Season 5's American Idol: Katherine or Taylor?

[Goodsport]

So which of the two do you think it'll be... and why? :)

(And no, I didn't include a "Who cares?" option. If you're not interested in who wins, then simply don't participate in the poll. ;) )

GO SAN JOSE EARTHQUAKES!!! :cool:


-G

[bigdumbgod]

William Hung

[yalpstel]

I like the guy with the grey hair.

I haven't watched since about the time I posted this, but I guess we shall see if I am able to pick idols accurately. :D

Sheesh, I probably just jinxed him!

[JMichaels]

I like the guy with the grey hair.

http://www.chron.com/content/chronicle/special/yearend/99/photos/bill.jpg

???

[Bajoro]

Taylor will win because the voters of Richmond, Va. (Elliot's hometown and mine), will not vote for that slinky lapdancing hussy.

[sj_quakes_fan]

Taylor will win because the voters of Richmond, Va. (Elliot's hometown and mine), will not vote for that slinky lapdancing hussy.

:eek: You not falling for the slinky lapdancing hussy chick? Wow! ;)

Honestly, I just can't get behind either one. I don't care who wins. They're both going to get contracts. And I'm just not leaning one way or another. To be honest, when I read the song list, I said to my co-worker that Katharine would not win with those songs. But I'm also so sickened by the fish talking jealous females on the morning radio show thing. So I'd throw my support behind Katharine just for that reason. :p

[JMichaels]

:eek: You not falling for the slinky lapdancing hussy chick? Wow! ;)

Honestly, I just can't get behind either one.

All you have to do is sit down...and they will do the rest.

[sj_quakes_fan]

:eek: I don't know what's worse - the jealous female morning show audience or you boys!

:P

[yalpstel]

http://www.chron.com/content/chronicle/special/yearend/99/photos/bill.jpg

???

:eek: :eek:

[JMichaels]

:eek: :eek:

All you said was the grey haired one.

[sj_quakes_fan]

How did a thread about American Idol become one about Bill Clinton and slinky lapdancing hussies? :confused:



At least the slinky lapdancing hussy on Idol is much hotter than the slinky lapdancing hussy of the Clinton Administration Era. :D

[sonofapitch]

I'm thinking it'll be Taylor. He is just to enthusiastic and likable. While I haven't been watching it very closely this season (because I think the talent level has severely fallen off and I'm tired of the judges saying the same thing over and over,) I have been hearing from those that are Katherine "fans" that she has "been screwing up the past few weeks" and shouldn't have lasted longer than Chris or Elliot. Personally, I thought long ago that Mandisa would still be around at this point--though I was backing Chris to win it all.

...but at this point, I don't care that much.

[Sherman-Peabody]

Spartacus.

[JMichaels]

Spartacus.

Have you ever heard him sing?

[sj_quakes_fan]

To be honest, when I read the song list, I said to my co-worker that Katharine would not win with those songs.

I may have just been correct on this one.... I don't want to jinx anything, but Taylor deserves to win.

[DCSharksFC]

i'm going agains the jay leno look alike

slinky lapdancing hussy, who cares? she's hot

at least kelly clarkson sounds like she's making music

bill clinton: best president ever :D

[bigdumbgod]

Hottie gets the TV contract, dude gets singing contract. Paula gets ripped and incoherent...again.

[sj_quakes_fan]

Hottie gets the TV contract, dude gets singing contract. Paula gets ripped and incoherent...again.

Paula doesn't have to get ripped and incoherent. She just is ripped and incoherent.