees fan driving a car (http://news.bostonherald.com/news/regional/general/view.bg?articleid=1092028&srvc=home&position=recent) ran down and killed a Red Sox fan who yelled: "Yankees suck".
June, fans of the Boston Celtics celebrated their NBA championship with a traditional window-smashing riot (http://www.complex.com/ENTERTAINMENT/FEATURES/Sports-Riots-A-History-of-Violence). This was after fans of the defeated Lakers mobbed up and savagely beat (http://blogs.laweekly.com/ladaily/sports/laker-fans-brawl-at-the-staple/) Celtics fans in LA. And the month also saw an unusually well publicised mass donnybrook (http://phillies.fandome.com/video/103246/Most-Shocking---Fans-Brawl-at-a-Phillies-Game/) at a Phillies v New York Mets baseball game.
In July Columbus Crew fans greeted visiting West Ham fans with a proper US-style fan punch-up (http://www.columbusdispatch.com/live/content/sports/stories/2008/07/21/crew~sep~side21.ART~sep~ART~sep~07-21-08~sep~C2~sep~R0AQ9IL.html?sid=101), inspiring one muppet to ask (http://www.doubleazone.com/2008/07/soccer~sep~fan~sep~violence.php): "We almost never see large-scale fights in other sports. Why does this happen in soccer?"
Also in July, a mob of baseball bat-wielding, "rabid" Red Sox fans (http://www.nypost.com/seven/07072008/news/nationalnews/bat~sep~snit~sep~crazy~sep~118830.htm) beat up a 69-year-old grandad they wrongly suspected of being a Yankees fan. Meanwhile another Red Sox fan lost an eye after being beaten by Cubs fans at a children's party (http://www.dailyherald.com/story/?id=224019).
August, two Chicago Cubs fans went on trial for beating a Brewers fan so badly he had to have his jaw wired (http://archives.chicagotribune.com/2008/aug/01/local/chi-cubs-fan-charges-webaug02).
September, an NFA game between the Utica Yard Dogs and Troy was abandoned after mass brawling in the stands spilled onto the pitch (http://www.wktv.com/sports/local/28376684.html). And gunfire broke out among the crowd (http://www.oregonlive.com/news/index.ssf/2008/09/possible~sep~gangrelated~sep~shooting.html) at a high school game in Portland, Oregon.
In October Phillies fans rioted in celebration of their World Series win, engaging in brawls, slinging beer bottles, flipping cars, destroying streetlights, smashing bank windows, wrecking bus shelters, attacking a TV news van (http://cbs3.com/video/?id=67450@kyw.dayport.com), setting fire to trees and looting a luggage store.
This was after "knuckle-dragging Neanderthal" Phillies fans had visited Tampa where, says Tampa Rays owner Stuart Sternberg, they engaged in "behaviour more suitable for a prison yard than a family ballpark." The Philadelphians allegedly cursed at children before throwing food at them, called women "whores", poured beer over a terrified nine-year-old boy, and frightened one Tampa fan so much that he locked himself in a toilet stall until the Philly fans outside got bored of making death threats. That same month police attacked fans of Penn State football team with pepper spray after a victory party turned into an orgy of violence and destruction (http://blogs.usatoday.com/gameon/2008/10/penn-state-fans.html).
In November a high school soccer game in Massachusetts "almost degenerated into a European-style football brawl" according to a local newspaper. Because, as we all now know, brawls in proper American sports hardly every happen.
Oh, hang on: over in North Carolina a pee wee American football game was stopped after fans and coaches start hitting each other (http://www.beaumontenterprise.com/news/local/34944604.html).
In December a mass brawl stopped a high school basketball game in Connecticut (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/29/sports/othersports/29sportsbriefs-BRAWLAMONGFA~sep~BRF.html). And the NFL (http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/nfl) game between the Patriots and the Arizona Cardinals saw mass drunkenness, 22 arrests, and a fan slamming into a player on the sidelines.
This month five teenage basketball fans were gunned down (http://www.momsteam.com/team-of-experts/gun-violence-at-athletic-contests-an-administrators-nightmare) after a high school a game in Chicago. And just a few weeks ago Giants fans responded to a play-off loss against the Eagles (http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/football/giants/2009/01/15/2009-01-15~sep~giant~sep~idiots~sep~caught~sep~on~sep~tape~sep~fans~sep~smash~sep~c.html) by going on a car-smashing rampage in the parking lot (http://www.sbs.com.au/blogarticle/108989/Yet-another-football-riot/blog/Matthew-Hall-Open-Season-br). This followed soon after the news that the NFL has asked fans with cell phones to rat out the worst offenders in an effort to curb the league's notorious thug-fan problem.
The NFL has long played long played host to a boorish, violent, drunken fan culture where, in the words of the New York Times (http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/04/opinion/04sun4.html), games are ruined by the "thuggery" of "bibulous (http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/bibulous) loudmouths" and "drunken louts [who] can be heard vilely abusing and threatening fans of the opposing team, and lewdly harassing women."
The story of the NFL rat-line (http://www.hereticalideas.com/2008/09/the-tribalism-of-sports-or-why-soccer-fans-riot-and-football-fans-dont/) was reported on Yahoo news with the headline: "Tattletales: NFL teams ask for text messages about rowdy fans". (I love that word "rowdy". It summons up images of recalcitrant toddlers. Or schoolchildren making a bit too much noise on the back of a bus.)
The big question is: can it happen here? Is Europe in danger of being infected by America's terrifying culture of sports mayhem, mass substance abuse, rioting and horrendous fan-on-fan violence (http://www.the700level.com/2008/06/fights-and-nitr.html)?
Let us hope not. Perhaps we Europeans (who let us not forget, have a few sports hooliganism problems of our own) will this time fail to copy the worst excesses of what the Buffalo News (http://www.buffalonews.com/248/story/488611.html) recently called "the most violent of all modern democratic nations in the world".

Cool Rob
24 Mar 2009, 04:05 PM
I read that Guardian article and didn't like it at all. I thought it was a cheap way of demeaning Americans (obviously the point of the artcle) by mixing apples and oranges.

In Europe, the hooligan problem is defined by violence in and outside the stadium and organized violence. But in America...the problem is somehow defined to include children's birthday parties, by writers desperate to say something bad about the US in our post-Obama euphoria to improve their readership's self-esteem.

You'll find Europeans are also much more violent if you include every pub fight tangentially related to sports. And then you have the fact that the US has 300 million people- if you want to include "Eastern" Europe in this list (Europe isn't just the UK, France, Italy, Germany) I guarantee the list of ""European sports violence" over the past year will run very, very long.

comme
24 Mar 2009, 05:30 PM
I read that Guardian article and didn't like it at all. I thought it was a cheap way of demeaning Americans (obviously the point of the artcle) by mixing apples and oranges.

In Europe, the hooligan problem is defined by violence in and outside the stadium and organized violence. But in America...the problem is somehow defined to include children's birthday parties, by writers desperate to say something bad about the US in our post-Obama euphoria to improve their readership's self-esteem.

You'll find Europeans are also much more violent if you include every pub fight tangentially related to sports. And then you have the fact that the US has 300 million people- if you want to include "Eastern" Europe in this list (Europe isn't just the UK, France, Italy, Germany) I guarantee the list of ""European sports violence" over the past year will run very, very long.

I'm not agreeing with the OP in the slightest, but that Guardian article is from 2005. I think relating it to Obama's America is a leap too far.

Cool Rob
24 Mar 2009, 06:17 PM
I'm not agreeing with the OP in the slightest, but that Guardian article is from 2005. I think relating it to Obama's America is a leap too far.

1) The article had to be updated for some strange reason:
Does Europe really have a bigger hooligan problem than America?
21 Jan 2009: Steven Wells: Perhaps it's time for Americans to look at their own fan thuggery problems before reporting hysterically on ours

2) The Presidential Inauguration of Barack Obama was held in Washington, DC on January 20, 2009.

Coincidence?

safe hands 01
25 Mar 2009, 01:28 AM
Does it really matter who has worse hooliganism, well i spose if your a hooligan it does but then fair enough. But to just us, people who like sports in general, be it soccer, or american football, or even kids birthdays :P

At the end of the day it doesnt matter!

That was a petty shot though, the guy who started this arguement, You only have to look at the hooligan films ratio, i am yet to see an american hooligan film :P

Excape Goat
25 Mar 2009, 01:31 AM
It's different. America is a much violent society (as stated by Congressman Lungren below). I have been to college football games where the fans were much more violent than I've seen in Europe, but those are drunken frat boys rather than hooligans belonging to an organized crime group.



In Europe, the hooligan groups are the fan clubs. Some of the groups evolved into organized criminal groups. The European hooligan groups are liked Hell's Angels in the US where a motocycle club evolved into a criminal organization. There isn't a "real" sport fan group in the US that is liked the Hell's Angels.

What I mean by "real"? Some athletic attire in the US are associated with street gangs. Some schools in the US banned attire bearing the logos of L.A. Raiders, LA Kings, Cincinnati Reds, on campus. I don't see those street gangs as a sport fan group. They just borrowed the logo of sport teams as their own symbol.





As California Congressman Dan Lungren put it: "America is, by far, the most violent country in the [industrialised] world … Violence is deeply rooted in our society and has become woven into the fabric of the American lifestyle."

man_in_the_middle
25 Mar 2009, 02:17 AM
It is an idiotic spin job of an article and argument.

The other posters are correct that these are isolated incidents of violence. Sporting tribes don't band together looking for fights in the states. There are crazy individuals in all countries. But no sane human is looking to beat up a man in his late 60s for any reason, and anyone who is fighting at a child's birthday party is as likely to brawl over the type of cake than sport.

There will always be incidents, especially in college areas, where there is mass drinking, which leads to violence. But it is very rare that as a visiting spectator you should be fearful of being jumped anywhere in the states. Unfortunately the same cannot be said for areas in Europe.

Tottenham4life the hooliganism has toned down considerably in England. But going to a football match can still be unsafe in many areas. I would not want to take my family to some areas of Eastern Europe for a match.

Tottenham4life
25 Mar 2009, 04:51 AM
ok mate, here it goes again to prove that not all of you yanks but a great few of you all you do is denied the fact that there is a problem with hooligans in USA just like there is everywhere else, it is a fact that USA is violent but is people like you that tries to be blind to the facts with the pretend that oh America is the greatest, come on stop the bullshit and admit to it, like i said it might not be just in soccer(like you call it) but the fact that fights happens in every single sport in the US is something that you better wake up for it and realized it it does happens so stop acting so goody goody tissue

nicephoras
25 Mar 2009, 05:06 AM
England no longer has a significant hooligan problem, but it did once. The US has no, and has never, had significant hooligan problems. It has many isolated incidents of stupid behavior, but the notion that groups of American fans go to sporting events looking for a fight is nonsense, and always was.
Thread closed.