PDA

View Full Version : Player gesturing for a card


DadOf6
28 Mar 2007, 10:09 PM
I just pulled this from www.ussoccer-data.com:

To: National Referees
National Assessors
National Instructors
State Referee Administrators
State Directors of Assessment
State Directors of Instruction
CC: National Referee Committee
From: Alfred Kleinaitis
Manager of Referee Development and Education
Re: Misconduct -- Player Gesturing for a Card
Date: March 23, 2007

Major League Soccer (MLS) gave a presentation at the 2007 National Camp which included a request that referees pay particular attention to the practice of players gesturing in a manner traditionally interpreted as a request or demand that a card be given to an opponent for some action. The same topic has drawn attention recently in certain European competitions.

FIFA, the international body responsible for developing and implementing the Laws of the Game for all national associations, has consistently emphasized “Fair Play” and USSF supports this concern. Although there is no automatic rule that player gestures calling for a card must be cautioned, such actions can be considered cautionable if they are blatantly disruptive, for example, by indicating disagreement with an official’s decision, aggressively aimed at a particular opponent or an official, or being part of a simulation (faking) to gain a favorable decision. The public nature of the action often makes the gesture too obvious to ignore and can spread to other players, who either agree or disagree, thus provoking further conflict.

Referees must be sensitive to any effort by affiliated leagues or tournaments to support the highest level of sporting behavior and should deal promptly with players who engage in misconduct.

The idea of giving a caution for this has never crossed my mind. It seems to me the same as a beaten defender raising an arm to ask for an offside flag.

falcon.7
28 Mar 2007, 10:30 PM
Score one for the irony department.

"You think I should caution him. Sure, and here's one for you too".

I think we can file this under "dissent" if a player decides to force the issue after you've made a decision. The decision to card or not to card is yours and yours alone. However, if a situation happens, say if a player elbows another, but you don't see it well enough to decide 100% if it is a caution or send-off, and the teamates of said foulee chase after the other player, chances are there was something that wasn't entirely up to scratch.

mw26
28 Mar 2007, 10:35 PM
http://sport.independent.co.uk/football/european/article1948164.ece


very often a yellow, in my book

IASocFan
29 Mar 2007, 12:39 AM
http://sport.independent.co.uk/football/european/article1948164.ece


very often a yellow, in my book

Interesting, but your sources was date 2 Nov, 2006.

mw26
29 Mar 2007, 12:49 AM
Interesting, but your sources was date 2 Nov, 2006.

and....?

it was this season, and this was the match i immediately thought of when this was brought up.

funny that chelski would complain :rolleyes:

pot calling the kettle black