Who is a United Legend ?

[Bex79]

Just been reading a few Ronaldo threads on other forums and one of them has descended into a discussion on what makes a United legend.

So what makes a player a United legend to you ? And who do you consider legends in those you've seen ?

[cr7torossi]

My criteria would be in order:
a. Genuinely in love with Manchester United
b. Always gives his 100% for the club
c. Individual achievements

Giggs, Scholes, Neville,Ole, Cantona, Brucey would fit the category.

Keane, Sparky, Ronaldo wouldn't.

btw, the caf is ridiculous even at the best of times:D

[Vermont Red]

My criteria is if I feel the player is a legend or not. Other than that, its completely arbitrary.

[yikchi]

My criteria would be in order:
a. Genuinely in love with Manchester United
b. Always gives his 100% for the club
c. Individual achievements

Giggs, Scholes, Neville,Ole, Cantona, Brucey would fit the category.

Keane, Sparky, Ronaldo wouldn't.

btw, the caf is ridiculous even at the best of times:D
WTF!!?

[MtP07]

- Gives their all to United.
- Is loyal to United.
- Embodies the United spirit.


And Roy Keane is 100% a United legend.

[Stud83]

No certain criteria, it's just how I feel about the player, similar to VR.

[cr7torossi]

WTF!!?

Well, as I pointed out, for me personally a legend can only be someone who loves the club.

[Stud83]

Well, as I pointed out, for me personally a legend can only be someone who loves the club.

Is Denis Law a legend in your opinion?

[cr7torossi]

Is Denis Law a legend in your opinion?

Based on what I have read, yes.

[Vermont Red]

Law is part of a statue in front of Old Trafford, so he must be a legend.

[Amdrag]

Keane is the first name on my list. The man was willing to die for United. Ask the manager.

[Bex79]

My criteria would be in order:
a. Genuinely in love with Manchester United
b. Always gives his 100% for the club
c. Individual achievements

Giggs, Scholes, Neville,Ole, Cantona, Brucey would fit the category.

Keane, Sparky, Ronaldo wouldn't.

btw, the caf is ridiculous even at the best of times:D

aye, certainly. :D That penalty takers thread I read on there a little while back was enough proof.

[FCDallas96]

Eric Cantona
Roy Keane
20LEgend
Steve Bruce
Sir Bobby Charlton
Ryan Giggs
Paul Scholes
Gary Neville
Mark Hughes
Denis Irwin
Peter Schmeichel
These are just a few for me.

[Twix]

Same as VR/Stud, it usually depends on how I feel about the player.

[israbeckham]

DAVID BECKHAM.

and cr7torossi you seriously left Keane out??:D

[Mighty_Mouse]

Cristiano Ronaldo: Legend, best player to ever put on a United shirt.

[Chaz Striker]

Cristiano Ronaldo: Legend, best player to ever put on a United shirt.

false

[urbnzy]

...Gary Neville
Mark Hughes
Denis Irwin...


Delete?

[Afro Mexican]

Cristiano Ronaldo: Legend, best player to ever put on a United shirt.
He was influential this past season, but how can there be a best in a team of 11? Our defense was influential too. Everyone has a job and to Ronaldo I say, "Job well done". Legend? Not yet...

[Vermont Red]

Cristiano Ronaldo: Legend, best player to ever put on a United shirt.

Agreed.