Robinho or Shaun Wright Phillips

[phil80]

That is in the past and he has failed to bring anything like that form to Real Madrid and Europe. On paper he is the better player but he has yet to prove it.
The game isn't being played on paper. Try keeping up, Teso. The thread is opinions on who is better- which is no question robinho, not who has recently hit better form with their club team- which is no question swp. Apparently, all your previous nonsensical posts have clouded your vision.

[Koby7STAR]

He should have a better chance with Schuster in charge.
yeah good point, capello, was clearly not a big fan of him and obviously wasn't a fas of Ronaldo

[User Name]

Robinho is still built like a 14 year old boy, all great players have that natural athletic strength - Pele, Maradona, Zidane. SWP is small but he is well built and tough.

Just my two.

[alocksley]

Robinho is the real deal and will be a fixture for Brazil for many years to come. He literally carried tham to the Copa America title the summer when the likes of Ronaldinho, Kaka and Adriano were 'resting' after a gruelling season.

SWP is a role player. He's a very good one, but I'm afraid that's all he'll ever be.

[bosterosoy]

Robinhodid great at the Copa America, but i feel he should leave madrid,

agrred, but there is no contest in this one.

Robinho >>> SWP
(and this is coming from an Argentinian :eek:

[Koby7STAR]

at full potential, Robinho is better than SWP,

[Teso Dos Bichos]

The game isn't being played on paper. Try keeping up, Teso. The thread is opinions on who is better- which is no question robinho, not who has recently hit better form with their club team- which is no question swp. Apparently, all your previous nonsensical posts have clouded your vision.

The discussion evolved. Try doing likewise.

[jpick]

Robinho is the real deal and will be a fixture for Brazil for many years to come. He literally carried tham to the Copa America title this summer

he did less than many in the semi's and final, he played very well up until then admittedly, but the single-handed stuff is overblown imho.

when Adriano was 'sobering up' after a gruelling season.

FYP :p.

[phil80]

The discussion evolved. Try doing likewise.
Once again, stick up for what you post, no matter how nonsensical it is

[Teso Dos Bichos]

Stop trolling.

[phil80]

BigSoccer's village idiot, aka Teso, is telling other people to stop trolling. Hysterical.

[Teso Dos Bichos]

I'm off to bed. I'll deal with your ignorance, stupidity and trolling later. :rolleyes:

[phil80]

OK village idiot, and while you're at it dream up some more ridiculous ideas to post.

[tedfirestone]

Not even close.

Until SWP accomplishes anything remotely close to what Robinho did recently at the Copa he doesn't even deserve to be mentioned in the same sentence.

Does SWP even get meaningful minutes for the English National team?

Brazil NT>England NT
Copa America> Anything SWP has played meaningful/impact minutes in.

[Teso Dos Bichos]

Likewise, until Robinho accomplishes anything remotely close to what Wright-Phillips has done in a European domestic season then he doesn't even deserve to be mentioned in the same sentence.

[Koby7STAR]

SWp's erformance for England waas fantastic, has this stepped up his chances agimst Robinho?

[Teso Dos Bichos]

He played better for Man City, so there is still more to come from SWP but considering he is finally getting a fair chance to play then he should eventually get there.

[phil80]

Anyone who doubts Robinho's talent needs to watch the Brazil-US game. Case closed.

[AussieLFCfan]

They are both overrated.

[phil80]

Yes, but when they are on form, they are absolutely brilliant.