View Full Version : Carlos Tevez vs. Wayne Rooney
roykeanes_safc
10 Jul 2007, 11:22 AM
Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo would surely disagree with that.
Ask SAF if he had to choose one of Rooney or Ronaldo to miss a season which one he would choose?
nicephoras
10 Jul 2007, 11:22 AM
England currently have the best young player in the world, the best defense in the world, one of the best cm in the world and in aaron lennon i believe we could have a world class winger. Ask anyone form the continent however we are a long ball team who cant keep the ball when in fact our players are being badly coached.
What is this England of which you speak? Aaron Lennon is a world class winger? Really?
cr7torossi
10 Jul 2007, 11:27 AM
England currently have the best young player in the world, the best defense in the world, one of the best cm in the world and in aaron lennon i believe we could have a world class winger. Ask anyone form the continent however we are a long ball team who cant keep the ball when in fact our players are being badly coached.
amongst the funniest statements I have read on BS.
Ask SAF if he had to choose one of Rooney or Ronaldo to miss a season which one he would choose?
SAF chose Ronaldo over Ruud. We will see what he does in the future.
roykeanes_safc
10 Jul 2007, 11:29 AM
What is this England of which you speak? Aaron Lennon is a world class winger? Really?
Key word in the passage "could"
roykeanes_safc
10 Jul 2007, 11:31 AM
amongst the funniest statements I have read on BS.
SAF chose Ronaldo over Ruud. We will see what he does in the future.
Ruud 29/30 years old, Ronaldo 22? if Ruud had been 25 years old im not sure hed have been so willing to let RVN go
Naughty by Nature
10 Jul 2007, 11:50 AM
Ask SAF if he had to choose one of Rooney or Ronaldo to miss a season which one he would choose?
I'm pretty sure he would want Ronaldo to play.
Teso Dos Bichos
10 Jul 2007, 11:55 AM
If anyone asks, this is not ducking out of anything. I'm simply tired of people playing the ignorant card and then creating even more arguments as they try to defend an untenable postion before swiftly trying to backtrack. I've said it all before and rather than repeat myself people can simply use the search function. If anyone has anything new to bring to the table then great. I can only hope it is of a better standard then our Sunderland friend.
I guess you need to look up the difference between "bashing" and "criticizing" in the dictionary :rolleyes: Please elaborate on how I "bashed" Ronaldo or Rooney.
Spartak, I'm not going to waste my time going back and quoting from all of your posts in this thread thus far. If you read back through them and honestly attempt to ask that same question again then I feel very sorry for you indeed. It's there for anyone to see and you know that full well.
Teso I'm still waiting for these Rooney bashing and belittling comments you claim I've made. Also using the term ignorance against other folks is well ignorant when you yourself can't accept that other people disagree with you. Were you ignored as a child?
If that is going to be your attitude then you will be waiting an awfully long time. Like Spartak, it is there for all to see. I did say you were not one of the worst but to claim you did not do it would be a lie. It has nothing to do with people disagreeing with me and I'm getting pretty tired of that accusation. I have detailed my complaint numerous times and on several threads. I stand by it. It is a simple concept to comprehend and I live in hope the ignorant in our midst (did I just say that again...) will finally be able to grasp it. Good day.
nicephoras
10 Jul 2007, 12:12 PM
Key word in the passage "could"
And England COULD have a world class striker in Emile Heskey. But they don't. Nor is Rooney the best young player in the world.
nicephoras
10 Jul 2007, 12:13 PM
If anyone asks, this is not ducking out of anything. I'm simply tired of people playing the ignorant card and then creating even more arguments as they try to defend an untenable postion before swiftly trying to backtrack. I've said it all before and rather than repeat myself people can simply use the search function. If anyone has anything new to bring to the table then great. I can only hope it is of a better standard then our Sunderland friend.
Spartak, I'm not going to waste my time going back and quoting from all of your posts in this thread thus far. If you read back through them and honestly attempt to ask that same question again then I feel very sorry for you indeed. It's there for anyone to see and you know that full well.
If that is going to be your attitude then you will be waiting an awfully long time. Like Spartak, it is there for all to see. I did say you were not one of the worst but to claim you did not do it would be a lie. It has nothing to do with people disagreeing with me and I'm getting pretty tired of that accusation. I have detailed my complaint numerous times and on several threads. I stand by it. It is a simple concept to comprehend and I live in hope the ignorant in our midst (did I just say that again...) will finally be able to grasp it. Good day.
If you don't stop with the victim crap I'm going to close the thread. Enough already.
As for everyone else - lets tone down anything personal. Please keep this thread clean.
SirManchester
10 Jul 2007, 12:21 PM
If you don't stop with the victim crap I'm going to close the thread. Enough already.
As for everyone else - lets tone down anything personal. Please keep this thread clean.
In all fairness, and you may not be a fan of Teso's posting style but he really has no choice. Reading back the last three or four pages it's like he was arguing with clowns. It's the same stuff that's been flooding this forum for almost two years now.
jpick
10 Jul 2007, 12:24 PM
And England COULD have a world class striker in Emile Heskey.
and he would be, if it wasn't for mcsven, oh that damn mcsven.
nicephoras
10 Jul 2007, 12:34 PM
In all fairness, and you may not be a fan of Teso's posting style but he really has no choice. Reading back the last three or four pages it's like he was arguing with clowns. It's the same stuff that's been flooding this forum for almost two years now.
Are you calling Spartak a clown?
As for the same stuff that's been "flooding this forum for two years now", Teso's replies aren't helping.
Anyone who has an issue with the forum should feel free to send me a PM. Otherwise, keep it private.
SirManchester
10 Jul 2007, 01:33 PM
Are you calling Spartak a clown?
No, why do you care?
In fact I was referring to just about every other poster who has contributed absolutely nothing short of a reasonable argument. And this is in favor of either player.
SIR-T
10 Jul 2007, 01:38 PM
The best young player all comes down to personal choice, for me the top five young players in the world are,
Ronaldo
Rooney
Messi
Tevez
Fabregas
All these are very close in terms of quality and they can only get better. I dont see the point of comparing them, because they are all world class players.
Val1
10 Jul 2007, 01:45 PM
He will not displace Rooney and the interesting thing will be the partnership they will form. It has the potential to be explosive and they vary just enough to make it workable. Obviously time will tell but exciting times are ahead.
You have no idea whether or not Rooney will be displaced. And most clubs don't have the money to bring in one someone as talented, and presumably as expensive, as Tevez when you have someone as young as good as Rooney. But Man Utd is not most clubs, and so you'll have this glut. I saw more West Ham games last year than Arsenal games (my brother's a West Ham fan), even four or five when Tevez was being mishandled by Pardew, and I just think he's better. And they're most effective, to me, playing the withdrawn striker.
nicephoras
10 Jul 2007, 01:46 PM
No, why do you care?
Because Teso is arguing with Spartak. Are you claiming Spartak is a clown?
jpick
10 Jul 2007, 01:48 PM
spartak doesn't know his arse from a hole in the ground
:D
SirManchester
10 Jul 2007, 01:50 PM
Because Teso is arguing with Spartak. Are you claiming Spartak is a clown?
My apologies, I was under the impression that he was arguing against several other posters as well.
nicephoras
10 Jul 2007, 01:55 PM
Don't apologize to me - I've never even met Spartak and his club continues to poach my club's captains.
But keep in mind that once you lower the level of discourse you can't claim its the fault of other people.
cr7torossi
10 Jul 2007, 01:57 PM
spartak doesn't his know arse from a hole in the ground
:D
seconded:D