Rate the player above

[Alan D]

Very fast, good going forward and good defence, but lacks in concentration. 7/10

Jihai Sun

One of the most versatile and useful squad players in the whole world as he can play anywhere in midfield and defence. Lacks the talent and consistency to settle down a first team place but will always give you 110% and his energy can brighten up a side. Hampered by injury the last few seasons that has limited his appearances for City.

Usefulness: 10/10
As a first team player and this season: 5.5/10

Andy Cole (now at Birmingham on-loan but Portsmouth own his contract)

[Dear_Claudio]

Mikel a 5/10 but Denilson a 7/10?:rolleyes:

[tigerdave]

Andy Cole (now at Birmingham on-loan but Portsmouth own his contract)

Couldn't get a game at Pompey, but scored when he did. Can't give a rating for four games, really.

James Milner

[The Old Lady Hertha]

Flashes of brilliance, flashes of mediocrity. 6 out of 10 I guess, but he's got potential and consistency usually comes at a later age.

Dickie Wright :D

[5_EUROPEAN_CUPS]

Flashes of brilliance, flashes of mediocrity. 6 out of 10 I guess, but he's got potential and consistency usually comes at a later age.

Dickie Wright :D

0 He had 1 but he dropped it.

Matias Fernandez.

[Gunner14Kiwi]

Mikel a 5/10 but Denilson a 7/10?:rolleyes:

Coming from a chelsea fan:rolleyes: , Mikel has hardly started a game, so what you want me to put down 7/8 for a guy who has start something like 5-10 game, get real.Denilson is alot young and less experienced but filled the gap up well, when needed.

[Dear_Claudio]

Coming from a chelsea fan:rolleyes: , Mikel has hardly started a game, so what you want me to put down 7/8 for a guy who has start something like 5-10 game, get real.Denilson is alot young and less experienced but filled the gap up well, when needed.Ah, you are the idiot who ranked him. Not only has Mikel played far more than Denilson but Mikel is 100x the player.

[The Old Lady Hertha]

Ah, you are the idiot who ranked him. Not only has Mikel played far more than Denilson but Mikel is 100x the player.

i believe this is about personal preference, not about who you think is right or wrong. i think mikel is better right now, but who are you to call someone an idiot for believing something like that?

who is matias fernandez? i don't recall a player in the Prem with that name.

joleon lescott

[Dear_Claudio]

No, I know he's an idiot because he trolls the Chelsea forum with absolute nonsense. If a logical person honestly hadn't seen Mikel and had seen the Brazilian kid then maybe it'd be okay. However, Mikel wouldn't get a 5 from anyone who knew what he was about.

Fernandez is a Chilean who plays for Villareal, doesn't belong in this thread if someone brought him up.


Lescott - 72/100. Despite being somewhat disformed, he's a very good defender. Proven himself after jumping up a division, I rather like him.

[Chelsea8-0Manu]

Wayne Bridge

[three lions]

Wayne Bridge

Nice defender...Too injury prone.....

Ledley King

[Chelsea8-0Manu]

Nice defender...Too injury prone.....

Ledley King

Nice, rating two players with one statement.

Gabriel Agbonlahor

[three lions]

Nice, rating two players with one statement.

Gabriel Agbonlahor

LOL.. You caught that did you.. Good job..:D

Aggie is a decent young talent.. Needs to be a little more disciplined in his position, but that will come..

[Dear_Claudio]

LOL.. You caught that did you.. Good job..:D

Aggie is a decent young talent.. Needs to be a little more disciplined in his position, but that will come..Ah, I always forget to provide a player (as you have done). I'll fill in, then.


Titus Bramble

[Footie4ever]

Ah, I always forget to provide a player (as you have done). I'll fill in, then.


Titus Bramble

Strong defender...needs to watch concentration-can be amazing. 7/10

Jimmy Bullard

[Dear_Claudio]

Strong defender...needs to watch concentration-can be amazing. 7/10Really? Because he is one of the worst defenders in the Premiership.

Jimmy BullardCrocked, was a huge fan before the move to Fulham and injury shortly thereafter.


Adel Taraabt

[Chelsea8-0Manu]

You forgot to add someone. I'll fill in.

Zheng Zhi

[Footie4ever]

Really? Because he is one of the worst defenders in the Premiership.

Crocked, was a huge fan before the move to Fulham and injury shortly thereafter.

I think he's having an off season, but overall is talented. Lack of focus hurts him though.

[Harry Boulton]

Really? Because he is one of the worst defenders in the Premiership.

He is. He's shocking. He shouldn't even be in the EPL. He's clumsy, his reading of the game is poor, his concentration is the stuff nightmares are made of, he's not a strong as he should be because his balance is so bad and his passing is casual and inaccurate.

There really is no hope for him. He lloked so good when he first came through but he just isn't up to it at this level.

Kevin Doyle.

[The Old Lady Hertha]

Zheng- great start, hope he uses this experience for the Asian Cup (if our coach lets him play in the right position for once)- 6/10 so far
Kevin Doyle- nice forward, but not exceptional at really anything besides finishing 7 /10

Tim Cahill