Players player of the year

[Scottish_Morton]

Nominees:

SPL: Artur Boruc, Lee Naylor, Shunsuke Nakamura, Russell Anderson

SPL Young player: Scott Brown, Aiden McGeady, Steven Naismith, Charlie Adam

SFL1: Colin McMenamin, Mark Roberts, Jason Scotland, Goran Stanic

SFL2: Chris Aitken, Paul McGowan, Iain Russell, Peter Weatherson

SFL3: Martin Johnston, David Weatherston, Gary Wood, Neil Jablonski

Weatherson surely has to win the SFL2 award, Anderson deserves the SPL award, he gets nowhere near the amount of recognition he deserves. Young player is probably too close to call, McGeady had a good start to the season, same with Adam, Naismith has come into things as the season has progressed, Brown has been quality in an inconsistant Hibs side.

[Burkies Ginger Mop]

Nominees:

SPL: Artur Boruc, Lee Naylor, Shunsuke Nakamura, Russell Anderson

SPL Young player: Scott Brown, Aiden McGeady, Steven Naismith, Charlie Adam

SFL1: Colin McMenamin, Mark Roberts, Jason Scotland, Goran Stanic

SFL2: Chris Aitken, Paul McGowan, Iain Russell, Peter Weatherson

SFL3: Martin Johnston, David Weatherston, Gary Wood, Neil Jablonski

Weatherson surely has to win the SFL2 award, Anderson deserves the SPL award, he gets nowhere near the amount of recognition he deserves. Young player is probably too close to call, McGeady had a good start to the season, same with Adam, Naismith has come into things as the season has progressed, Brown has been quality in an inconsistant Hibs side.

Who does Chris Aitken play for these days?

[eirebhoy]

Nakamura should walk away with the poty award. I dread to think what we'd be like without him. Granted he's rarely at his best when the Setanta cams are on him but he has been man of the match against every team this season, bar Rangers. The opposing teams all got to see him at his best and he is on another level to anyone in the league.

[Scottish_Morton]

Who does Chris Aitken play for these days?

Stirling. Bit of a surprise that he's up for this award.

[YankHibee]

Nakamura and Brown for me.

[Burkies Ginger Mop]

Stirling. Bit of a surprise that he's up for this award.

I was at school with him and his Brother. One of those cases when I look at them and some of the people I played football with at School and wonder how they made it!

[Gordon EF]

I expect the winners to be Nakamura, Scotland, Wheatherson, Johnston.

[United Pumps]

Nakamura. I don't follow the other leagues so I can't really comment.

[celtic76]

Nominees:

SPL: Artur Boruc, Lee Naylor, Shunsuke Nakamura, Russell Anderson

SPL Young player: Scott Brown, Aiden McGeady, Steven Naismith, Charlie Adam

SFL1: Colin McMenamin, Mark Roberts, Jason Scotland, Goran Stanic

SFL2: Chris Aitken, Paul McGowan, Iain Russell, Peter Weatherson

SFL3: Martin Johnston, David Weatherston, Gary Wood, Neil Jablonski

Weatherson surely has to win the SFL2 award, Anderson deserves the SPL award, he gets nowhere near the amount of recognition he deserves. Young player is probably too close to call, McGeady had a good start to the season, same with Adam, Naismith has come into things as the season has progressed, Brown has been quality in an inconsistant Hibs side.

SPL: Nakamura
SPL: Brown
SFL1: Scotland
SF2: N/A
SF3: N/A

[Teso Dos Bichos]

SPL: Shunsuke Nakamura
SPL: Steven Naismith
SFL1: Colin McMenamin
SFL2: Iain Russell
SFL3: Scott Chaplain

Manager: Gordon Strachan
Community Club: Falkirk
Special Merit Award: Eusebio

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/scot_prem/6582025.stm

[Teso Dos Bichos]

Team of the Year

SFL1

Goalkeeper: Alan Main (Gretna)
Defenders: Martin Canning (Gretna), Neil McGregor (Clyde), Kevin James (St Johnstone), Goran Stanic (St Johnstone)
Midfielders: Craig Bryson (Clyde), Alex Rae (Dundee), Don Cowie (Ross County)
Forwards: Jason Scotland (St Johnstone), Colin McMenamin (Gretna), Mark Roberts (Partick Thistle)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/scot_div_1/6586371.stm

SFL2

Goalkeeper: Paul Mathers (Morton)
Defenders: Peter Weatherson (Morton), Stewart Greacen (Morton), Todd Lumsden (Raith Rovers), Ross Forsyth (Stirling Albion)
Midfielders: Jamie Stevenson (Morton), Chris Aitken (Stirling Albion), Kieran McAnespie (Alloa Athletic)
Forwards: Liam Buchanan (Cowdenbeath), Iain Russell (Brechin City), Paul McGowan (Morton)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/scot_div_1/6586373.stm

SFL3

Goalkeeper: Stephen Grindlay (Dumbarton)
Defenders: Paul Paton (Queen's Park), Jonathon Smart (East Fife), David Craig (Dumbarton), Chris McGroarty (Berwick Rangers)
Midfielders: Stuart Kettlewell (Queen's Park), Scott Chaplain (Albion Rovers), Paul Stewart (East Stirlingshire)
Forwards: Garry Wood (Berwick Rangers), David Weatherston (Queen's Park), Martin Johnston (Elgin City)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/scot_div_1/6586381.stm



Voted for by the managers. I do not agree with the First Division team. How do the other teams look?

[Gordon EF]

Team of the Year

SFL3

Goalkeeper: Stephen Grindlay (Dumbarton)
Defenders: Paul Paton (Queen's Park), Jonathon Smart (East Fife), David Craig (Dumbarton), Chris McGroarty (Berwick Rangers)
Midfielders: Stuart Kettlewell (Queen's Park), Scott Chaplain (Albion Rovers), Paul Stewart (East Stirlingshire)
Forwards: Garry Wood (Berwick Rangers), David Weatherston (Queen's Park), Martin Johnston (Elgin City)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/scot_div_1/6586381.stm



Voted for by the managers. I do not agree with the First Division team. How do the other teams look?

No goalkeeper has stood out in the 3rd this season so Grindlay's as fair a pick as anyone to me although Dumbarton fans don't really rate him.

Paul Paton, Jonathon Smart and McGroarty are fair shouts although I'd stick Grant McNicholl or Robbie Horn of Berwick in instead of Davie Graig any day.

You could probably pick 3 of about 10 midfielders if you were doing a 3. All those are decent picks. Gary Greenhil, Neil Jablonski and Ryan Borris are all just as good IMO.

Top 3 strikers should be Johnston, Craig O'Reilly and David Wheatherston.

[camerondocherty]

do u think the player voted for themselves?

[Teso Dos Bichos]

The managers voted.

[camerondocherty]

then why is it the players' player of the year?

[mcoconnor8390]

bazza in team of the year shocker:eek:

only captain to get his manager mutually consented FACT;)

[Gordon EF]

then why is it the players' player of the year?

Players pick the player of the year, managers pick the team of the year. I doubt players can vote for themselves, they can't even vote for team mates at the nomination stage.

[Teso Dos Bichos]

do u think the player voted for themselves?

then why is it the players' player of the year?

I thought you were referring to the teams.