Current Music Draft > > Voting / Results / Post-Draft Discussion < <

[Crimen y Castigo]

For Drafting Participants Only
Unless you were participating in the Current Music Draft, please refrain from posting here until all 15 drafters have voted.


This thread is for the 15 participants of the Current Music Draft to vote for their top three lists in order of preference -- excluding their own. The winner will be the person who receives the most points from their fellow drafters:
1st Place votes= 5 points
2nd Place votes = 3 points
3rd Place votes = 1 point

The Drafters are also encouraged to post arguments / analysis / diatribes as to why their list of albums is the most mind-expanding, balls-to-the-wall, gorgeous, body movin', gutbucket, heaviest, most ethereal, and just plain rocking compendium of modern music imaginable.

Once those fifteen members have posted their votes / treatises, it's open season for other posters. Contrary to a previous post, I will leave the general draft thread open for general discussion.

Drafters should post votes / arguments at will. No need to follow the drafting order.

The Big Board is finalized and available here. (http://www.bigsoccer.com/forum/showthread.php?t=501479)

You can go directly the lists of each Drafter here.
(http://www.bigsoccer.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10991257&postcount=2)

The Drafters are:

Karl K
bmurphyfl
nicodemus
bestbecks
Jeremy Eritrea
SirManchester
Matt in the Hat
Toon³
frenil
scaryice
quentinc
Achtung
billyireland
sch2383
yellowbismark


Have at it.

[billyireland]

3) Karl K.
2) Toon3.

...

(drumroll and a fart)

1) bestbecks.

[frenil]

1. sch2383
2. bmurphyfl
3. quentinc

[sch2383]

1. bmurphyfl
2. billyireland
3. Achtung

[MLS SupaStr3]

1.) Toon³
2.) Achtung
3.) bmurphyfl

Honorable mention to sch2383 for introducing me to Okkervil River. Thanks a lot!


Mod's Note:
Not to be a fascist or anything, but only votes by fellow drafters will be counted.
--CyC

[yellowbismark]

3 - frenil
2 - Karl Keller
1 - nicodemus

I'm running low on time, so I'll just get my voting out of the way for now, I'll give my reasonings later.

sch2383 is my honorable mention...

[bestbecks]

3 - bmurphyfl
2 - billyireland

and my number one selection goes to...

1 - frenil

Honourable mention goes out to nicodemus, great stuff picked by him.

Great draft to everyone who participated. I was glad to be a part of it. Thanks for introducing me to a lot of new music guys. :)

[quentinc]

My vote:

1) sch2383
2) yellowbismark
3) billyireland

I liked scaryice's list until he imploded down the stretch.

[sch2383]

I liked scaryice's list until he imploded down the stretch.

Seriously. We need explanation for those picks.

[bestbecks]

Seriously. We need explanation for those picks.
Yeah really. You don't just pick those two albums after picking such great ones and not explain the reason for it, lol.

[JeremyEritrea]

My votes

JeremyEritrea
quentinc
Toon³


And hell yes I'm gonna vote my list the best. :p

[Crimen y Castigo]

My votes

JeremyEritrea
quentinc
Toon³


And hell yes I'm gonna vote my list the best. :p


Not that you don't have a quality list, but:

"...vote for their top three lists in order of preference -- excluding their own. The winner will be the person who receives the most points from their fellow drafters..."

[JeremyEritrea]

Not that you don't have a quality list, but:

"...vote for their top three lists in order of preference -- excluding their own. The winner will be the person who receives the most points from their fellow drafters..."

Whoops. Then make mine

quentinc
Toon³
bmurphyfl

[Toon³]

1. bmurphyfl
2. nicodemus
3. frenil

All chosen because of their picks that were music that I like and music I'd never heard before but now like.

[frenil]

1 - frenil


You have impeccable taste, no doubt. Seriously though, I didn't expect to be placed in first place by anyone.

[bmurphyfl]

1 - frenil
2 - Bestbecks
3 - Jeremy Eritrea

[scaryice]

I don't know I can make a fair list when I haven't heard half the albums. I would be basically picking the people who picked stuff that I'm familiar with. It's not like the USA draft where you can judge how your team would be.

[JeremyEritrea]

Looks like the vote is going nearly as fast as the actual "choices" thread did.

:D

[nicodemus]

I feel like scaryice in that I don't really feel like I can come up with an informed top 3.

[bmurphyfl]

Isn't it the American way to vote regardless of how informed you are?