Mejor Arquero de la CONCACAF???

[MetroChile]

Por ahi lei que Ricardo Foster (Guate.) iba a firmar por el Pachuca mexicano. Lo he visto poco como para tener una opinion formada de el, aunque si va a Mexico, no debe ser muy malo.

Por lo tanto, mi pregunta es la siguiente: cuales son los mejores arqueros de la CONCACAF? (Como un requisito minimo, tienen que aun estar disponibles para su seleccion, o sea en este caso...Friedel y Keller estarian descartados.) Asumo que en la "parte alta" de la lista estarian Ochoa, Sanchez, Hanhemann, Howard, Alfaro, Porras, Jack, Hislop...?

Metro

[MoRado]

Jose Francisco Porras and his 15 angels

[vettgt]

ricardo foster is nice hopeful they pick him up in mex that would boost his game up even more

[EduarDitto]

US keepers are very good.

Porras? Are you kidding me? I think that the Under-20 Tico keeper will be in the senior squad in the near future, he looked very solid in the qualifiers.

What Guate keeper are you talking about? The one who plays for Marquense was excellent.

[MetroChile]

US keepers are very good.

1. Porras? Are you kidding me? I think that the Under-20 Tico keeper will be in the senior squad in the near future, he looked very solid in the qualifiers.

What Guate keeper are you talking about? The one who plays for Marquense was excellent.

1. I was just mentioning him as CR is one of the stronger CONCACAF sides--I wasn't trying to neccesarily say he was one of the best GKs in the region. Speaking of the CR U20 GK, though, doesn't he play in Europe?

2. I am referring to Foster. I don't know whether he is the one that plays for Marquense.

Metro

[EduarDitto]

1. I was just mentioning him as CR is one of the stronger CONCACAF sides--I wasn't trying to neccesarily say he was one of the best GKs in the region. Speaking of the CR U20 GK, though, doesn't he play in Europe?

According to Wikipedia he plays for Alajuelense.

[MoRado]

he played last season for a 3rd-4th division team in Spain, right now he has no team

[Antonio81]

It would probably be an American keeper, loads of them are world-class. Our keeper Conejo in 1990 was considered the best in that World Cup by several sportswriters.

[Crazy_Yank]

Friedel, Howard, and then Keller. After that there is a huge drop off. I do like Tony Warner from T&T. I think he has the making of a good EPL keeper.

[MetroChile]

Friedel, Howard, and then Keller. After that there is a huge drop off. I do like Tony Warner from T&T. I think he has the making of a good EPL keeper.

Yea, I would agree, but on the 1st post I tried to establish being an int. currently as a parameter. :o Though if we discount that, you're 100% right.

I thought Warner had not been allowed to play for TnT?

Metro

[Jabinho]

Friedel, Howard, and then Keller. After that there is a huge drop off. I do like Tony Warner from T&T. I think he has the making of a good EPL keeper.
Hahnemann should at least get some mention.. He has been the top ranked goalkeeper in England by Actim for a bit now..

As at: Tue 27 Feb 07 09:35

Name Index Score Overall Index Rank Team
1 marcus hahnemann 378 14 Reading
2 edwin van der sar 371 16 Manchester United
3 david james 366 20 Portsmouth
4 jose reina 359 23 Liverpool
5 tim howard 343 32 Everton


http://www.premierleague.com/fapl.rac?command=forwardOnly&nextPage=actimTop5&type=Goal%20Keeper

He's also their keeper of the year so far:

http://www.premierleague.com/fapl.rac?command=forwardOnly&nextPage=teamOfTheSeason

[Crazy_Yank]

Yea, I would agree, but on the 1st post I tried to establish being an int. currently as a parameter. :o Though if we discount that, you're 100% right.

I thought Warner had not been allowed to play for TnT?

Metro


I can't believe I forgot about Hahneman, but we have so many awesome keepers it's hard to keep track of all of them :D. I believe Warner is eligible for T&T. I believe it was Lloyd Samuels who was ruled ineligible due to appearences with England's U21's.

[Guatefc]

Ricardo Trigueño Foster, Marquense(Guate) is becoming a star on the Intl' level(WCQ 2006, best GAA in the UNCAF tourney) and Club level ( Marquense CCC), and he is being chased by Mexican copa sudaamerican Champs Pachuca, he has the size 6,2 the wing span, the reflexes, reaction time. he is definatley the Hottest keeper in region right now, awaiting a transfer.




he is up there , but me personally i think the best has to Kasey Keller and Sanchez.

Hislop on FC dallas is a little shakey , he is #2 behind Dario Sala on his team, and gets 2.5+ gaa of late

Hahnemann is a up and comer but, i lack seeing him play at the intl' level for the USA

Jamie penedo? was sublime 2 years ago, i haven't heard from him him in a while

[Deathdealer]

My response would be:

1. US keepers

2. Osvaldo Sanchez

3. Porras

US keepers have proven there worth in Europe and that makes the diffrence.

[whitemexican]

an honest reply:

1- Ochoa

2- Sanchez and Howard

3- Corona

[anthony85]

an honest reply:

1- Ochoa

2- Sanchez and Howard

3- Corona

That's the sad part

[Crazy_Yank]

an honest reply:

1- Ochoa

2- Sanchez and Howard

3- Corona



*rolling on the floor laughing my ass off* I'm an America fan, but Ochoa sucks. Sorry, but there isn't a single Mexican keeper who could get a sniff in the US team.

[Crazy_Yank]

My response would be:

1. US keepers

2. Osvaldo Sanchez

3. Porras

US keepers have proven there worth in Europe and that makes the diffrence.



Here it is. Thread over. Lock it up. The 3 US EPL keepers are amoung the tops in the world's best league. Until Mexico has a keeper that can claim that there isn't any way a person can claim someone playing in a lesser league is better.

[MightyMouse]

*rolling on the floor laughing my ass off* I'm an America fan, but Ochoa sucks. Sorry, but there isn't a single Mexican keeper who could get a sniff in the US team.

I'd take Sanchez as backup for sure!

[Crazy_Yank]

I'd take Sanchez as backup for sure!



Maybe we can use him as a late game sub if we need someone to take a cheap shot at an opposing striker :D Truth be told I respect Sanchez as a goalkeeper. He';s a pretty good player and could probably do well in a league like Holland or Portugal. I do think both Ochoa (I'm even saying this as an America fan) and Corona are pretty poor.