Premiership, Seria A, La Liga e.t.c Best Eleven [Archive]

View Full Version : Premiership, Seria A, La Liga e.t.c Best Eleven

Pages : [1] 2 3 4

Dantheman1

25 Dec 2006, 10:15 AM

Which league could produce the best team? Choose the top Eleven players from a league anywhere in the world.

A Premiership Dream Team

Given

Eboue Terry Ferdinand A Cole

C Ronaldo Gerrard Parker Robben

Henri Drogba

The Old Lady Hertha

25 Dec 2006, 08:06 PM

England

-------------van der Sar-------------
Eboue---Toure----Vidic-------A. Cole
-------------Makelele----------------
Ronaldo-----------------------Robben
--------------Gerrard----------------
--------Henry------Drogba-----------

Italy (excluding Juve)
-------------Dida--------------------
Oddo-----Materazzi--Barzagli--Grosso
-------------Pirlo-------------------
Gattuso--------------------Stankovic
---------------Kaka----------------
------Ibrahimovic----Toni-----------

Spain
-------------Casillas---------------
D. Alves---Puyol----Cannavaro--Zambrotta
Joaquin---Deco----Jesus Navas---Ronaldinho
--------Eto'o------Villa/Torres-----

Germany
---------Weidenfeller--------------
Sagnol---van Buyten-Mertesacker-Lahm
-------------Frings---------------
Schweinsteiger----------van der Vaart
-------------Diego---------------
---Klose---------Pantelic---------

France
-----------Coupet----------------
Faubert--Cris---Cacapa----Tafforeau
------------Juninho--------------
Ribery-----------------------Malouda
------------Bodmer--------------
----Aruna Dindane----Feindouno--

Difficult to say...I think Ligue Un has the worst lineup, followed by Italy actually, and then close by in Germany. England and Spain fight out for top spot.

Walter3000

25 Dec 2006, 09:38 PM

-----------------Given

Eboue------Gallas----Terry-------Cole

Cronaldo----Essien---Lampard------Cole

-----------Drogba------Henry

-----------------Casillas

Miguel-------Puyol----Cannavaro------Zambrotta

-------------Xavi-----Deco

Messi----------------------------Ronnie

-----------Ruud-------Villa

Teso Dos Bichos

25 Dec 2006, 09:47 PM

I'll have a quick stab at this. I'm not going on recent form or reputation but picking the team I would want from each league. I'm also sticking to the same formation (1 support striker, 1 winger) for easy comparison. Clearly not the most accurate way of doing things but flame away.

England

--------- Adebayor
--- Rooney ------------ Ronaldo
------ Scholes
---------------- Gerrard
---------- Makelele
Heinze - Vidic - Ferdinand - Neville
----------- Cech

Italy

----------- Suazo
-- Mutu ------------- Mancini
------- Totti
-------------- De Rossi
----------- Corini
Grosso - Chivu - Mexes - Oddo
----------- Amelia

Spain

----------- Van Nistelrooy
--- Nihat ----------------- Navas
------- Ronaldinho
------------------ Xavi
------------- Poulsen
Zambrotta - Puyol - Ayala - Miguel
-------------- Casillas

Germany

-------------- Klose
---- Podolski ------------ Trochowski
---------- Diego
----------------- v.Bommel
------------- Frings
Lahm - v.Buyten - Metzelder - Sagnol
-------------- Kahn

France

--------- Koller
-- Kalou ----------- Ribery
------ Juninho
-------------- Bodmer
--------- Toure
Abidal - Cris - Yepes - Cufré
--------- Coupet

Miran Klosnic

26 Dec 2006, 05:11 AM

England:

------------------Given

--Eboue---Terry----------Vidic----A.Cole

-----------------Makelele

-----Essien---------------------Lampard

------------------Gerrard

----------Drogba----------Henry

Coach: Wenger
Bench: van der Saar, C.Ronaldo, Ballack, Carragher, Rooney

Germany:

-------------------Enke

--Sagnol---Mertesacker--Naldo---Lahm

--------------van Bommel

----Frings------------------van der Vaart

-----------------Diego

---------Klose------------Makaay

Coach: Schaaf
Bench: Weidenfeller, van Buyten, Pantelic, Schweinsteiger, Hargreaves

It was important for me that these teams would be able to play successful together. So I maybe didn't always chose the best players overall!

Bluecrux

26 Dec 2006, 07:02 AM

England
--------------------Lehmann-------------------
--Eboue-----Terry-------Ferdinand-------Cole---
-------------------------------------------------
-------------Ballack-----Gerrard------------------
--C.ronaldo---------------------------Robben-----
---------------Drogba-----Henry-----------------

Germany
------------------Kahn----------------------------
--Sagnol----van Buyten--Mertesacker--------Lahm
----------------------------------------------------
----------------Hargreaves--------------------------
--Deisler:D ------Diego/vDv------------Schweinstieger
----------Klose---------------????---------------------

Teso Dos Bichos

26 Dec 2006, 01:53 PM

We'll see how Deisler does. Certainly a great talent and great potential but too many problems in his career. Let's hope he gets a clean run from now.

Teso Dos Bichos

26 Dec 2006, 01:55 PM

It was important for me that these teams would be able to play successful together. So I maybe didn't always chose the best players overall!

When then, did you have two stoppers in central defense (Terry/Vidic are not complementary) and Lampard/Gerrard in midfield when it's clear they cannot function together?

ForeverRed

26 Dec 2006, 03:51 PM

Slight differences in mine:

-------------------------Kahn-----------------------

Sagnol-------Van Buyten--------Naldo-------Lahm----

------------------Frings-----------------------------

-------VdV--------------------MvB------------------

------------------------------------Schweiny-------

------------------Diego-----------------------------

--------------------------Klose----------------------

I always wanted to see Schweinsteiger in a free roaming role.

As for the EPL:

---------------------Lehmann------------------------------

Finnan---------Vidic---------------Agger-----------Barry---

----------------------Essien-----------------------------

Hleb---------------------------------------Ronaldo----

------------------Gerrard-------------------------------

--------------Henry----------Berbatov--------------------

sinner78

26 Dec 2006, 03:51 PM

prem

..........Lehmann..........

...richards.....Vidic....Ferdinand....Gallas

...lennon....makelele......ballack.....gerrard

.............henry.....rooney

Teso Dos Bichos

26 Dec 2006, 04:00 PM

Berbatov

I knew someone had slipped my mind. Even more embarrassing considering he was in my draft team. Switch Adebayor for Berbatiov. Before anyone asks I left Saha out because I cannot stand watching him miss easy chances and I left Drogba out because he has the same problem.

Bluecrux

27 Dec 2006, 01:27 AM

When then, did you have two stoppers in central defense (Terry/Vidic are not complementary) and Lampard/Gerrard in midfield when it's clear they cannot function together?

Very true.That's why they cannot produce the same terrfic perfomances at the country level.There cant be more than one '#8' in a team + you cannot play them in the CAM because they demand possesion

Bluecrux

27 Dec 2006, 01:31 AM

Bluecrux

27 Dec 2006, 01:37 AM

....and I left Drogba out because he has the same problem.
After his reading double,do you think that the UNSTOPPABLE and UNTOUCHABLE drogs should be left out:D

Teso Dos Bichos

27 Dec 2006, 11:52 AM

Still do. He's clearly in a great run of form at the moment but it's too early to tell if he will continue at this level. Aside from the diving, he still has issues with being clinical and putting away the easy chances, something I do not like in a striker and even more so when my formation only has one (although I suppose I have been spoiled by Ruud/Ole in my time).

Colm

27 Dec 2006, 12:15 PM

Prem

----------------------------Van Der Sar-----------------------------

---Richards--------------Vidic------------Ferdinand--------------A. Cole---

---Ronaldo-------------Essien----------Gilberto-------------Lennon---

-------------------------Rooney---------Drogba----------------------

On this seasons form.

yasik19

27 Dec 2006, 12:27 PM

w/out injuries, the best 11 would be:

-----------------------Cech
Eboue----------Terry----------Gallas------------ACole
Ronaldo-----------Essien----------Gerrard---------JCole
-------------Henry----------------Drogba

with current injuries, VDS woudl replace Cech, Vidic would replace Terry, Robben would replace JCole.

JuveFE

27 Dec 2006, 12:35 PM

like your team colm but if your going on this years form wouldn't want to replace an injured henry with someone like saha? just a thought.

Spartak

27 Dec 2006, 02:45 PM

Most of the Serie A teams in this thread are crap. As of right now here is the best eleven in Serie A:

-------------------------Dida
Oddo---------Mexes-------------Chivu---------Zanetti
-----------------------De Rossi
--------Kaka---------------------------Mancini
-------------------Totti
-----------------------------Toni

The Old Lady Hertha

27 Dec 2006, 02:47 PM

I think Barzagli's club form is very good (if not for Italy). I think he's better than Chivu now, but thats just my opinion.